Home Front: WoT | |||||
US appeals court tosses Hamdan conviction | |||||
2012-10-17 | |||||
![]()
If the government wanted to charge Hamdan with aiding and abetting terrorism or some other war crime that was sufficiently rooted in the international law of war at the time of Hamdans conduct, it should have done so, wrote Judge Brett Kavanaugh. All three judges on the case were appointed by Republican presidents. The war crime for which Hamdan was convicted was specified in the Military Commissions Act of 2006. The government suggests that at the time of Hamdans conduct from 1996 to 2001, material support for terrorism violated the law of war referenced in US law, said Kavanaugh, but we conclude otherwise. To date, the cases against seven prisoners under the military commission system in place at Guantanamo Bay military base in Cuba have involved material support for terrorism. In five of the cases, those charged pleaded guilty. Hamdan went to trial, as did Ali Hamza Al-Bahlul, who helped Al-Qaeda produce propaganda and handled media relations for Bin Laden. Bahlul was convicted in November 2008 of multiple counts of conspiracy, solicitation to commit murder and providing material support for terrorism, and is serving a life sentence at Guantanamo. It is highly likely that the result of this decision in Hamdan will be to vacate the convictions of Bahlul, said Hofstra University constitutional law professor Eric M. Freedman. Even the conspiracy and solicitation to commit murder counts are very probably headed toward reversal. Justice Department spokesman Dean Boyd said the department is reviewing the ruling. In 2006, Hamdans lawyers successfully challenged the system of military commissions set up by President George W. Bush. That resulted in congressional enactment of the Military Commissions Act under which Hamdan was eventually tried. A six-member military jury in 2008 cleared Hamdan of conspiracy while finding him guilty of material support for terrorism. The Center for Constitutional Rights, a private group
American Civil Liberties Union attorney Zachary Katznelson said the decision strikes the biggest blow yet against the legitimacy of the Guantanamo military commissions, which have for years now been trying people for a supposed war crime that in fact is not a war crime at all. Hamdan met Bin Laden in Afghanistan in 1996 and began working on his farm before winning a promotion as his driver. Defense lawyers say he only kept the job for the $200-a-month salary. But prosecutors alleged he was a personal driver and bodyguard of the Al-Qaeda leader. They say he transported weapons for the Taleban and helped Bin Laden escape US retribution following the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks. Hamdan was captured at a roadblock in Afghanistan in November 2001.
| |||||
Link |
Home Front: WoT | ||||||||||||
Gitmo closure hopes fade | ||||||||||||
2012-01-12 | ||||||||||||
![]()
"I wonder if the US government wants to keep us here forever," the 37-year-old Al-Nahdi wrote in a recent letter to his lawyers.
The 10th anniversary will be the subject of demonstrations in London and Washington. Prisoners at the US Navy base in Cuba plan to mark the day with sit-ins, banners and a refusal of meals, said Ramzi Kassem, a lawyer who represents seven inmates. "They would like to send a message that the prisoners of Guantanamo still reject the injustice of their imprisonment," said Kassem, a law professor at the City University of New York.
Today, Guantanamo holds 171 prisoners and it's an odd mix. Thirty-six await trial on war crimes charges, including the alleged mastermind of the Sept. 11 attacks. There are 46 in indefinite detention as men the US considers dangerous but who cannot be charged for lack of evidence or other reasons. The US wants to release 32 but hasn't, largely because of congressional restrictions, and 57 men from Yemen, like Al-Nahdi, aren't being charged but the government won't let them go because their country is unstable.
Few expected Guantanamo to reach this milestone. The prison, which occupies a portion of the 45-square-mile (115-square-kilometer) US base at the southeastern corner of Cuba, started as an impromptu place to hold men scooped up at the start of the Afghanistan war, a mix that turned out to range from hard-core Al-Qaeda members to hapless bystanders. Al-Nahdi seems to be in the middle. He was detained because he attended an Al-Qaeda-linked training camp in Afghanistan but he was not accused of any specific attacks on US forces. The military classified him as a "low level" mujahedeen who could be transferred out of Guantanamo, where he has been held since June 2002.
Zachary Katznelson, a lawyer for the American Civil Liberties Union, said Congress was more interested in scoring political points, and should listen to security experts. "We are not talking about releasing anyone who is dangerous. We're talking about releasing people who the intelligence and military communities have unanimously agreed should be released," Katznelson said.
With such a bleak legal landscape, Chandler and his co-counsel withdrew Al-Nahdi's appeal rather than face certain defeat. It's made for difficult meetings when the lawyers must explain why so many others, including prisoners who were convicted of war crimes, have been released. "He says: 'How come I can't go home? I've never been charged and I'm never going to be charged. And of course, I have no answer to those questions," Chandler said.
| ||||||||||||
Link |
Africa North | |
2 Algerians go missing after transfer from Guantanamo, rights group says | |
2008-07-15 | |
![]() Human Rights Watch said several Algerian detainees at Guantanamo have expressed fear of torture and called on the US to help ensure the two men - the first Algerians transferred to their home country from Guantanamo - are treated humanely. "What happens to these men is significant in figuring out what to do with the others,"
The Pentagon announced July 2 that Abdul Raham Houari and Mustafa Ahmed Hamlily had been transferred to Algeria, but the rights group says that country apparently has not confirmed the men's whereabouts. Their families and attorneys have not heard from them, the group said. Algeria's security forces have been accused of torturing terrorism suspects, the US State Department has noted in reports on human rights practices, citing international and local rights groups. Attorney Zachary Katznelson, of the British human rights group Reprieve, said he represents four Algerians at Guantanamo who have been cleared for release but worry they will risk mistreatment if returned home. | |
Link |
Home Front: WoT |
U.S. lawyer asks Pakistan to help free Gitmo inmate |
2008-06-03 |
An American lawyer pleaded on Monday for the Pakistan government to intervene on behalf of a prisoner being held at the U.S. detention centre at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba. Zachary Katznelson, a senior counsel for Reprieve, a charity that campaigns for prisoners facing injustice, made the plea on behalf of Saifullah Paracha, a 60-year-old Karachi-based businessman, who has been held in detention for almost 5 years. Suspected of having contacts with al Qaeda, Paracha was detained in Bangkok in July 2003 and taken to Bagram Airbase in Afghanistan, before being transferred to Guantanamo Bay in 2004. "High-level political intervention is the only hope for Mr. Paracha to receive justice," Katznelson told a news conference in Karachi. The lawyer said he had met Paracha several times at Guantanamo. "Mr Paracha, who is suffering from heart disease, is kept in a steel-made cell for 22 hours. Only two hours he is taken outside in a bigger cage. This is what the Americans call recreation for him," said Katznelson. Katznelson said Paracha's case has been pending in U.S. courts for more than three years because of delay in proceedings sought by U.S. authorities. |
Link |
Home Front: WoT | |||||
3 British Residents Leaving Guantanamo | |||||
2007-12-08 | |||||
![]()
A fourth British resident, Ethiopian national All five men had been granted refugee status, indefinite leave or exceptional leave to remain in Britain before they were detained, according to Britain's Foreign Office.
El-Banna was arrested by Gambian authorities in November 2002 and transferred to U.S. detention, according to Amnesty International. It said Deghayes and Aamer were captured in Pakistan in 2002. The group Reprieve claims Mohamed was held in Morocco for 18 months after being captured in April 2002 in Pakistan and he was later sent to Guantanamo. Amnesty International said the circumstances of Sameur's detention were not immediately clear.
| |||||
Link |
Israel-Palestine-Jordan |
Three Jordanians return from Guantanamo Bay prison |
2007-11-07 |
![]() The United States sent the three Jordanians from Guantanamo back to Jordan, said Katznelson, a senior counsel with the British-based rights group Reprieve. The whereabouts of the three, who had been kept in solitary confinement, was unknown but it was likely they were being held by Jordans intelligence services, the lawyer said. Jordanian rights groups and politicians have criticised the US authorities for their treatment of the inmates following allegations of torture and violation of religious rights during their detention. |
Link |
Home Front: WoT |
High court denies prisoner's efforts to stay at Guantanamo |
2007-08-11 |
I take it he's not a member of the Gitmo Poets Society... WASHINGTON (CNN) -- The Supreme Court refused to block the pending transfer of an accused terrorist held by the U.S. military, despite his fears of being tortured if he is sent back to his home country of Algeria. Tough darts, Ahmed. Get on the bus... Ahmed Belbacha has been incarcerated at the U.S. military prison in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, for five years. He has tried to keep himself detained because he said he fears being tortured by the Algerian government if he goes home. But..I thought...this is very confusing. The justices, in a one-sentence order, denied his emergency request for a stay to any pending release. Dear Ahmed, Screw. The Justices Six other Algerians also face release from the Guantanamo prison. The U.S. military has been under pressure to speed the process of evaluating the approximately 360 detainees and freeing those who are not considered dangerous. The Pentagon has said about 80 Guantanamo men are eligible for freedom and has been negotiating with their home countries to accept them. Pentagon and State Department officials have said they would not repatriate any prisoner to countries where they would "likely" be tortured. Good luck, boys. Don't forget to write when your hands heal up... There was no immediate reaction from Belbacha's attorney, Zachary Katznelson. This is, like, really embarrasing. They laugh at me down at the club. His lawyer said last week that despite the conditions of the prison, his client would prefer to stay if that were his only option. "He said to me, 'My cell is like a grave.' He lives in an all-steel cell. It's about 6 feet by 10 feet; say, the size of someone's bathroom," Katznelson said. Hmmmmm...sound's "cozy"... Belbacha said he is not an international terrorist. He said he was an accountant for the Algerian government and said Islamic radicals threatened his life in 1999. He said he fled to Britain to escape the radicals and worked as a waiter. How would you like that cooked...INFIDEL! He later traveled to Pakistan to attend a religious school, he said, and was turned over to U.S. forces in 2002 by men seeking bounty money for alleged terrorists. Ah, yes. "Religious school" in Pakistan. Funny how that always seem to show up in these sob stories. Belbacha is afraid the stigma of being a U.S. military prisoner would make him a victim of Algerian government interrogation and abuse, his lawyer said. "Now that he's been in Guantanamo, the Algerian government may come after him," Katznelson said. Too bad ya ain't a Saudi, kid. They'd pick you up at the airport in a limo... The Algerian Embassy in Washington and the State Department refused earlier requests to discuss the appeal and Belbacha's claims. Probably too busy planning his Welcome Home party. |
Link |
Home Front: WoT |
Guantanamo lawyers predict more suicides |
2007-04-30 |
![]() SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico (AP) - Lawyers envision more suicides and despair at Guantanamo Bay if the U.S. Justice Department succeeds in severely restricting access to detainees by defense attorneys, virtually the only contact inmates have with the outside world. The only people you have to talk to are lawyers. No wonder they're suicidal... The Justice Department has asked the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit to limit the number of lawyer visits allowed to three after an initial face-to-face meeting, to tighten censorship of mail from attorneys and to give the military more control over what they can discuss with detainees. Lawyers for detainees believe that if their visits are limited, detainee desperation will deepen and more will try to kill themselves. On June 10, 2006, two Saudi detainees and one Yemeni hanged themselves with sheets, the first and only suicides since the 2002 opening of the detention center that now holds about 380 inmates. Ya need another sheet there, Mahmoud? How about shoelaces? Ya need some shoelaces? "Belt looks a little tight there, Mahmoud, let's give you a longer belt." "Visits by lawyers are one of the few bright spot these men have," attorney Zachary Katznelson told The Associated Press from Guantanamo, where he is spending two weeks to meet with 18 client detainees. ...and lawyer boy wonders why they're suicidal? Clive Stafford Smith, an attorney for several Guantanamo detainees, said curtailing lawyer visits would likely lead more prisoners to attempt suicide. "The level of depression is soaring, I am afraid," he said over the weekend. Awwwwwww... Many detainees are kept in isolation in small cells with no natural light. With no prison sentence having been pronounced except for one Australian detainee the detainees do not know when they will get out, if ever. Many have been there for more than five years. Jeez, sounds like time for another hunger strike... Attorney Stephen Oleskey, who represents six Algerians, said more suicides are "a real risk" if the court restricts lawyer-client contacts. "I've seen firsthand the mental conditions of my clients deteriorate in isolation," Oleskey said from Boston. "And I think the impact of further restrictions would be dramatic." Ummmmmmm...so? ... and even if we'd release them, most of them have nowhere to go since their home countries don't want them ... Meanwhile, Katznelson sees the move to restrict attorney access as an attempt to seal the facility from critics. "If we cannot come in, the only news getting out of here will be the government's carefully crafted version," Katznelson said in an e-mail Saturday. Instead of our carefully crafted version... It is the attorneys, arriving at the base in southeast Cuba aboard military planes or tiny commuter flights, who provide the world with information about hunger strikes, solitary confinement and other details about the detainees. Journalists can visit but are barred by the military from interviewing detainees. The Red Cross, which occasionally visits, keeps its findings confidential. Here's an idea. Give their clients new roomates! Whaddya say counselors? All the access to 'em ya want, 24/7! Cheers the boys up! Whaddya say? A win-win for everybody! But military commanders at Guantanamo and the Justice Department view the lawyers with suspicion. Well can ya beat that? Navy Cmdr. Jeffrey Gordon, a Pentagon spokesman, told the AP the military has been giving broad lawyer access to many detainees even though they are accused of having al-Qaida or Taliban links and the United States is still at war. The mail system was "misused" to inform detainees about military operations in Iraq, activities of terrorist leaders, efforts in the war on terror, the Hezbollah attack on Israel and abuse at Abu Ghraib prison, the Justice Department said in this month's court filing. Hmmmm? Maybe grounds for disbarment? Barry M. Kamin, president of the New York City Bar, called the assertions "astonishing and disingenuous" in a letter to U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales. Lawyers for detainees also dismissed the claims, calling them a pretext to deprive detainees of proper legal representation. "There have been a lot of extreme statements made," said Oleskey, referring to U.S. government criticism of legal defense efforts. "I think it's unfortunate and it should stop." Lawyers lying? Preposterous, I tells ya! Preposterous! |
Link |
Home Front: WoT |
Guantanamo inmate nixes heart procedure |
2006-11-20 |
A 59-year-old Guantanamo Bay detainee has refused to have a required heart procedure at the U.S. military base in Cuba, one of his attorneys said Sunday. Saifullah A. Paracha, a Pakistani multimillionaire, will not agree to have a cardiac catheterization done at the base because he thinks its medical facilities and backups are inadequate, said Zachary Katznelson of the London-based human rights group Reprieve. "This is a completely new procedure for Guantanamo. Mr. Paracha very well might need open heart surgery, and that has never been done before at Guantanamo," Katznelson said. Paracha, who is accused of laundering money for al-Qaida and plotting to smuggle explosives into the United States, already has had one heart attack while in U.S. custody and has recently suffered chest pains, according to his lawyers. Cardiac catheterization is a diagnostic procedure used to detect blockages or other heart problems. A doctor inserts a thin plastic tube into an artery or vein in the arm or leg and pushes it into the chambers of the heart or into the coronary arteries to measure blood pressure within the heart and blood oxygen levels. Sometimes the procedure involves injecting a dye and using radiology to get images of any blockages. Treatment options for blockages can include anti-clotting drugs and balloon angioplasty to open the artery. Heart bypass surgery is often the preferred solution when there are many blockages. A motion filed by Paracha's legal team to block the medical procedure, which doctors have scheduled for this month, is expected to be heard Monday in a federal court in Washington. Government lawyers have asked the court to reject the motion. |
Link |
Home Front: WoT | ||||||
Lawyers Go to Court for Gitmo Detainee | ||||||
2006-09-19 | ||||||
![]() Shaker Aamer, a 37-year-old resident of Britain, was placed in isolated confinement Sept. 24, 2005, and has been beaten by guards, deprived of sleep and subjected to temperature extremes, according to the motion filed in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. However, Aamer has said he had contact with fellow prisoners as recently as the beginning of June, one of his lawyers, Zachary Katznelson, said in a declaration to the court in Washington. Neither lawyer could immediately be contacted to explain the apparently contradictory information.
Katznelson said that on June 9 - the day before three Guantanamo detainees committed suicide by hanging themselves in their cells - military police beat Aamer because he resisted providing a retina scan and fingerprints. ``They choked him,'' the lawyer said. ``They bent his nose repeatedly so hard to the side he thought it would break. ... They gouged his eyes. They held his eyes open and shined a mag-lite in them for minutes on end, generating intense heat. They bent his fingers until he screamed. When he screamed, they cut off his airway, then put a mask on him so he could not cry out.''
He discounted the allegation that Aamer was kept in solitary confinement. ``No detainee is in a situation where they do not have available human contact 24 hours a day,'' Byer said, but he declined to discuss whether Aamer has been kept apart from other detainees for a year.
Aamer claims he was working for a charity organization when he was captured in Afghanistan after the Sept. 11 attacks.
| ||||||
Link |