Home Front: WoT | ||||||||
Fair jury hard to find for | ||||||||
2009-03-16 | ||||||||
![]()
Although passions have subsided since the Sept. 11 attacks, experts say it will still be a challenge to find a jury that can fairly judge a Muslim defendant. "There is so much prejudice toward Muslims still," said Neil Vidmar, a Duke Law School professor who served as a defense jury expert in the case of former USF professor Sami Al-Arian, who was accused of leading a U.S. cell of the Palestinian Islamic Jihad.
Mohamed, also an Egyptian studying at USF, said he posted the YouTube video hoping it would help martyrs harm U.S. troops overseas. He pleaded guilty to helping terrorists and is serving 15 years in federal prison. Megahed has not been linked to the YouTube video, although prosecutors have said they want to show it at his trial. Merryday has said he will not allow that. Megahed's attorneys will fight to keep the specter of terrorism out of the courtroom and to keep jurors focused on deciding whether the trunk's contents meet the legal definition of explosives or destructive devices. Bolstered by the FBI report, the defense maintains the contents could not have exploded and, at worst, could have spewed smoke if ignited. In the portrait that has emerged from the defense, Megahed and Mohamed were college buddies on a road trip to visit beaches with homemade fireworks, or "sugar rockets," to celebrate Mohamed's birthday. The defense says they were stopped by racist deputies who saw Arabic letters on a book and concluded the men were terrorists. Megahed maintains he was unaware of Mohamed's terrorist support.
"I think the really interesting thing," Beck said, "is going to be how Judge Merryday necessarily controls ... the government's efforts to turn this into a quasi- or mini-terrorism case. | ||||||||
Link |
Home Front: WoT |
15 years for Ahmed Mohamed |
2008-12-19 |
![]() TAMPA - The YouTube video was on the Internet only a few days but was viewed nearly 800 times before the Web site operators saw it and took it down, prosecutors said. "There's no way to know how far it went, to whom and what they did with it," said Assistant U.S. Attorney Jay Hoffer. In the video, Ahmed Mohamed, then a student at the University of South Florida, showed how to modify a plastic toy car so it could be used to remotely set off a bomb. The idea, Mohamed has admitted, was to target "infidels," including American troops overseas, without "martyrs" having to sacrifice their lives. For that, Mohamed was sentenced today to 15 years in federal prison, the maximum allowed under the law for the charge he pleaded guilty to, providing material support to terrorists. The video was shown in court today, its first public display since Mohamed was arrested Aug. 4, 2007, in South Carolina, along with fellow student, Youssef Megahed, after deputies found what prosecutors say was explosive materials in the trunk of their car. Megahed, who has not been implicated in the Youtube video, is awaiting trial on charges of transporting explosives. Mohamed's attorneys argued there was no evidence that anyone ever viewed the video and took action as a result, that there were no identified victims of this crime. "I admit that the video was something that was not a wise idea," Mohamed said in a statement read by his attorney, Lyann Goudie, before he was sentenced. "I do apologize because I never intended to harm anybody in particular I am convinced that I have learned a lesson I am no more than a college guy." Pssssst...Ahmed. Big smile for the judge. Mohamed, 27, asked U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday to show leniency, to allow him to go on to lead a good life and one day have children. Mohamed, who is from Egypt, hung his head low as Merryday sentenced him. "I hear no contrition that I find convincing," the judge said. "His objective was to cause others to have the knowledge needed to do damage including death to persons in the service of the United States," the judge said. Defense attorneys portrayed Mohamed as leading an otherwise exemplary life. His background was so clean, said lawyer Linda Moreno, that he worked for American companies in Cairo, including Haliburton. Wouldn't that prove how...evil he is? "While it's a terrible video, and it's a horrible video, in the context of what's happening in the world and in the context of what's happening in the Middle East, I can ask the court to consider it from that point of view," Moreno said. We did. Fifteen years. Buh bye. Mohamed used USF equipment at night, when no one else was around, to upload the video onto the Web site, said Assistant U.S. Attorney Robert Monk, who said Mohamed "embraces a violent and extreme ideology" and "has a particular dislike of Americans." Monk said Mohamed has said, "Americans are pigs. Americans are easy to deceive. Americans are scum." Well... not that easy. Mohamed told an FBI agent, "You don't understand, you have made me a hero." He also said, "Americans are more stupid than pigs, and you cannot deny this." Might wanna learn to squeal like a pig, Ahmed. It'll make you popular with the stupid Americans who will be your new "friends". According to Monk, Mohamed said, "It is the wish of every Muslim to die at the hands of the invaders, and he will get credit for this when he dies." Don't worry. There's still a pretty good chance that wish could come true. Monk read from letters Mohamed wrote from jail to his parents and another person where he talked about the Muslim religion taking over the world. The defense asked for an eight-year sentence, saying Mohamed has been mistreated while in the Falkenberg Road Jail awaiting disposition of his case. They said he was tortured in Egypt when he was imprisoned for four months without charges for donating money to the Red Crescent. Geez, nobody likes this guy... Goudie appealed to the judge's sense of fairness. The defense attorney said her son is in the military and served two tours of duty in Iraq, during the initial invasion in 2003 and then in 2005 until September 2006. She said she told her son before he went, "Remember when you're putting on that uniform that you're representing the United States of America." She said she urged him not to "ever think it's proper to stoop down to anybody else's level. Remember that you're an American and that you're fair and you're just." I'll translate: I...got nuthin your honor. The judge concluded Mohamed was a true adherent of his extreme religious beliefs. Such a view, he said, is not changeable through rehabilitation. Trying to persuade someone to change that viewpoint wouldn't be considered rehabilitative, the judge said. "It would be apostasy." Heh heh heh. Looks like that one came back to bite you in the ass, Ahmed. |
Link |
Home Front: WoT |
Mohamed Lawyers Argue For Shorter Sentence |
2008-12-18 |
![]() Remember the "Fireworks Boys"? TAMPA - Defense attorneys for a 27-year-old Egyptian man who pleaded guilty to trying to help terrorists are asking a judge to sentence him to eight years in prison, not the 15-year-term being requested by prosecutors. Ahmed Mohamed, a former student at the University of South Florida, is scheduled to be sentenced Thursday by U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday for posting a video on the Web site YouTube in which he demonstrates how to use a remote-control toy to detonate a bomb. The purpose of the video, Mohamed has said, was to help "martyrs" who target U.S. forces overseas. In a sentencing memorandum, defense attorneys maintain Mohamed should be spared an excessively long prison sentence, partly because there is "no evidence that anyone actually used the information that he produced to harm any American or any other person. There is no evidence of any victims of this crime." Hmmmmmm. Too bad he copped that guilty plea. Kinda complicates things. Prosecutors, in a memo submitted to the court last month, maintained that Mohamed came to this country to gather information about explosives "to cause harm within this country." Mohamed was arrested, along with his friend, Youssef Megahed, last year in South Carolina after deputies there said they found explosives in the trunk of their car. Megahed is still awaiting trial on charges of illegally transporting explosives. Mohamed's attorneys, Linda Moreno and Lyann Goudie, also say in their memorandum that Mohamed has been subject to abuse while in jail pending prosecution. Mohamed has been repeatedly strip-searched and not allowed to cover himself, they write. "His cell has been routinely searched and property tossed in greater numbers than those of other inmates. When he has been returned to his cell, his personal belongings are often arranged in the form of a cross. His religion has been demeaned, with the guards taunting profanities at Allah, the Islamic word for God. His Koran was often thrown on the floor and his prayer sheets tossed in the toilet. Aw, geez. Not the Koran shit... When he attempted to pray during his rare recreation time, he was physically prevented from doing so and his privileges were terminated, including the elimination of recreation time altogether. He was repeatedly humiliated and disrespected. How do they know this? He told them. "This adverse treatment has caused him psychological harm and prompted defense counsel to assistance from the United States Attorney to relocate him to a more humane facility," the attorneys added. "As a result of such inhumane and debilitating treatment, counsel has observed Mr. Mohamed's physical health deteriorate. From the time of his arrest, to the first meeting with defense counsel, Mr. Mohamed had lost over 40 pounds. Mr. Mohamed had also been placed on suicide watch while housed at the local detention facility as a result of his noted depression." The prosecution memo says Mohamed has lashed out at corrections officials: "The coldest statement of this defendant and the most telling as to his hatred and disdain for the United States came in a hand-written letter which the defendant sent to a Hillsborough County jail deputy on April 1, 2008. In that letter, which he signed, the defendant 'congratulated' the jail deputy upon the fact that the Pentagon had recently announced the death of more than 4,000 U.S. troops in the Middle East." The defense attorneys argue that Mohamed will serve his federal prison sentence under harsh conditions. "Mr. Mohamed will face a stark existence with long term psychological effects," they write. "He will be kept in virtual isolation, 23 hours each day, and denied any meaningful contact with his family and the outside world, except an occasional visit with his lawyers. Correspondence by mail will be greatly restricted due to the government's administrative review procedures." Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm. Sounds like...prison. They maintain that such isolation has been documented to psychologically damage inmates. |
Link |
Home Front: WoT | |
Mohamed to plead guilty to providing support to terrorists | |
2008-06-14 | |
TAMPA -- Former University of South Florida student Ahmed Mohamed has agreed to plead guilty to a federal charge of providing material support to terrorists, according to an agreement filed in Tampa federal court today. Mohamed, 26, faces up to 15 years in prison. A sentencing date has not been set. "This plea agreement was at the request of our client after a very long and agonizing decision by both him and his family, and it was his decision to resolve this matter through this plea," said Linda Moreno, one of Mohamed's defense attorneys.
A federal grand jury in Tampa indicted both men for illegally transporting explosive material across state lines. Mohamed faced additional, more serious, charges that included accusations of violating his student visa by possessing a firearm, demonstrating how to make an explosive device through a YouTube video and providing material support to terrorists. Moreno said the plea agreement calls for those charges to be dismissed at the time of sentencing. Mohamed has been in custody since his arrest. | |
Link |
Home Front: WoT | ||||
Third Goose Creek Attack Suspect Arrested | ||||
2007-12-16 | ||||
![]()
Moussaoui is from Morocco and has been living in a campus residence hall and studying computer engineering, Gullette said. He was scheduled to be awarded his undergraduate degree Saturday. His parents arrived Wednesday from Morocco to attend his graduation. At today's hearing, they signed a $50,000 signature bond for his release. Moussaoui surrendered his passport and travel documents. The defendant was told he must vacate campus housing within two weeks of graduation. He must then find an apartment with a phone and begin serving house arrest and wear an ankle monitor. Until then, he must have daily phone contact with pretrial services. Moussaoui's attorney, Stephen Crawford, said the student was awakened this morning in his dorm room and arrested. His client was scheduled to take his last final exam at 1 p.m. today but will miss the class, he said. Crawford said the defendant comes from a prominent family of engineers and developers in Morocco. | ||||
Link |
Home Front: WoT | ||
Honest guys, they were only homemade bottle rockets. | ||
2007-12-03 | ||
Accused USF Student: Explosives Harmless TAMPA | A University of South Florida student charged with trying to aid terrorists said the explosives found in his possession were just fireworks that could only travel a few feet in the air, according to a court filing. Ahmed Mohamed, an Egyptian national, said he made the fireworks, called "sugar rockets," because it was cheaper than buying them at a roadside stand, the defense filing said.
Mohamed told investigators that he became interested in fireworks just before July 4 when he noticed their availability as part of the holiday celebrations, public defender Adam Allen wrote. Mohamed told authorities the devices "did not explode, but traveled a few feet into the air and would make smoke." Mohamed said he went to YouTube to learn how to make the sugar rockets, and had ignited them before his arrest. Allen filed a petition Friday for reconsideration of the decision by U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday to deny a separate trial. The trial is set for March. | ||
Link |
Home Front: WoT | ||||||
Judge Nixes Megahed Bail Bid | ||||||
2007-10-30 | ||||||
![]() Merryday wrote in a 25-page ruling that no conditions would stop Megahed if he "wants to blow something up or cause a disturbance. ... I am unwilling at the prospective cost of property damage, injury or death to assume he will not do so."
Megahed, 21, was arrested Aug. 4 in South Carolina along with fellow USF student Ahmed Mohamed, 26, after deputies found explosives in the trunk of the car in which the two men were riding, authorities said. Mohamed was driving the care, which was registered to Megahed's brother. Mohamed has waived his right to a bail hearing. Both defendants are Egyptian nationals. Megahed is a legal, permanent U.S. resident, and Mohamed has a student visa.
"The evidence fails to establish or even suggest any innocent or wholesome explanation for the events that led to Megahed's arrest," Merryday wrote. "Guns, explosives, fuses, canisters of gasoline, ammunition, welding equipment, GPS devices, all-night interstate drives to an unstated and indeterminate destination, stops to check gun prices and availability, and computers with a recent history of visits to sites that feature the advocates and the means of violence are not attributes that a disinterested but cautious observer associates with a safe and tranquil citizen of the community," the judge said. "Rather, a person about whom these attributes are discovered is a person whose means, motive and degree of determination are unknown and unpredictable and who is highly suspicious and threatening."
| ||||||
Link |
Home Front: WoT |
What was in the trunk |
2007-09-15 |
HT Michelle Malkin. Don't look like "fireworks" to me... TAMPA -- PVC pipe filled with homemade "low-grade explosive mixture'' and a videotape instruction for turning a remote-controlled toy car into a detonator were among the items found in the car driven by two University of South Florida students arrested in South Carolina and now facing federal explosives charges, according to a federal prosecutor. A judge set bail at $200,000 for one of the defendants, Youssef Megahed, but the government immediately appealed, which means Megahed will remain in custody. Earlier in the court hearing Friday, an assistant U.S attorney outlined the evidence confiscated from the car driven by Megahed and another suspended USF student -- describing a container and three pipes filled with a low-grade explosive mixture. The list also included a videotape that instructs viewers on how to convert a toy electric car into a detonator. Defendant Ahmed Mohamed has admitted making the tape, and in it he says he intended the instruction "to save one who wants to be a martyr for another battle,'' said federal prosecutor Jay Hoffer. Hoffer told a federal magistrate today that the government believed Youssef Megahed should be detained because he is a danger to the community and a flight risk. He itemized what South Carolina authorities found in the trunk of a car he and Mohamed were driving that concerned them. Those items included: three pieces of PVC piping that were filled with a mixture of potassium nitrate, Karo syrup and cat litter. Federal authorities called it a potassium nitrate low-grade explosive mixture, and said they also found more of that mixture in a separate container in the trunk. Additionally they found an electric drill, a box of .22 caliber bullets, a five gallon container filled with gasoline and 23 feet of safety fuse. FBI analysts said the explosive mixture met the definition for a low-grade explosive. Hoffer said many of the items had been purchased locally, in and around Tampa, by Mohamed. They also found a laptop computer in the men's car. On the laptop they found a 12-minute video on which a man shows how to turn a radio-controlled toy car into a remote-controlled detonator, Hoffer said. Jackpot... Mohamed admits that it is him in the video, although you cannot see his face, Hoffer said. In the video, Mohamed said that he was showing how to make such a device "to save one who wants to be a martyr for another battle,'' Hoffer said. Mohamed also makes reference to a toy boat in the video. The FBI seized a toy remote controlled boat in a box from Megahed's home. Megahed also purchased a .22 caliber rifle in mid-July. The FBI found it in a storage shed, Hoffer said. Hoffer also detailed for the judge why he believed Megahed is a flight risk. FBI agents saw, but did not seize, two Egyptian passports that appeared to belong to Megahed. Hoffer sad they both had pictures of Megahed, but one had a different family name. U.S. Magistrate Judge Elizabeth Jenkins asked why they didn't seize them, and Hoffer said the FBI made that decision because it was a consent search, and they didn't have a warrant. He also said Megahed was denied naturalization on in March 2006, because he too frequently traveled back to Egypt. Between 1998 and 2003, he spent more than 1,600 days in Egypt, he said. When authorities arrested him in South Carolina, he had a photocopy of an immigration green card, but no passport. Authorities said he also has traveled to Saudi Arabia, Nigeria and Canada, and that his family has substantial business ties in Egypt. On July 29th, the defendant and his brother went to Sears and got passport sized portraits made. Hoffer said the government saw no reason why they would have a need for these photos. If the defendant was able to return to Egypt while on bond, Hoffer said, the U.S. government would have a hard time getting him back to this country, because Egypt does not extradite its nationals."It may be very hard, if not impossible, to extradite him back to the Middle District of Florida,'' he said. Mohamed has waived his right to a detention hearing. Mohamed's attorney, Lionel Lofton, said he didn't believe his client would be allowed bail, so he thought there was no point in having the hearing today for Mohamed. "He has absolutely no ties to the United States or to this community," Lofton said. He also didn't think it was necessary to use the hearing to get more information about the evidence against his client. That's because he met with prosecutors on Thursday night to discuss the case. He declined to talk about his meeting with prosecutors, saying that he has not been formally retained by the Egyptian embassy, which is helping Mohamed find legal representation. It's unclear whether he will be retained. He is preparing a budget for this case to present to embassy officials. He said the case would be "extremely expensive." Yeah. Sounds like it. Heh heh heh... |
Link |