Warning: Undefined array key "rbname" in /data/rantburg.com/www/rantburg/pgrecentorg.php on line 14
Hello !
Recent Appearances... Rantburg

India-Pakistan
Federal government seeks Governor Sindh's resignation
2015-06-06
[NATION.PK] The federal government has sought resignation from Sindh Governor Dr Ishratul Ebad Khan, local media quoting sources reported today.

According to reports, the government holds the stance that after the allegations by executed convict Saulat Mirza, it is unsuitable for Dr Ebad to remain the Sindh governor. Sources said, Dr Ebad has asked for one month to resign from his position. Dr Ebad has said that he is currently occupied with some private engagements and after the completion of some left over responsibilities, he will resign.

Sources said that the Federal government has also taken the Sindh government into confidence, over the decision. According to sources, high level consultations have begun for the appointment of a new Sindh governor.

Earlier, MQM had announced to disown Ebad and demanded him to step down.

On other hand, federal government is considering names of Mushahidullah, Ghos Ali Shah and Sardar Mumtaz Bhutto for its new representative in the province, while the Prime Minster would nominate final name in few days, sources added.
Link


India-Pakistan
Nuggets From The Urdu Press
2012-04-22
Pasha 'double game' expert
General Pasha of the ISI was very much in the news this week, for some reason..
Writing in Jang Hamid Mir stated that outgoing ISI chief General Ahmad Shuja Pasha was an expert at playing double game at whatever he did. He named 'national interest' every time he did something while promising to do something else. He adopted fair or foul means to achieve his ends but he failed in the end. Because the very constitution under which he had pledged his honour was betrayed by him. He considered the Constitution the biggest wall in the way of his objectives. He told journalists that presidential system instead of parliamentary system was good for Pakistain. He praised General Ayub and his governance and told journalists that they were condemned under the present to live as slaves the children of Zardari and children of Nawaz Sharif
... served two non-consecutive terms as prime minister, heads the Pakistain Moslem League (Nawaz). Noted for his spectacular corruption, the 1998 Pak nuclear test, border war with India, and for being tossed by General Musharraf...
. But he approached Zardari repeatedly for extensions in his job. He was the master of the Double Game.
 
Pasha and his extensions
Daily Jang had Hamid Mir writing that General Pasha as head of the ISI got items published implying that the PPP government would extend his tenure yet again, because General Kayani
... four star general, current Chief of Army Staff of the Mighty Pak Army. Kayani is the former Director General of ISI...
and the Americans liked him. He had met CIA chief General David Petraeus in Thailand and Britannia assuring him that NATO
...the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. A single organization with differing goals, equipment, language, doctrine, and organization....
supplies would resumed but at the same time he was giving the impression in Pakistain that he was opposed to the US because America was Pakistain's biggest enemy.
 
General Pasha and terrorists
According to Hamid Mir column in Jang ISI chief General Pasha stated in November 2008, right after the Mumbai attack, that Fazlullah and Baitullah Mehsud were the assets of Pakistain but in March 2009 the same bully boyz attacked the Sri Lankan team in Lahore, giving the lie to Pasha. Once he told Hamid Mir that relations with India would mend soon but after attack on the GHQ in 2009 he said that attack had come from India.
 
Pasha the jinxed ISI chief
Columnist Hamid Mir wrote in Jang that ISI chief General Pasha's era in power was a nightmare for Pakistain: May 2011, Osama was killed by the US in Abbottabad
... A pleasant city located only 30 convenient miles from Islamabad. The city is noted for its nice weather and good schools. It is the site of Pakistain's military academy, which was within comfortable walking distance of the residence of the late Osama bin Laden....
; May 2011 Mehran naval base was attacked in Bloody Karachi
...formerly the capital of Pakistain, now merely its most important port and financial center. It may be the largest city in the world, with a population of 18 million, most of whom hate each other and many of whom are armed and dangerous...
; after attack at Salala, drone attacks were resumed on his watch. In the four years under him the Baloch were made to disappear and largest number of journalists were killed in the conflict zones of Pakistain.
 
Pasha can't write
Award-winning columnist Haroon Rasheed wrote in Jang that when he met General Pasha of the ISI he asked him to write a book about himself to defend against the untrue comment being written in the press. Pasha replied that that he had no experience of writing and therefore could not write a book. He said that he was good at speaking: if you invite me to a two hour lecture I can prepare it in ten minutes.
 
General Zaheerul Islam will be the next Army Chief
Daily Jinnah reported that General Zaheerul Islam newly selected as ISI chief was bound to become the next Army Chief after General Kayani. The other reason was that General Zaheer was very close to Kayani. In the past Kayani first ran ISI then became Army Chief.
 
Zaid Zaman and murder of Maulana Jalalpuri
Banned magazine of Sipah Sahaba monthly Paigham Khatme Nubawwat wrote that Zaid Zaman was the continuation of the mission of False Prophet Yusuf who hid after the death of Yusuf then appeared on TV talking in such a way that people took him to be a proxy of ISI and Army, When Bloody Karachi's Maulana Saeed Jalalpuri became critical of him as the follower of Yusuf the False Prophet he was killed. An FIR was registered against Zaid but little was done to get hold of him. But ISPR and ISI have declared that they were not supporting him.
 
Fatwa against Zaid Hamid
Banned monthly Paigham Khatme Nabuwwat reported that Jamia Banuria had published a fatwa against Zaid Hamid saying that Yusuf the False Prophet had nominated Zaid as next in line. Zaid Zaman was made responsible for making the False Prophet leave Pakistain safely. False Prophet Yusuf nominated Zaid Hamid (then Zaman) of Brinks Company as his khalifa.
 
Roedad Khan will not appeal
Quoted in Express ex-civil servant stated that if the Supreme Court convicted him in Asghar Case known as Mehrangate he will not appeal the sentence. The case has him working together with President Ghulam Ishaq in a cell put in charge of planning the defeat in elections of the PPP.
 
Tehrik Insaf and its 'seasonal birds'
Daily Jinnah stated that Insaf Party of Imran Khan
... aka Taliban Khan, who ain't the sharpest bulb on the national tree...
was already a failing party because the opportunists (mausami pancchi) had either decamped or were fighting among themselves. This resulted in the party not being able to frame its constitution. People came late to the meeting in Islamabad and deputy chief Shah Mehmood Wormtongue Qureshi was absent.
 
Osama was buried in America!
Daily Jinnah reported that the dead body of the late Osama bin Laden
... who is now among the dear departed, though not among the dearest...
after his murder in Abbottabad was not thrown in the Indian Ocean but was transported secretly to the state of Maryland in the US to a military hospital and the body was taken in a special plane of the CIA.
 
Contest of apologies in Moslem League
Quoted in Jinnah PMLN leaders invited each other to apologise for wrongdoing. Nawaz Sharif asked Chaudhry Shujaat to apologise to the people for siding with General Musharraf. Chaudhry Shujaat asked Nawaz Sharif to apologise for being supported by General Zia.
 
Mubahila: discussion unto death
Reported in Nawa-e-Waqt a mubahila was arranged in Lahore against the Ahmadis for which the latter did not turn up, thus yielding victory to the truthful Sunni opponents. Mubahila is a discussion which some describe as a competition of curses in the name of God in which the false party dies of its own accord. Ex-president Rafeeq Tarar also attended. The speakers said that Mansoor Ijaz can't get away by reciting the kalima. The challenge is a call to prove the truth or falsehood of the Qadiani religion.
 
Regal Chowk should be Akbar Bugti Chowk
Writing in Jang that Punjab University held a discussion on Balochistan
...the Pak province bordering Kandahar and Uruzgun provinces in Afghanistan and Sistan Baluchistan in Iran. Its native Baloch propulation is being displaced by Pashtuns and Punjabis and they aren't happy about it...
in which the speakers were Oria Maqbool Jan and Suhail Warraich among others. Warraich said that media in 1971 was not alive therefore East Pakistain was lost but now it was alive therefore Balochistan would not be lost.
Truly impeccable logic. If only djinns were included, it could never be answered.
Hamid Mir suggested that Regal Chowk in Lahore should be renamed Akbar Bugti Chowk.
 
Mumtaz Bhutto to join PMLN
Reported in Nawa-e-Waqt Sindhi leader Mumtaz Bhutto stated that Tehrik-e-Insaf
...a political party in Pakistan. PTI was founded by former Pakistani cricket captain and philanthropist Imran Khan. The party's slogan is Justice, Humanity and Self Esteem, each of which is open to widely divergent interpretations....
had approached him but he had already decided to join the PMLN. He said that Imran Khan himself had made the approach and invited him to join his party but he excused himself because of prior commitment.
 
Raza Rabbani talks about his political creed
Quoted in Jinnah PPP leader Raza Rabbani stated that he found that Socialism was the only way of life for the states of the world. Socialism was the true revolution which the rightwing politicians wanted to destroy. He said third party employment (through contractors) was the worst form of employment and was exploitative. He said PPP would do its best to end this system.
Thank goodness the PPP's very best is never good enough.
Link


India-Pakistan
Nawaz asks govt to write letter to Swiss authorities
2012-02-14
The hyenas circle...
LAHORE: Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) chief Nawaz Sharif on Monday demanded the government write a letter to the Swiss authorities as required by the Supreme Court (SC) so that the people's money could be brought back.

Addressing a press conference along with Sindh National Front (SNF) chief Mumtaz Bhutto, he said the question of immunity does not concern the common people, adding that common man wants his hard-earned money brought back into the country. The PML-N leader wondered as to why Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani was shirking from writing the letter. He said the government had ridiculed the country in the world by not obeying the Supreme Court orders.

Nawaz said he stood by his stance over the memogate scandal and asked the government not to make hurdles in investigation process. Speaking on the occasion, Mumtaz Bhutto said that fair and transparent elections could not be expected from the rulers.
Link


India-Pakistan
Nuggets from the Urdu press
2011-11-27
Chaudhry Nisar against MFN to India
PMLN leader Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan was quoted by Nawa-e-Waqt that the intent of giving India the Most favoured Nation (MFN) status by Pakistan had aroused intense reservations in the breast of his party. His leader Nawaz Sharif had earlier favoured closer relations with India.
 
Hold on to Nazriya Pakistan!
Reported in Nawa-e-Waqt a number of speakers at a seminar including Qazi Husain Ahmad and Sardar Atique stated that if Pakistan did not want to be defeated by any power in the world it will have top hold on to Nazriya Pakistan (Pakistan Ideology). They said water war (abi jang) was worse than nuclear war (aytmi jang) referring to the stopping of Pakistani waters by India. Famous ISI ex-chief Hamid Gul made special appearance.
 
Jamaatud Dawa against MFN!
Quoted in Nawa-e-Waqt leader of Jamaatud Dawa Abdur Rehman Makki stated that giving the MFN status to India would put paid to Kashmir independence movement and will also destroy national security. He said Indian businessmen will actually be RAW agents who will strengthen the destructive network of CIA agent Raymond Davis in Pakistan. He said India never accepted independent Pakistan and that Hina Khar was an inexperienced foreign minister.
 
Fazlur Rehman rejects MFN!
Famous cleric of Pakistan sand JUI leader Maulana Fazlur Rehman told Jinnah that he was surprised by the pledge of Pakistan to grant MFN status to India. He said his Kashmir Committee was not taken into confidence. He said all parties should be united on Kashmir.
 
Strange conference to defend Pakistan
WPriting in Jinnah Khushnood Ali Khan stated that JUI's Maulana Samiul Haq organised an all-parties conference aimed at ending Saudi and Iranian differences in Pakistan. Not many turned up. Imran Khan too did not turn up. But Hafiz Saeed was the most revered person in the conference while Maulana Samiul Haq was acknowledged as merely the teacher of the mujahideen. Ex-ISI Brig Yusuf was there too as were ex-ISI chief Hamid Gul and politician Sheikh Rashid. The conference did not take off because of Samiul Haq's refusal to postpone it to after the funeral of Nusrat Bhutto.
 
A Musharraf-Imran government?
Famous editor Khushnood Ali Khan wrote in Jinnah that there was rumour that the powers that be will install a Musharraf-Imran Khan government in Pakistan in which Musharraf would specialise in collecting overseas aid plus money given by expat Pakistanis while Imran Khan will focus on ending corruption in Pakistan.
 
Why call the judges My Lord?
Reported in daily Pakistan lawyer AK Dogar had approached the Lahore High Court with a petition that it should be banned to address any judge in the judiciary as My Lord which was against the edicts of Islam and equated the judge with God. The High Court asked the federal and provincial governments to defend themselves on the practice of addressing the judges as My Lord.
 
America goes for oil in Arab Spring!
An intellectually gifted TV anchor and acknowledged genius wrote in Express that the US was after the oil of Libya but the people of Libya were willing to become the hired killers of the West against their own ruler. There will be no democracy in Tunis, Egypt and Libya but the oil of Libya will be out of Muslim hands. If there is no democracy in oil-less Tunis and Egypt how can there be democracy in oil-rich Libya?
 
Gadafi not so great
Writing in Express famous intellectual Oria Maqbul Jan stated that Gadafi was not so great after all. He was born in a Bedou home and went to a madrassa for a time before getting selected in the army. He also spent some time in London bust in very dubious activities, then went back to join Hizbut Tahrir. He later staged a coup as a colonel and became ruler of Libya surrounding himself with beautiful hired white nurses.
 
A new PPP?
Khushnood Ali Khan revealed the secret in Jinnah that on the 40 days (chaliswan) of Begum Nusrat Bhutto a new PPP would announce itself to counter the ruling PPP which will be headed by her daughter-in-law Ghinwa, followed by Mumtaz Bhutto, Dr Mubashir Hasan, Nahid Khan and Safdar Abbasi. Ghinwa fell out with Zardari on the question of starting the funeral march of Nusrat Bhutto from her house which is the house of Nusrat Bhutto's eldest son.
 
Libya war is Western plot!
Daily Express held a seminar in which famous speakers such as Prof Sajjad Nasir, Ambassador Javed Hussain and General Nishat came to the conclusion that the West had destroyed a Muslim state while Ambassador Khalid Mehmood insisted that Gadafi gave nothing valuable to his country in his 40 years rule.
 
Dr AQ Khan versus Imran Khan
Daily Pakistan quoted the father of the Pakistani nuclear bomb Dr AQ Khan as asking famous emerging leader Imran Khan to tell him what solution he had for the problems of Pakistan. He said it was Pakistan's misfortune that no one today was willing to take Pakistan out if its crises. (He was expecting to be 'made active' in politics.)
 
Hafiz Saeed rails against MFN
The strongest man of Pakistan Hafiz Saeed of banned Jamaatud Dawa told Jinnah that giving MFN status to India was like binding Pakistan hand and foot and throwing it in front of India. He said such plots should be abandoned forthwith. He said Bharat was not most favoured (pasandida) but most disliked (napasandida) country for all Pakistanis. He said rulers conspiring to buy electricity from India were Indian agents.
 
Gadafi invited Indira Gandhi
Daily Mashriq revealed that Gadafi was a most unpredictable person subject to changing moods and he was not consistent in policy-making. He once sent his wife to India to invite prime minister Indira Gandhi to Libya. He once handed over his embassy in New Delhi to Libyan students. India helped Libya greatly in the 1970s decade and Indira Gandhi visited Libya in 1984.
 
ISI paid renegade Karzai!
Famous columnist Hamid Mir wrote in Jang that President Karzai of Afghanistan studied in Simla University in India, then became a minister in the pre-Taliban Rabbani Government while he had contacts in Pakistan's ISI who also gave money (wazifa) to his father living in Quetta. After America invaded Afghanistan the ISI and CIA joined to send Karzai to Kabul through Quetta after CIA pledged that Karzai will defend the interests of Pakistan.
 
Judges get illegal concessions
Reported in Mashriq two retired judges ex-chief justice of the Lahore High Court Khwaja Sharif and ex-judge of the Supreme Court Khalil Ramday were living in official residences even after retirement and were using free concessions like oil and official cars in addition to residences. The Punjab government was getting ready to organise raids to stop the facilities of the two judges as well as a lot of other ex-employees who had retained their facilities.
Link


India-Pakistan
Nuggets from the Urdu press
2011-05-23
F-16s useless against drones

Federal Interior Minister Rehman Malik told Nawa-e-Waqt (18 April 2011) that even if Pakistan’s F-16 warplanes were made to fly 24 hours they could not bring down the US drones targeting people inside Pakistan’s frontier. But air force chief Rao Qamar contradicted him saying the Pak Air Force had the capability of bringing down the drones. Punjab law minister added that according to General Kayani the army could bring down the drones.

Bhutto and Mujib both killed by America!

Famous columnist Hamid Mir wrote in Jang (18 April 2011) that America killed Bhutto because he was going against America’s policy. When he mentioned the killing of Bhutto by America to American ambassador and scholar Ms Shaffer she asked for proof, on which Mir said Kissinger had threatened Bhutto publicly after Bhutto’s nuclear programme was discovered. About Mujib too he said that although the Bangladeshi army shot him, it was mastermind America who killed him.

Zardari’s father and Babar were Bhutto’s enemies

Veteran politician Mumtaz Bhutto told Jang (19 April 2011) that Hakim Ali Zardari – President Zardari’s father – and PPP’s Law Minister Babar Awan were both enemies of Bhutto once but opportunism attracted them to the party.

Get China to stop American drones!

Disgusted by loss of sovereignty of Pakistan, Punjab Chief Minister Shehbaz Sharif was quoted by Jinnah (18 April 2011) as saying as he left for a tour of China that all links with the US should be broken in favour of China who should help stop the drones.

Hizbut Tahrir wants khilafat instead of democracy

Banned organisation Hizbut Tahrir was reported by Jinnah (18 April 2011) holding a rally at Regal Chowk in Lahore where it called for the establishment of khilafat as against democracy which was against Islam. The rally was lathi-charged and water-cannoned by the police. Banned Hizb also held a similar rally in Peshawar.

Eunuchs become maulvi!


Reported in daily Express (19 April 2011) several eunuchs (khusra) of Lahore and Karachi expressed dissatisfaction with their careers as dancing transvestites and decided to become clerics instead. They stopped shaving hard and let their beards grow long after which they were greatly respected in society. In their photographs they looked like some famous religious politicians of Pakistan. They said they felt spiritually elated too.

Pakistan too important for America!


World famous strategist ex-ISI boss Hameed Gil told Express (17 April 2011) that after the drones crisis Pakistan had become even more important for America and therefore it should not be scared of Washington. PPP spokesperson Sharmila Farooqi said no one should stage a Long March against drones.

Amjad Islam Amjad defrauded

Daily Jinnah (20 April 2011) reported that some fraudsters in Karachi were informing people how they had come into possessing a car by lots only if they would remit money in an account before getting it. The fraudsters sent in pretty girls to the houses of the ‘lucky winners’ with flowers and sweets. After the money was remitted however the company giving out cars simply disappeared. The paper informed that famous Urdu poet and writer Amjad Islam Amjad was trapped like this and had lost his life’s savings.

Pak-Afghan talks useless!

Veteran politician Naseem Ahir told Jinnah (17 April 2011) that recent Pak-Afghan talks would be useless because they were mere American drama because both were taking orders from America. He said America was strong in Pakistan but back home it was very weak.

General Akhtar for blocking NATO supplies

General (Retd) Naseer Akhtar told Jinnah (17 April 2011) that if Pakistan wanted the drone attacks stopped it should block the NATO supply trucks going across Pakistan to Afghanistan. He said Pakistan should actually tell the Americans that it was going to block the supplies.

Americans turned terrorists

Daily Jinnah (20 April 2011) reported that there was a growing trend among Muslim immigrants in the US to turn extremist in their thinking and also to go to regions of crisis and take part in what they considered jihad against America. Young Umar went from the US to Somalia where he grew into a hardline Islamist. He was a Christian with a Muslim father and turned to Islam after leaving his mother’s religion. Adam Ghadan in California also converted to Islam and is now inside Al Qaeda. Pakistani Faisal Shahzad was an American who turned extremist and came to Pakistan to take training as a terrorist under Taliban leader Hakimullah Mehsud. Major Hasan Nidal an American army doctor is facing trial for murdering Americans in revenge.

Pakistan trying to control Afghanistan

PMLQ leader Gohar Ayub told Jinnah (17 April 2011) that Pakistan was trying to control events in Afghanistan after America decided to get out of there after NATO was unsuccessful to achieve its objectives. He said if Americans sent a sweeper to Pakistan the Pakistani rulers will start saluting him.

Judiciary should not destroy democracy

President of the Supreme Court Bar Council Asma Jahangir was quoted by Jinnah (14 April 2011) as saying that she was going to tell the judiciary that it should not sink democracy (baira na daboa jai). She said one judge was going to retire in two and a half weeks when he was confirmed which put a load on the treasury. She was addressing the Multan bar.

The smiling columnist


Famous columnist, who according to him smiles every time he rebuts the Americans, Hamid Mir wrote in Jang (14 April 2011) that once American officer Deputy Secretary of State Richard Boucher complained to him that he was unfairly accusing America of killing Bhutto. The columnist smiled attractively and replied that it was not an accusation but a fact. America had used military generals, religious parties and secular leaders like Asghar Khan. He gave reference of Irshad Tirmizi the ISI brigadier who had mentioned it in his book.

Use Mithaq-e-Madina type of order

Chief Minister Punjab Shahbaz Sharif was quoted in Jang (14 April 2011) as saying that to end terrorism some social order based on Mithaq-e-Madina should be brought about. He said Musharraf had brought the current terrorism on Pakistan. He was addressing the Rangers Headquarters.

Awan ate sweets after Bhutto’s death!

Son of General Zia, Ijazul Haq told Jang (14 April 2011) that PPP law minister Babar Awan was once linked to Jamaat Islami and General Zia and had demanded death to Bhutto when the latter was in jail. After Bhutto was killed Awan publicly ate sweets to celebrate his hanging. In daily Jinnah, Ijaz said that Awan used to raise slogans in his father’s name. When Babar was not given ticket by the PMLN he joined the PPP 15 years ago.

Gaddafi loved pretty nurses

Daily Nawa-e-Waqt (15 April 2011) reported that the beautiful Ukrainian nurse who was close to Gaddafi stated that the dictator was very fond of having pretty girls around him but he did not do anything improper with them.

Universities without vice chancellors


Reported in Nawa-e-Waqt (14 April 2011) 6 of the universities in the province of Punjab were functioning without vice-chancellors. This situation prevailed since two years. The education university has invited candidates for the post twice but because of torrents of sifarish from powerful people no appointment was made, rendering the universities dysfunctional.
Link


India-Pakistan
Mumtaz to be produced before court on July 17
2009-07-05
[Geo News] The local court has issued orders for the production of the Chairman Sindh National Front (SNF) Mumtaz Bhutto, accused of plotting attack on a Sindhi language newspaper, before court on July 17. The judicial magistrate, charging Mumtaz Bhutto and other accused persons involved in the case, has ordered them to appear before court on July 17. So far Mumtaz Bhutto was exempted from appearing before court but after the court has charged him with offensive, he and other accused will have to appear before court.
Link


India-Pakistan
Mumtaz Bhutto can't lodge FIR in BB's killing, says Sanam
2009-04-16
Sindh National Front (SNF) chief Mumtaz Bhutto has no right to file a first information report regarding Benazir Bhutto's assassination as he had always criticised her during her life, Benazir's younger sister Sanam Bhutto said on Wednesday. According to a private TV channel, Sanam said Mumtaz wanted to gain public sympathies in the name of Benazir, "but, he did not lend any help to Benazir during her five years in exile and did not do anything about her assassination". The channel said Sanam denounced Mumtaz as the chief of the Bhutto clan and also denied having differences with President Asif Ali Zardari. "The reports being published in the media in this regard have no substance," Sanam said. She said as Benazir had tended to her during her life, it was her (Sanam's) responsibility to take care of her children. Sanam said she had returned to Larkana to look after her property and meet the locals.
Link


India-Pakistan
You can't put on Pak blinkers
2008-01-06
By Swapan Dasgupta

The tragedy of Benazir Bhutto's assassination should not blind us to the farce that was enacted in Larkana a day after her funeral. For the first time in the annals of dynastic democracy in the subcontinent, the succession issue in a political party was settled on the strength of a Last Will and Testament which, unfortunately, the world will never get to read.

It is undeniable that the major political parties of the region, viz the Pakistan People's Party, Awami League, Sri Lanka Freedom Party and the Indian National Congress, have transformed themselves into proprietorial concerns. It is almost axiomatic that you have to be a Bhutto, a Nehru-Gandhi, a Bandaranaike or a descendant of Sheikh Mujib to secure the top job in these parties.

Earlier there was always the pretence that grassroots pressure and the overriding need for a unifying symbol had catapulted the inheritors into the top job. With the coronation of Bilawal I — there is no better description for his anointment as PPP chairman — political inheritance has lost its democratic pretensions. In death, Benazir turned it into a bequest.

The idea is not to mock the bewilderment of a 19-year-old who has had both his mother and the joys of youthful freedom cruelly snatched away from him. Nor does it behove anyone to wait expectantly for Chairman Bilawal I to come into his own, upstage the decrepit Regent and show that he is the true Bhutto. Bilawal's future has all the makings of a family melodrama, now that Mumtaz Bhutto and the daughter of the late Murtaza Bhutto have also staked their claim on the inheritance. Yet, life in Pakistan is too full of inglorious uncertainties to warrant speculative forward trading.

Indeed, the turmoil in Pakistan over the past fortnight should force liberal India to discard the blinkers with which it views the other side of the Radcliffe Line. Pakistan has shown itself to be a bizarre place, not merely on account of the itinerant suicide bombers who hop from place to place. It is the complete non-existence or breakdown of institutions that should worry Indians who believe "they" are like "us".

For a start, there are no elementary rules of forensic examination. There was no post-mortem examination carried out on Benazir's body because the husband piously declared he didn't want it. To say this is preposterous is a wild understatement; the wilful lapse has ensured that the cause of death will remain a matter of wild conjecture forever, unless the body is cruelly exhumed.

Second, in proffering the incredible theory that Benazir died after an accidental bump in the head — a claim contested by the indignant car manufacturer — the authorities have shown that in the game of cover-ups, brazenness is the rule. Despite photographic evidence of a smartly dressed man in sunglasses pointing a gun at Benazir, sundry military administrators have persisted in following a script that doesn't correspond to reality. That the Government had to call in investigators from Scotland Yard — who are unlikely to find anything because most of the evidence has been destroyed or removed — shows how little credibility the Pakistani state enjoys in the eyes of its own people. The revelation that Benazir planned to release a dossier of the ISI's rigging plans on behalf of the King's Party confirms the extent of the rot.

If these shenanigans were confined to the internal affairs of Pakistan, India could have looked the other way. Unfortunately, the state that presided over the murder of one of its foremost leaders and then tried to cover-up ineptly also happens to be the state that the world must deal with.

For too long, many have tried to make an expedient distinction between the "responsible" and "rogue" arms of the Pakistan State — A Q Khan being the proverbial rogue and Musharraf the modernist. This distinction is notional. We are now dealing with a criminal entity called Pakistan that possesses nuclear weapons and where jihad has entered the bloodstream.

The implications don't need to be spelt out explicitly.
Link


India-Pakistan
Bhutto tribe patriarch disputes party leadership succession
2008-01-02
MIR BHUTTO, Pakistan — The elevation of slain former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto's husband and teenaged son to replace her as leaders of Pakistan's largest opposition party is re-opening fissures that have divided the powerful political family for decades.

To Mumtaz Bhutto, the septuagenarian patriarch of the 700,000-strong Bhutto tribe, Asif Ali Zardari and his son, Bilawal, are interlopers. The leadership of the Pakistan Peoples Party, he said in an interview Tuesday, should have gone to "a real Bhutto."
Not one of them damn furriners ...
Mumtaz Bhutto's comments reflect the important roles that family, tribe and ethnicity continue to play in Pakistani politics 60 years after independence from British colonial rule, and one reason why democracy has failed to put down strong roots.

The Bhuttos are ethnic Sindhis. Zardari is from the Baluch ethnic group. His son carried Zardari as his last name until after his mother's assassination last week, when he added Bhutto as his middle name in what some experts saw correctly as a move to perpetuate the political dynasty.

Mumtaz Bhutto was a founding member of the party established by Benazir Bhutto's father, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, the country's first democratically elected prime minister, who was executed two years after being toppled in a 1977 military coup. "The party has come into existence on the name and the sweat and the blood of the Bhutto family," asserted Mumtaz, 74, who lives on a grand country estate in Mirpur Bhutto, the original family village in southern Sindh Province. "Therefore, the leadership should either have gone to Sanam or Murtaza's son or daughter."

Sanam, Benazir's sister, has never taken any active role in politics. Murtaza, Benazir's brother, saw himself as Zulfiqar Ali's true political heir, but he was gunned down in Karachi by police in 1996, leaving a daughter, Fatima, 25, and Zulfiqar Ali junior, 18.

After Benazir took over leadership of the party in 1984, she sacked Mumtaz in a family feud policy disagreement. Fatima and her stepmother Ghinwa have publicly accused Benazir and Asif Zardari of complicity in Murtaza's death, which remains unsolved — Benazir was prime minister at the time.

Benazir retorted that Murtaza was killed by people who wanted to "frame" her for his murder. Sanam always sided with Benazir and it is believed that her relations with Murtaza's children remain tense, even after Benazir's death.

"The Zardaris have made no sacrifices for the party, whereas the [Bhutto] family have made big sacrifices. The Zardaris have just profited from it," said Mumtaz.
Handsomely too, to about 1.5 billion dollars ...
"Whatever Mumtaz Bhutto is saying, he is saying out of spite for Benazir Bhutto, spite and frustration, because he is now out in the political wilderness," responded Farhattullah Babar, a PPP spokesman.

As Bilawal, 19, will continue his studies at Britain's Oxford University, the announcement Sunday that father and son will co-chair the PPP means that Zardari — who was jailed for seven years on corruption and murder charges that were never proved — is actually running the PPP for now. "This will split the party very badly. He [Zardari] has no political background or acumen. I think this will lead to break-up. Total disintegration," predicted Mumtaz Bhutto.

So far, the PPP has accepted the succession plan.

Sanam Bhutto also endorsed it. She said in a statement, "I believe that the resolution of the issue of leadership in accordance with (Benazir's) will has not only saved the party from a crisis of leadership but will also strengthen it further."

Fatima Bhutto, a graduate of Columbia University in New York, who was tipped as a future challenger for the party's leadership even when Benazir was alive, has so far made no claim to her grandfather's legacy. But in a local newspaper article, she admitted she never reconciled with Benazir. "I never agreed with her politics. I never did. I never agreed with those she kept around her, the political opportunists, hanger-ons, them. They repulse me. I never agreed with her version of events. Never. But in death, in death perhaps there is a moment to call for calm," she wrote.
Link


India-Pakistan
Nuggets from the Urdu press
2006-06-04
Prime minister and the stinking ladies
Famous historian Dr Safdar Mehmood wrote in Jang that Pakistan’s lady prime minister, after coming to power, ordered that she would go to offer umra with a planeload of her lady party loyalists. A big party landed in Saudi Arabia but when the ladies along with the prime minister were separated and made to pray in close proximity to each other in front of the mausoleum of the Prophet (pbuh) in Madina the prime minister called the protocol officer and told him to get her out of the place because ‘she could not stand the stink of the ladies.’

Palmist says Iran invasion is on
According to Khabrain Lahore’s famous palmist Majeed Salimi predicted that America will invade Iran in 2006 and that President Musharraf would remain safe. He said that the government will make a deal with the PPP and that there was ‘foreign hand’ involved in the Nishtar Park blast in Karachi. And that Nawaz Sharif will not return to Pakistan.

Dead men who stink
Humour columnist Ataul Haq Qasimi in Jang referred to a man who was recently reported as having announced his own death in Qasur. Daud son of Jani got onto a mosque loudspeaker and informed the people that he had died at the age of 45 and would be buried by one Mistri Feroz after namaz janaza. When people gathered outside the mosque the man fled after scaling the back wall of the mosque. Qasimi wondered that while a living man was announcing his death, those literary persons who had actually died in the brain were scared of announcing their deaths. They were actually cadavers of Urdu literature who had started stinking.

Murtaza feared Benazir will kill her!
Quoted by Sunday Express veteran politician Mumtaz Bhutto stated that Benazir Bhutto accused him of inviting Murtaza Bhutto back to Pakistan. He told her that he was in fact opposed to Murtaza coming back when she was in power but could not get him to agree not to return. She accused him of getting Murtaza back in Pakistan to make the brother fight his sister. Mumtaz said he had asked Murtaza to meet his sister but he said that she was too dangerous (khatarnak aurat) who would kill him if he went near her.

Proud son who stabbed German editor
Daily Pakistan reported in the following way the incident of a Pakistani boy stabbing the editor of Die Welt publication in Germany for printing objectionable material against the Holy Prophet (pbuh): the proud self-respecting son of Wazirabad paid the price of his enslavement to the Holy Prophet (pbuh) when he stabbed the German editor of Die Welt and was caught and sent to jail. He had gone to Germany for higher education and now Europeans were investigating his family background in Wazirabad.

Bad law against wedding meals
Columnist Nazeer Naji wrote in Jang that he was personally against spending heavily on weddings but the law against wedding meals was a bad law since it actually widened the gulf between the haves and the have-nots, forcing them to do illegal things and practice hypocrisy to avoid being nabbed by the police. On the other hand the police were tough on the poor but blind to the grand weddings of the rich. Also the law was against the economy.

Zardari killed Murtaza!
Daily Express magazine quoted Mumtaz Bhutto as saying that only Asif Zardari could have ordered the killing of Murtaza Bhutto. He was not killed in an encounter with the police; he was arrested and then taken to a predetermined place and shot dead. Benazir could kill her sister because she was a cruel woman who could drag her mother out of the house of her son and keep her like a prisoner in her old age. No one knew if Nusrat Bhutto was alive or not in the custody of her daughter.

Sherry can be ‘Sherni’
Sarerahe stated in Nawa-e-Waqt that everyone was changing their media managers. Ms Bhutto changed her appointee Taj Haider for Sherry Rehman who was Sherry but could become Sherni for the media. Nawaz Sharif had got rid of loud-mouthed Siddiqul Farooq for a more polished Ahsan Iqbal. Sheikh Rashid had lost his information portfolio because he had displeased both prime minister Shaukat Aziz and PML chief Chaudhry Shujaat – and perhaps also Punjab governor General Khalid Maqbul.

Our villain, their hero
Writing in Jang Javed Chaudhry stated that in 1971 a Pakistani pilot, Rashid Minhas, was about to take off in his fighter plane when his Bengali instructor Motiur Rehman jumped in and gave chloroform to him to make him unconscious. After that Motiur Rehman flew close to the ground to avoid the radar and tried to take the plane to India, but Rashid woke up and pulled the plane down and crashed it, thus ‘killing’ the instructor and ‘martyring’ himself. When Bangladesh prime minister Khalida Zia visited Pakistan this year she demanded the remains of Motiur Rehman as he was one of the seven recipients of Bangladesh’s highest bravery award. Rashid Minhas was posthumously given Pakistan’s highest bravery award.
Link


Afghanistan/South Asia
PPP politicians slam Mumtaz for accusing Zardari of Murtaza's murder
2004-12-12
Anna Comnena reports from Karachi...
PPP MNAs and MPAs criticised SNF Chairman Mumtaz Bhutto on Saturday for alleging that Asif Ali Zardari was involved in the killing of Murtaza Bhutto. Talking to reporters in Hyderabad on Friday, Mumtaz Bhutto claimed that Asif Zardari was involved in Murtaza Bhutto's killing on September 20, 1996.

In a joint statement, MNAs Fehmida Mirza and Nabil Gabol and MPAs Ayaz Soomro and Rafiq Engineer claimed that Mumtaz Bhutto was trying to get cheap media publicity by blaming Asif Zardari. " The people of Sindh cannot forget Mumtaz Bhutto's role since 1977 to date," they said. They claimed that Mumtaz Bhutto was confused, as he could not stomach Zardari's release on bail after eight years of imprisonment. They claimed that had Mumtaz Bhutto chosen to face jail instead of joining hands with General Ziaul Haq and the army, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto would not have been hanged. They claimed that the people of Sindh could not forget the anti-Bhutto role of Mumtaz Bhutto since General Zia's time to president Farooq Leghari's time. The PPP's MNAs and MPAs claimed that Mumtaz Bhutto's allegation was tantamount to contempt of court. "The inquiry tribunal headed by Justice Nasir Aslam Zahid had absolved Asif Zardari of Murtaza murder case."
Link



Warning: Undefined property: stdClass::$T in /data/rantburg.com/www/rantburg/pgrecentorg.php on line 132
-11 More