[LegalInsurrection] Wisconsin state court Judge Hannah Dugan was charged with helping an illegal alien Eduardo Flores-Ruiz evade ICE by directing him out a back exit from her courtroom.
We have covered the case extensively since the beginning.
She was convicted by a jury in federal court and awaits sentencing. Dugan filed post-verdict motions, including for a judgment of acquittal or alternatively a new trial
In an Order today federal court judge Lynn Adelman (a Clinton nominee) denied the motions, The judge rejected various legal arguments most of which already had been ruled upon in pre-trial motions (such as Judge Dugan’s supposed immunity):
After surveying the caselaw, I concluded that there is no general rule of criminal immunity for judges, nor was there a basis for granting immunity simply because some of the allegations in the indictment described conduct that could be considered “part of a judge’s job.” (R. 48 at 21.)….
As I had noted in denying defendant’s motion to dismiss, there was no basis for granting immunity simply because some of the allegations in the indictment describe conduct that could be considered part of a judge’s job. (R. 72 at 13.)
The judge found the evidence sufficient to support the verdict:
# StarringRoles($srow->id) ?>
|