Rantburg

Today's Front Page   View All of Fri 11/20/2026 View Thu 11/19/2026 View Wed 11/18/2026 View Tue 11/17/2026 View Mon 11/16/2026 View Sun 11/15/2026 View Sat 11/14/2026
2025-11-25 Home Front: Politix
Pentagon threatens to court-martial Democratic senator over 'refuse illegal orders' video
[FoxNews] The video could lead to his recall to active duty and possible court-martial under the Uniform Code of Military Justice, the Pentagon said

The Department of War announced Monday that it has opened a formal review into allegations of misconduct against Democratic Sen. Mark Kelly of Arizona over a video calling on service members to "refuse illegal orders."

The Pentagon said it may even call Kelly, a retired Navy captain, back to active duty to face court-martial proceedings or other administrative actions under the Uniform Code of Military Justice.

"This matter will be handled in compliance with military law, ensuring due process and impartiality," the department said, adding that further comments will be limited to protect the integrity of the proceedings.

The statement also underscored that military retirees remain subject to the UCMJ and reminded servicemembers that "orders are presumed to be lawful" and must be obeyed. The department cited federal statutes, including 18 U.S.C. § 2387, which prohibits attempts to undermine the loyalty, morale, or discipline of U.S. forces.

"The Department of War reminds all individuals that military retirees remain subject to the UCMJ for applicable offenses," the statement read. "A servicemember’s personal philosophy does not justify or excuse the disobedience of an otherwise lawful order."

Even though Kelly left active service years ago, the Pentagon could, if it determines his actions violated the code, bring him before a military court.

Such recalls are rare and typically reserved for serious criminal conduct, such as espionage, sexual assault, or fraud. Still, precedent exists. In United States v. Dinger (2018) and United States v. Larrabee (2020), military appellate courts reaffirmed that retirees receiving pay remain under the UCMJ’s jurisdiction and can be tried for offenses committed after retirement.

If the review concludes that Kelly’s comments constituted conduct "to the prejudice of good order and discipline" or a violation of U.S. code, which prohibits encouraging disloyalty or insubordination among the armed forces, he could face recall to active duty for a formal court-martial. Punishments under those statutes can include forfeiture of pay, confinement or dismissal from service — though such outcomes are extraordinarily rare for political figures.

Any proceedings would likely provoke a constitutional showdown over whether speech made in a political context can be subject to military law, even by a retired officer.

While many lawmakers have served in the armed forces — and several have remained in the reserves while in office — there is no historical record of a sitting U.S. senator or representative being recalled to active duty for disciplinary action.

Last week, Kelly and five other Democratic members of Congress posted a video directed at service members and intelligence officers stating: "Our laws are clear. You can refuse illegal orders."

Four of the other Democrats are former military, but not retired and therefore are not subject to the UCMJ, according to Sec. Pete Hegseth. Another, Sen. Elissa Slotkin, D-Mich., is a former CIA officer.

"The Department is reviewing his statements and actions, which were addressed directly to all troops while explicitly using his rank and service affiliation—lending the appearance of authority to his words," Hegseth said. "Kelly’s conduct brings discredit upon the armed forces and will be addressed appropriately."


# id) ?>
Posted by Skidmark 2025-11-25 00:00|| E-Mail|| Front Page|| [1873 views ]  Top

1 I'll kiss my own ass if that happens.
Posted by chris 2025-11-25 01:07||   2025-11-25 01:07|| Front Page Top

2 ^^ lol

Well, I'm still waiting on the results of Eric Holder's contempt of Congress charge.
Posted by DooDahMan 2025-11-25 04:04||   2025-11-25 04:04|| Front Page Top

3 Ruben Gallego warns military 'there will be consequences' going after congressmembers once Trump is gone
Posted by Skidmark 2025-11-25 05:50||   2025-11-25 05:50|| Front Page Top

4 Dems fine firing troops over Biden’s vax order but furious over Trump ‘treason’ talk, GOP vet says
Posted by Skidmark 2025-11-25 06:24||   2025-11-25 06:24|| Front Page Top

5 Can of worms. There is a lot involved here.
What is about to happen is a Article 32 investigation as to the facts at hand. Similar to grand jury investigations in the civilian environment.

What we know.

Mark Kelly is a 'retired' military officer.
Retired in the military is not the same as retired in the civilian world. A commissioned officer retains the commission, granted by Congress, and is subject to recall by the Secretary of the service. The 'retired pay' is something like half pay on the recall rolls.

Back during a 'zipper' epidemic and women's movement, Congress changed the law to allow retired officers to be recalled to active duty for UCMJ action.

The Constitution prohibits the holding of two federal offices at the same time. Which raises the question, did Mark Kelly suspend his retired pay when he took his political office? If he did not, then he placed himself as still subject to the UCMJ. (take the King's shilling, take the King's chances)
Posted by Procopius2k 2025-11-25 06:31||   2025-11-25 06:31|| Front Page Top

6 That's cute P2k. You really think anything is going to happen here?
Posted by chris 2025-11-25 07:40||   2025-11-25 07:40|| Front Page Top

7 Re #1 - old George Carlin joke about a dog licking himself: "If I could do that I'd never leave the house."
Posted by Mercutio 2025-11-25 09:29||   2025-11-25 09:29|| Front Page Top

8 At one level I would love to see all 6 tried and convicted of sedition. This came up last week and I posted that I thought a very good lawyer went over that statement before it went out and under the letter of the law there is nothing they can be charged with. Convicting someone under the spirit of the law is not a precedent I think we should set. It is the first step down a legal path we shouldn't take.
Posted by Chantry 2025-11-25 11:15||   2025-11-25 11:15|| Front Page Top

9 Convicting someone under the spirit of the law is not a precedent I think we should set.

IMO: they get their "precedents" from Stalin & Mao.
Posted by Grom the Affective 2025-11-25 11:36||   2025-11-25 11:36|| Front Page Top

10 @#9
I don't doubt it, but any legal precedent we set going after them can be used against us down the road. History so far strongly suggests there will be another Democratic President. Since Truman, no political party has held the Presidency for more than 3 terms.
Posted by Chantry 2025-11-25 11:53||   2025-11-25 11:53|| Front Page Top

11 ^Exactly my point - a D POTUS doesn't need your precedents! Don't believe me - ask J6 detainees.
Posted by Grom the Affective 2025-11-25 12:02||   2025-11-25 12:02|| Front Page Top

12 Agreed; create their own precedents. Arbitrarily changing property values to create a tax trap, fire sale on autopen declarations, judicial warfare..

Mark Kelly looks like Cosplay Bunnicula; can't be healthy.
Posted by swksvolFF 2025-11-25 20:35||   2025-11-25 20:35|| Front Page Top

Merry-Go-Blog










Paypal:
Google
Search WWW Search rantburg.com