Hello !
Recent Appearances... Rantburg

Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
'The Stalin Affair': How Borders Were Drawn Along Former Russian Outskirts
2025-05-14
Direct Translation via Google Translate. Edited.
by Daniil Pelymov

[REGNUM] One hundred years ago, on May 13, 1925, the III All-Union Congress of Soviets unanimously decided to include two new republics into the Soviet Union - the Uzbek SSR and the Turkmen SSR. But this was not an expansion of borders.

Later, in 1939-1940, the number of union republics and the size of two of them expanded along with the state's borders (the annexation of Western Ukraine, Western Belarus, the Baltics and Bessarabia). But that was still a long way off.

And in 1925, there was talk of “redevelopment with the transfer of walls” within the recently established USSR. The Soviet government, on the orders of the ruling All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks), redrew the borders in the sands and oases of Turkestan.

This was done in fulfillment of Lenin’s principles of national policy, which were based on the right of nations to self-determination, including secession, as well as “indigenization,” that is, the implantation of the languages ​​of the titular peoples, and the creation (sometimes from scratch) of national elites.

Those who, against the backdrop of the war with the Basmachi, drew the administrative borders of the Central Asian republics, of course, did not predict that 65 years later the country would disintegrate along these borders. That the end of the 20th and beginning of the 21st century would be marked by new civil wars, uprisings (similar to the Andijan rebellion of 2005), the death and exodus of the “alien population” – the Russians.

And that “low-intensity conflicts” will regularly flare up on the borders of the former fraternal republics.

TO THE BORDERS OF THE 17TH CENTURY
At first glance, to understand the scale of national-territorial demarcation, it is enough to look at two maps of Soviet Central Asia.

Until 1925, the territory of the Russian Socialist Federative Soviet Republic (as the abbreviation RSFSR was then deciphered) extended to the borders with Persia and Afghanistan. Within the RSFSR were the Kirghiz (Kazakh) ASSR with its center in Orenburg and the Turkestan ASSR with its center in Tashkent.

Two people's Soviet republics were included in the territory of the Russian Federation: the Khorezm People's Soviet Republic, created on the site of the Khiva Khanate occupied by the Bolsheviks, and the Bukhara People's Soviet Republic, organized, accordingly, on the territory of the former Bukhara Emirate.

After the territorial demarcation, Orenburg was "withdrawn" from the Kazakh ASSR, whose capital moved to the city of Perovsk (renamed then to Kzyl-Orda, or - translated from Kazakh - Krasnoarmeysk). To the south of the Kazakh Autonomous Republic, two autonomous regions were allocated - Karakalpak and Kara-Kyrgyz. For now, part of the RSFSR.

Eleven years later, in 1936, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan went from being autonomous regions to full-fledged union republics, and the Russian border acquired its current form, roughly corresponding to the borders of the Russian kingdom in the first half of the 17th century.

But in order to appreciate the significance of this shift in the administrative boundaries of the union republics, it is necessary to briefly recall how Russia moved to the southeast from the end of the 16th to the beginning of the 20th century.

SEMEY AND PETROPAVL
In the last year of Ivan the Terrible's life, in 1584, several hundred Don and Lower Volga Cossacks marched east and occupied the lands of the Nogai Khans along the Yaik River. The history of the Yaik Cossack Host began from that moment. After the suppression of the Pugachev rebellion in 1775, the Yaik Host was renamed the Ural Host, and the military capital, Yaitsky Gorodok, founded in the same 1584, was named Uralsk. This city, which retained its historical name, is the oldest in the European part of independent Kazakhstan.

During the reign of Alexei Mikhailovich, in 1640, the merchant Guriy Nazaryev built a fort at the mouth of the Yaik River into the Caspian Sea - the city of Guryev that arose here bore this name until 1991. Now it is the regional center of Atyrau.

Under Peter the Great, in 1718, a detachment of the voivode Vasily Cheredov built the Semipalatnaya fortress in the southern Siberian steppe near the Irtysh, around which the city of Semipalatinsk (now Semey in Kazakhstan) arose. In those same years, in the same place, in the Irtysh region, the Cossacks built the Koryakovsky outpost, where a village of the same name would later arise, which in the 19th century became a city named Pavlodar.

In 1720, by decree of Peter I, the "capital" of Rudny Altai, the fortress of Ust-Kamenogorsk, was founded to strengthen the borders of the Russian state and explore gold veins in the upper reaches of the Irtysh. It is still known as the city of Ust-Kamenogorsk (now the center of the East Kazakhstan region).

Simultaneously with the advancement of the Russian Tsardom, and then the Russian Empire, into the steppe, there was also a counter movement.

In 1731, the Chingizid Abulkhair, khan of the Younger Zhuz (a Kazakh tribal union that roamed from the Southern Urals to the Syr Darya), asked for Russian citizenship, counting on help in the fight against the Dzungar Khanate. Abulkhair and the heads of 27 clans swore allegiance to Empress Anna Ioannovna on the Koran.

But even after this, the southeastern steppes remained permeable to raids on the Russian frontier by slave traders from three Central Asian states, fragments of Tamerlane’s empire – from Bukhara, Khiva and the Kokand Khanate.

Under Elizabeth Petrovna and Catherine the Great, fortified lines were built to protect against the nomadic Dzungars and Kyrgyz-Kaisaks of the Middle Zhuz: the Tobolsk-Ishim and Irtysh lines, from Tomsk and Omsk through Ust-Kamenogorsk to Semipalatinsk. A logical continuation were the defensive lines in the steppes near Orenburg, founded in 1730.

Note that in the first half of the 18th century, with a difference of 12 years, the empire founded two outposts with the same name - Petropavlovsk: on Kamchatka and on the bank of the Irtysh tributary, the Ishim River. In modern Kazakhstani documentation, this city is called Petropavl.

At the beginning of the 19th century, on the frontier from the lower reaches of the Yaik-Ural to Altai, on the lands of the Orenburg and Siberian Cossack troops, there were 46 fortresses and 96 redoubts. But the logic of history prompted the empire to move further south.

OUTRUN THE LION
In the early 1820s, the Kokand Khan carried out a devastating raid on the Kazakh nomad camps. At the same time, the ruler of the Middle Zhuz, Vali Khan, transferred his subjects under the protection of Russia. According to the "Charter on the Siberian Kirghiz" developed under Alexander I, the Kazakhs were introduced to Russian-style governance and legal proceedings. A little later, in 1830, the Cossack outpost of Akmolinsk appeared on the Ishim River, which, after changing many names, became the capital of Kazakhstan - Astana.

In 1839–1840, Russia organized its first campaign against Khiva, the center of the slave trade in Central Asia. Vasily Perovsky’s expedition was unsuccessful, but it was only the beginning of counterattacks in response to the raids.

It was no longer just a matter of protecting villages, peasant settlers and "peaceful foreigners" who had sworn allegiance to Russia, but also of the great game that had begun between two empires, the Russian and the British. The Chinese Qing Empire also laid claim to Central Asia, but its forces were incomparable with the might of the "bear" and the "lion".

The empire was forced to move further, relying on new southern outposts such as Lepsinsk (founded in 1846), the Perovsk fort (Kzyl-Orda) built in 1853, the Vernoye fortification built a year later (also known as the Cossack village of Vernaya, the city of Verny), and, finally, the southern capital of Kazakhstan, Alma-Ata.

In 1865, General Mikhail Chernyaev took Tashkent by storm, which became the main stronghold in the region. Cossacks of the new Semirechye army (with its center in Verny) and settlers from Central Russia rushed here. Thus, in 1868, peasants from the Penza, Samara, Voronezh and Tambov provinces founded the settlement of Pishpek (now the capital of Kyrgyzstan, Bishkek) near the Verny tract. Only later did the Sarts join the Great Russians - sedentary Turks from Tashkent and the centers of the Fergana Valley: Namangan, Kokand and others.

The imperial government abolished the remainder of the Kokand Khanate in 1876. In response to a series of uprisings, troops under the command of the "white general", the future hero of the Russo-Turkish War Mikhail Skobelev, entered the Khan's headquarters. The Russians began to develop the former Kokand lands much earlier. So much so that already in 1869 Mikhail Saltykov-Shchedrin could satirically describe the " Tashkent gentlemen " - officials in the newly annexed territories.

"WHO BUILDS SCHOOLS, BUILDS THE FUTURE"
Events in the Khanate of Khiva and the Emirate of Bukhara developed somewhat differently. In 1866, in the battles of Irdjai and Chapan-Ata, the troops of Adjutant General Konstantin Kaufman routed the army of the Emir of Bukhara, Muzaffar. Two years later, Samarkand was captured. In all cases, Russian soldiers released slaves. In 1868, the Emir of Bukhara concluded an agreement with Russia: the ruler of the faithful retained the throne, but Russia received the right to station garrisons and determine foreign policy. The territories from the Pamirs to the middle reaches of the Amu Darya were no longer in danger of becoming another pearl of the British crown.

A similar fate awaited the Khiva Khanate. After a quick campaign in 1873, Kaufman signed a treaty with Khan Seid Muhammad Rahim II : Khiva freed the slaves and transferred most of its possessions to Russian Turkestan.

In the late 1870s and early 1880s, it was time to "pacify" the warlike Turkmens (some of whom were vassals of Khiva). The port of Krasnovodsk on the Caspian Sea, now called Turkmenbashi, was founded in 1869 by the expedition of General and scientist-geographer Nikolai Stoletov. And since the 1880s, the border village of Askhabad has turned into a fast-growing city, the center of the Trans-Caspian region.

At the same time, "soft power" was taking root in the vassal states. "Whoever builds schools in Bukhara, builds the future" - so said the participant of the Central Asian campaigns, artist Vasily Vereshchagin.
Always.
At the end of the 19th century, with the demarcation of the borders in the Pamirs, the "Great Game" in Central Asia seemed to be won by Russia. According to the 1897 census, of the 7 million 746 thousand inhabitants of Turkestan (present-day Central and Southern Kazakhstan and Central Asia), 770 thousand were Russian-speaking - Great Russians, Little Russians, Belarusians, Poles and Germans.

By 1913, the settlers were cultivating the fields of Semirechye and Fergana, working in the mines of Rudny Altai and in the oil fields of the Ural-Embinsky region, and working on the Trans-Caspian, Semirechye, and Altai railways (the last two lines would serve as the basis for the Soviet Turksib). One of the elements of Pyotr Stolypin's agrarian reform was the project to resettle 100,000 peasants from the central provinces to Turkestan.

ANOTHER "BALKANS"
As for the indigenous population, the situation was almost as confusing as the infamous ethnic patchwork in the Balkans.

Under the rule of the rulers of Bukhara and Khiva and in Russian Turkestan lived the Turkic-speaking Uzbeks and "Kipchaks" (as the ruling class called themselves), Turkmens and Karakalpaks close to the Kazakhs. But in the same Bukhara and Samarkand lived many who spoke Persian and called themselves Tajiks. Often people who spoke different languages ​​settled in different quarters of the same city. This was the case, for example, in the settlement of Dushanbe-Kurgan, the current capital of Tajikistan.

The ethnonyms were not established either - the Kazakh zhuzes were called Kyrgyz and Kyrgyz-Kaisaks for a long time, and the modern Kyrgyz ethnic group was called Kara-Kirghiz. It was quite complicated with the above-mentioned Sarts, who simply spoke "Turkic", but often had Persian roots.

And this ethnic diversity, after the upheavals of the civil war and the “march of Soviet power,” had to be territorially demarcated.

According to a number of authors, the civil strife in Central Asia lasted not from 1918 to 1922, but from 1916 (a series of uprisings of the local population against mobilization for rear work, the Russian administration and settlers) until the suppression of organized Basmachi by the end of the 1930s.

The history of the civil war in Turkestan requires a detailed description. Let us just note that, for example, the Fergana Peasant Army under the command of Konstantin Monstrov, a migrant from Syzran, managed to fight for both the Reds and Kolchak's forces. Both times against the Basmachi, who were slaughtering settlers.

And the former leader of the Young Turks, Enver Pasha, who had moved to Turkestan, first acted on the side of the Red Army as an emissary of the People's Commissariat of Foreign Affairs of the RSFSR to combat the Basmachi, and soon as a kurbashi (general) of the Basmachi with the blessing of the Emir of Bukhara. But in all cases, this nationalist pan-Turkist acted against the settlers. "Things are going the way I wanted... Many Russians were killed," Enver reported in 1921.

"THERE WAS A FIERCE STRUGGLE"
Despite all the confusion “on the ground,” the Soviet government steadfastly followed the general line formulated in Vladimir Lenin’s letter to the communists of Turkestan in November 1919: “Make every effort to prove… the sincerity of our desire to eradicate all traces of Great Russian imperialism.”

As in other outskirts of the former empire, the party in the 1920s relied on the nationally minded intelligentsia. In the case of Bukhara and Khiva, this was the left wing of the Jadids (“enlighteners,” nationalists, and Islamic modernists), who, in particular, proposed using the original Turkic ethnonym “Uzbek” instead of the word of unclear origin “Sart.”

In 1920, under the supervision of Mikhail Frunze and his troops, "revolutions" took place in the multi-ethnic Bukhara and Khiva. But the overthrow of the emir and khan and the creation of republics under flags with a crescent, star, sickle and hammer were only an interim solution. Then it was time for "national building".

As Vyacheslav Molotov recalled at the end of his life, the implementation of Lenin’s national policy in Central Asia was entirely the merit of the General Secretary of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks) Joseph Stalin, as a great specialist in nationality affairs (and the People’s Commissar for the field in 1917–1923).

"The creation of the Central Asian republics and the border was entirely Stalin's work. There was a fierce struggle. The Kazakhs, for example, their top brass, fought for Tashkent, wanted it to be their capital... Stalin gathered them... looked at the borders and said: Tashkent to the Uzbeks, and Verny, Alma-Ata to the Kazakhs," Molotov said. An equally difficult task was how to divide the Khorezm oasis between the new national states, the Uzbek and Turkmen SSRs. Or how to divide the Fergana Valley between Uzbekistan and the Kara-Kyrgyz Autonomous Region, still part of the Russian Federal Republic.

However, as recent history has shown, the “filigree” of national borders with enclaves and semi-enclaves did not protect against ethnic cleansing (for example, the massacre in Osh, Kyrgyzstan, in 1990) or border conflicts in the 2020s.

The fact that the city of Skobelev (Fergana) should go to Uzbekistan, Krasnovodsk to Turkmenistan, and Przhevalsk (modern name Karakol) to Kyrgyzstan, did not raise any questions in 1925. It is also not surprising that, in fulfillment of the “desire to eradicate traces of Great Russian chauvinism,” the Kazakh ASSR with its capital in Orenburg included cities of the former Ural, Omsk and Semipalatinsk regions of the Russian Empire.

As is known, in the discussions of 1922 on the principles of creating the Soviet state, "People's Commissariat of Nationalities" Stalin defended the plan of autonomization. National formations were to become a garland of autonomies around the Russian SFSR without the right to secede.

But - again, as is well known - in Moscow in 1922, the Leninist approach of creating equal Soviet states (as the core of the communist " United States of the World ") with the right of each national republic to secession prevailed. Stalin accepted this principle and continued to adhere to it in the 1930s and 1940s, when creating new SSRs - Kazakh, Kirghiz, Tajik and others.

The Central Asian countries that emerged in 1991 within the administrative borders drawn in 1925 have emerged as national states with which modern Russia maintains friendly and, in some cases, allied relations. But for the fact that in the 1990s Russians and other “non-titular peoples” who had lived here for generations found themselves in the position of unwanted migrants, one cannot help but say “thank you” to the creators of Lenin’s national policy.

Link


India-Pakistan
Pakistan Reverses 911 Appeasement
2008-09-14
By Ahmed Quraishi

I think Pakistain may be in the process of making the decision to actually go to war with the United States. The jihadi bloc within the officially jihadi state was actually being held in check by Perv -- even as he tried to accomodate them. Balochistan outside the border marches and Sind outside of Karachi don't much count. The balance of power's shifted to the Punjabis and the Pashtuns the Punjabis think they're using as tools.

Entering a state of war with the U.S. will have one immediate effect: it will cut our supply lines to Afghanistan. Recall that country's surrounded by states that are either hostile to us -- Iran -- or whom we haven't been cultivating as we should have for the past seven years: Turkmenistan (post-Turkmenbashi), Uzbekistan (we're so fastidious about Karimov's authoritarian tendencies), and Tadjikistan (we have to get through the other two or the Soviet Union Russia to get there). Without Pakistain as an "ally" we'll have to either fight our way through or negotiate a new Central Asian deal in 24 hours or less.

Short-term, the prospects are grim for us, especially since Pakistain in probably the nation most likely to use nuclear weapons on the face of the earth, to include North Korea.

Longer-term, the prospects are horrible for Pakistain as a nation. Use of nukes will make their current pariah state seem benign. The Mighty Pak Army has never won a war, as I keep reminding anyone who'll listen. If they manage to restrain themselves from using nukes they may be allowed to remain as a state -- known as a perfidious would-be great power, useful only as a pawn from short-term tactical advantage on the international state but never to be trusted. If they do use nuclear weapons the only way they'll stay in business is if India or (post-ayataollah) Iran don't want the remnants of what we'll shatter in the course of a couple weeks.

What of Pashtunistan, Graveyard of Armies? Pashtun jihad thrives from hideouts. Without the hideouts the jihad will die as beturbanned savages waving small arms and rolling their eyes are targeted by modern weaponry. With nowhere to run, they must stand and die. It doesn't matter if they fight or not. The only way to save their miserable, ignorant lives will be to cease being beturbanned savages, to throw away the guns and willingly join the civilized world.
One telephone call seven years ago was enough for Islamabad to accommodate Washington's entire wish list. But United States pressure tactics will not work now. Pakistan's army chief, General Ashfaq Parvez Kayani, is leading a military and a nation that is determined to resist Washington's plan to bring to Pakistan Iraq and Afghanistan. the ethno-civil wars of Pakistani military's brisk response is not just a reaction to the deliberately humiliating and outrageous unilateral American decisions to include Pakistan in the Iraq/Afghanistan war theater.

There is a bigger problem here. Pakistani policy analysts are convinced that United States has been a duplicitous ally during the past seven years, using the sincere Pakistani cooperation on Afghanistan to gradually turn that country into a military base to launch a sophisticated psychological, intelligence and military campaign to destabilize Pakistan itself.

The objective is to weaken the control of the Pakistani military over geographical Pakistan and ignite an ethnic and sectarian civil war leading to changing the status of Balochistan and NWFP, possibly even facilitate the break up of both provinces from the Pakistani federation.

The defeatist stance of Pakistan's elected government in the face of U.S. belligerence is discussed later in this paper. But it is worth noting that President Zardari has refused to publicly back the military's warning to U.S. He also delayed his China visit to go to London to hunker down with Gordon Brown. Meanwhile, Prime Minister Yousaf Reza Gilani, in a statement that deprives Pakistan of strategic advantage and dampens the psychological effect of army chief's warning, has said that 'Pakistan can't wage war with U.S.' In comparison, the governor of NWFP, Mr. Owais Ghani, has become the only government official to publicly state the truth.

On Sept. 12, the governor's office issued the following statement: "Foreign forces based in Afghanistan and militants [inside Pakistan] are working on the same anti-Pakistan agenda and both are following the same strategy to weaken the country [...] while the coalition troops were threatening to extend their war to Pakistan, the militants are also attacking the country and creating a war-like situation. It appeared that both the forces were working on the same agenda to weaken Pakistan."

In one sign of the grand double game, despite the poor relations with Iran, Washington has encouraged Karzai and the Indians to complete the construction of a road that links Afghanistan to an Indian-built Iranian seaport. The purpose is to end the dependence of both U.S. army and the Karzai regime on Pakistan for access to sea. U.S. military officials have also been seeking permission to use Russian air space for military cargo to replace Pakistani facilities.

These American actions show a degree of long term planning and are not connected to the recent American grievances against Pakistan and its intelligence agencies.

A segment of the U.S. policy establishment had decided to take the war to Pakistan from the outset in 2001. Washington first used Islamabad to occupy Afghanistan and then used the Afghan soil to start series of insurgencies inside Pakistan. The strategy was an alternative to a direct confrontation with a nuclear-armed country. A weak Pakistani state with a neutered military was envisaged as an ideal situation to protect U.S. interests with regards to China, Russia and India.

It is not clear how much the rest of the departments of the U.S. government knew about the destabilization plans for Pakistan. If the entire U.S. political and military strategy on Pakistan since Sept. 11, 2001 was based on consensus, then Pakistanis have been massively deceived by their American allies.

The anti-Pakistan lobby in Washington found willing allies in the Indians and the Northern AllianceKabul. component of the Karzai regime in

The idea to destabilize Pakistan appears to have started with simple and clear thoughts. The U.S.- and India-backed Kabul regime proposed reviving Pashtun nationalism and the secession of Pashtun regions from Pakistan. The Indians offered their decades-old experience in penetrating Pakistani territories for espionage. The Indians offered something else too: The revival of the so-called Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA). The Soviets and Indians together created this terrorist organization in the 1970s and used Afghan soil to foment an ethnic-based civil war inside Pakistan. The idea died out naturally, until the Indians offered the Americans to revive it after 9/11 as a punishment for Pakistan.

Pakistan's tribal belt, Balochistan and Swat were peaceful until early 2005. Since then, series of insurgencies have erupted led by shady ethno-religious characters. One of them, a tribal thug who stayed in American and Karzai custody for several years, was released only to enter Pakistan and begin targeting Chinese citizens in the country. Another thug in Balochistan was convinced by handlers in Afghanistan that he would be made the head of an independent Balochistan with U.S. help if he agreed to launch an insurgency and help recruit young Pakistanis to get training to fight their own country.

Between 2005 and now, the entire western Pakistan from the Arabian Sea to the border with China has turned into a cocktail of ethnic and religious insurgencies focused on fighting the Pakistani state and the Pakistani military.

On July 12, 2008, when U.S. Chairman Joint Chiefs of Staff Adm. Mike Mullen and CIA Deputy Director Stephen R. Kappes were in Rawalpindi on a secret visit, Gen. Kayani, former President Musharraf and Pakistani intelligence officials confronted the American duo with conclusive evidence that showed U.S. complicity in feeding and sustaining a terrorist movement in Balochistan, where China is building a strategic seaport.

Pakistanis now also have damning evidence that shows that Karzai's security apparatus, which is heavily infested with Indian security and intelligence advisers, has been directly supplying weapons and money to clusters of thugs masquerading as 'Pakistani Taliban'.

The main assignment for these fake 'Taliban' is to target and kill Pakistanis -- military and civilians -- and kidnap Chinese citizens in Pakistan. Which is surprising because the Afghan Taliban, the real Taliban, are focused on targeting U.S. occupation forces in Afghanistan and not on spreading fear and chaos among Pakistanis. This is more like someone is trying to punish Pakistan through a planned effort.

In the latest incidents, over 25 worshippers perished when unknown terrorists lobbed hand grenades inside a mosque in northern Pakistan. The real Taliban would never indulge in such senseless violence targeting Pakistani citizens. Moreover, two Chinese engineers have been kidnapped. It is strange that the Chinese are the only foreigners being targeted in Pakistan, while citizens of United States and other NATO member countries are spared.

Even if U.S. officials deny that parts of the U.S. government are privy to this destabilization effort, there is no question that the U.S. military is inexplicably ignoring the Karzai-Indian export of terrorism into Pakistan.

The U.S. role is certainly suspicious. Starting in early 2007, the U.S. media unleashed an organized demonization campaign against Pakistan that was unprecedented in the history of Pak-U.S. relations. U.S.Pakistan and spread 'anti-Pakistanism' globally. media made a concerted effort to create world hostility against

Besides India, the United States is the only other country in the world busy in this deliberate creation of hostility against Pakistan. Take the example of this quote from an article that appeared in the conservative, pro-Bush magazine, The Weekly Standard, in Nov. 2007:

"A large number of ISI agents ... should be thrown in jail or killed. What I think we should do in Pakistan is a parallel version of what Iran has run against us in Iraq: giving money [and] empowering [anti-state] actors. Some of this will involve working with some shady characters."

On Feb. 1, 2008, New York Times, published an op-ed piece that discussed in detail the division of PakistanNYT is the same paper that allowed itself to be used by Bush administration spin masters to promote fake stories about WMD and Iraq before U.S. invaded that country. Pakistan's ace diplomat, Mr. Munir Akram, who has recently been removed by the Zardari government from his job as Pakistan's envoy to the U.N., saw the NYT article and sent a letter to the paper's editor, although it was not his job to do so but the responsibility of the press attaché in the Pakistan Embassy in Washington. into three independent states. The article was an example of malicious fear-mongering but the real surprise was that a prestigious paper carried it.

Mr. Akram wrote: "will confirm the belief of many Pakistanis that there is an international conspiracy to destabilize and disintegrate Pakistan [...] The orchestrated campaign against President Pervez Musharraf, the denigration of the Pakistani Army, calls for the capture of Pakistan's nuclear assets, the string of suicide bombings and terrorism in Balochistan are all seen as aimed at this malevolent design."

This American media campaign against Pakistan continues unabated. Last month, Mr. Harlan Ullman, a Washington columnist with strong ties to U.S. military, visited Islamabad and returned to float this stunning idea: "Pakistan should create integrated and joint operations centers at ISI or Army GHQ with U.S. military, State Department, law enforcement and intelligence officers in residence."

This U.S. media campaign has been going hand in glove for the past eighteen months with a wave of terrorism inside Pakistan targeting Pakistani civilians and government. The blame for these acts was laid at the doors of something called 'Pakistani Taliban' which is, in major part, a creation of Indian and Karzai intelligence setups inside Afghanistan.

It is highly suspicious that U.S. military attacks inside Pakistan in recent weeks have targeted pro-Pakistan tribesmen. Somehow the U.S. drones and spy satellites are unable to target the shady rebel leaders who are exclusively fighting Pakistan and never attack U.S. soldiers across the border.

Also, the American war strategy neatly fits in with the secessionist campaign that seeks to turn Pakistani Pashtuns against their own country. With every U.S. attack that kills women and children, Pakistani Pashtun are becoming convinced that their country, Pakistan, is either unwilling or incapable of defending its citizens. The military operations conducted by Pakistani military to kill these shadowy terrorists are indirectly sending the message that Islamabad is also party to spilling Pashtun blood. All of this is strengthening the case of those who are promoting a secessionist propaganda that the NWFP and the Pashtun areas must secede from Pakistan.

This is the first time in decades that the idea of Pashtuns, the real liberators of Azad Kashmir, turning against Pakistan is appearing to be a possibility. There is no question that Pakistan' military waited for a cue from the country's elected leadership to respond to U.S. violations of Pakistani territory.

On Sept. 6, marked as Pakistan Defense Day in memory of a failed Indian invasion of Pakistan in 1965, the Pakistani air force chief tried to send a message to the elected government. He told reporters that the Pakistani air force was ready to respond if the government made a policy decision.

The Zardari-Gilani government chose to ignore U.S. attacks. In fact, the defense minister, Mr. Ahmed Mukhtar, made statements on multiple occasions that raised eyebrows. At one point he said U.S. drones flew too high for Pakistani military to respond. At another point he justified U.S. attacks inside Pakistan by saying 'there must be a reason' for Washington to violate the border.

Then came Hamid Karzai to plant a misleading story in the Pakistani media when President Zardari invited him to his oath-taking ceremony on Sept. 9. After his arrival, Karzai called some journalists and leaked to them that Arabs were killed in the Sept. 8 U.S. attack on the house of the veteran Afghan commander Jalaluddin Haqqani in Miramshah.

This was a perfect justification for the violation of Pakistani territory and it helped the Americans tell their reluctant European allies that attacking Pakistan was justified. Karzai leaked the information, complete with names and numbers of the dead Arabs.

The sinister part of this exercise was that 'sources close to the Haqqani family' were cited to confirm the report. Major Pakistani news organizations picked up the story and made it their lead for several hours. This was the height of cynicism. The Haqqani family was in mourning, with several members of the family, women and children dead while a disinformation campaign was using their name to confirm the existence of foreign fighters in their house.

The truth was that Haqqani's house was never a secret hideout. His family maintained a house in PakistanAfghanistan and the people in the house where his extended family relatives, ordinary people with no link to the war in Afghanistan. This is like Afghan resistance groups deciding to target Mr. Karzai's extended family members who have nothing to do with Karzai's activities just to get back at him. The Afghan resistance has never done it. But Karzai and his American allies have no problem in resorting to this method. since the 1980s. Haqqani lived and operated in

The devastated Haqqani family corrected the story later and questioned the source of the story since there were no Arabs or foreign or any fighters at all in the house. The U.S. attack was a deliberate act of terrorism to cause maximum pain to the Afghan commander.

Pakistani military quietly watched the Zardari-Gilani government take no position on the U.S. attacks. Then came the bombshell when, last week, Bush and his military chief, Adm. Mullen, said Pakistan was now part of the Iraq-Afghanistan 'war theater' and New York Times published a leak that said Bush had authorized attacks inside Pakistan without Islamabad's consent.

The purpose behind the leak was to put Pakistan on notice and somehow force the issue down on Islamabad in the hope that Pakistan will grudgingly accept it.
After Gen. Kayani's tough-worded counter statement, an embarrassed Prime Minister Gilani said the statement reflected his government's policy.

But the biggest question mark is the silence of President Zardari. He did not endorse Gen. Kayani's statement. Even more shocking for Pakistanis was that Mr. Zardari reneged on his promise that China will be his first foreign visit as President. Instead he left for London after a call from British Prime Minister Gordon Brown 'inviting' him to London to discuss the new U.S. strategy.

It is clear that President Zardari supports the new U.S. policy and does not agree with the Pakistani military's warning that it will protect Pakistan's sovereignty and territorial integrity at all costs.

Mr. Zardari is in power thanks to the arrangement -- known as the 'deal' - that Washington and LondonPakistan to accept. His assets are mostly in United States and Britain. There is no way he can risk alienating his backers. forced

There is every possibility that President Zardari has been convinced by close advisors, especially Ambassador Husain Haqqani in Washington, to tacitly accept U.S. operations inside Pakistan and not allow the Pakistani military to dictate its terms.

Ambassador Haqqani is strongly sympathetic to Washington's position. Last year, he played a major role in convincing Benazir Bhutto to make public statements accepting U.S. boots on Pakistani soil and American access to Dr. A. Q. Khan. Before his present assignment, Mr. Haqqani has been closely linked to the same hawkish U.S. think tanks that are the biggest advocates of U.S. military intervention in Pakistan. The elected government's soft position on U.S. attacks has a lot to do with the work of Ambassador Haqqani and another American figure--Zalmay Khalilzad, President Zardari's 'secret' American adviser.

It is a foregone conclusion; based on Ambassador Haqqani's intrusive record at the Pakistan Foreign Office in the past four months, that he has a direct link to the bizarre statement by Prime Minister Gilani ["PakistanU.S."-Sept 12] and the series of statements made by Defense Minister Ahmed Mukhtar that justified U.S. attacks against Pakistan ["U.S. drones fly too high, we can't attack them" and "If U.S. attacks, there must be a reason."]. can't wage war with

If Pakistani military tries to block U.S. military violations, there is a possibility of limited armed conflict between Pakistani and American soldiers on the Afghan border. Gen. Kayani's warning of retaliation did help NATO make a public statement that it does not share Washington's idea of taking the war to Pakistan. However, no one in Islamabad is convinced that NATO will remain neutral in the event that U.S. military tries to engage Pakistan in a conflict.

In case of conflict, Washington is expected to signal to India to open a front in the east in order to divert Pakistani military resources. Intelligence assets that have been planted inside Pakistan with links in Afghanistan will be activated and will possibly try to ratchet up the campaign of public terror in order to spread chaos and exert pressure on Pakistan military. More Chinese targets can be attacked or killed in order to strain ties between Beijing and Islamabad.

But Pakistan is not without options. In fact, the Pakistani position is stronger than what it appears to be. Islamabad can activate old contacts with a resurgent and rising Afghan Taliban inside Afghanistan. The entire Pakistani tribal belt will seize this opportunity to fight the Americans. The attempts to divide Pakistanis along sectarian lines have failed and the Americans cannot expect to repeat what they did in Iraq Pakistanis will fight and resist. There is a possibility that Pakistani tribesmen could cross the border in large numbers using secret routes to dodge aerial bombardment and join the Afghan Taliban and find their way to Kabul. The misguided 'Pakistani Taliban' who appear to be operating as an extension of U.S. military in Afghanistan will also come under pressure of the tribesmen and will be forced to target the occupation forces instead of fighting the Pakistani government. in March 2003.

Washington might be tempted by the idea of signaling to the Indians to engage Pakistan from the east. But the fact is that the Indian army has a dangerous rebellion on its hands in the valley. By opening a front with Pakistan, Indian soldiers will have to protect their front and rear simultaneously. The Pakistani military has contingency plans for dealing with hostilities on two fronts.

But the situation between Islamabad and Washington does not have to come to this. Islamabad can help tip the scales in Washington against the hawks who want a war with Pakistan. Not all parts of the U.S.Pakistan must make it clear that it will retaliate. Statements like that of Prime Minister Gilani must be stopped. His statement virtually damaged the psychological effect of army chief's warning. government accept this idea and this must be exploited.

U.S. military posturing aside, Washington has recently seen a string of diplomatic defeats. Russia has cut American meddling in Georgia to size. In Iraq, a coalition of Shiite parties is forcing the Americans to leave the country. Bolivia and Venezuela have expelled U.S. ambassadors, and, in Bolivia's case, the world has suddenly become alert to Washington's meddling in that country's politics and the role of the U.S.U.S. role inside Pakistan, where U.S. ambassador in fueling separatism. Which is not very different from the diplomats have created political chaos by directly engaging the politicians, coupled with creating and feeding insurgencies to weaken the country.

The only way to entrap Pakistan now is to either orchestrate a spectacular terrorist attack in U.S. and blame it on Pakistan, or to assassinate a high profile personality inside Pakistan and generate domestic strife that will make it impossible for the military to resist U.S. attacks.
Link


Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
Turkmen leader restores calendar names
2008-04-25
January is January again in the Central Asian state of Turkmenistan. President Kurbanguly Berdymukhamedov, who swept to power in 2006 in his gas-rich Caspian nation, on Thursday reversed a decision made by his autocratic predecessor who renamed the first month of the year after himself in 2003.

Saparmurat Niyazov, who ruled Turkmenistan with an iron fist for 21 years until his death in 2006, dotted the desert nation with statues of himself and also renamed all other months and days of the week after his mother, national poets and symbols. He declared himself Turkmenbashi, or Head of the Turkmen, and banned opera, ballet and circus during his long rule.

Berdymukhamedov, seeking to soften Turkmenistan’s image abroad and open up the long-isolated country, has been reserving some of Niyazov’s most eccentric and unpopular policies. Under his latest reform, all months and days of the week will be given their original Turkic and Russian language names. Under Niyazov’s arrangement which many Turkmen people found confusing, January was called Turkmenbashi, April was named after his mother, September after his spiritual guidance book “Rukhnama”, and Monday was just called “The main day”. “Thousands of citizens have written to ask to return to the Western month names and call the days of the week the way our ancestors did,” parliament speaker Akja Nurverdyeva said.
Link


Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
Turkmenistan oppo group seeks probe of Deutsche Bank
2006-12-26
Desperately seeking Turkmenbashi's slush fund...
Deutsche Bank, the German bank, was last night under pressure over allegations it was holding billions of dollars in accounts formerly controlled by Saparmurat Niyazov, the autocratic president of Turkmenistan who died suddenly on Thursday.

The Financial Times daily reports that it obtains a document that reads that the German bank is holding an account for a $1.68bn Turkmenistan government contract, signed in 2001, to export gas to Ukraine. The account is managed by the bank on behalf of the Turkmenistan central bank, according to the document. Much of the country’s central bank funds were under the personal control of Niyazov, according to finance experts.
A quick spin thru my email shows no spam yet from Turkmenbashi's widow, orphans, or former vice-chancellors...
In a report issued in June, the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development warned that funds in the Turkmen central bank were under the “discretionary control of the president without appropriate regulation and transparency”. Niyazov maintained a personality cult that impoverished his country and involved oppression of opposition groups and alleged human rights abuses. His funeral is due to be held tomorrow.

Leaders of a Vienna-based Turkmen exiled opposition group wrote yesterday to Angela Merkel, the German chancellor, demanding an “official investigation” into Deutsche Bank’s role. The letter from the Republican party of Turkmenistan, obtained by the Financial Times, cites an estimate of $3bn being held by the Deutsche Bank and other foreign banks. It said there “are further questions about money-laundering” [and] “violations of European Union banking standards on transparency”. Deutsche Bank in Frankfurt declined to comment.
"Ve know nossink. Tell zem, Hogan!"
Speculation over Deutsche Bank’s alleged involvement with Niyazov has been circulating for months in Turkmenistan and other central Asian countries, according to oil industry workers in the region. Global Witness, a London-based non-governmental group that reported this year on Deutsche Bank’s involvement in Turkmenistan, last night said: “Deutsche Bank should come clear on the Niyazov funds it holds, and if necessary freeze the accounts to ensure the money is not stolen.” Alexander Zhadan, Niyazov’s private secretary and purse-keeper to the deceased president since communist times, controlled his financial affairs. Mr Zhadan has not been seen since the day before Niyazov died, according to unconfirmed reports.
Not to worry. CSI: Ashgabat is on the case!
Andrei Grozin, an expert on central Asia in Moscow’s Institute of the CIS, said it was “naive” to think European banks would return the funds to Turkmenistan.
After he stopped laughing, that is.
He added that Russian officials scheduled to attend Niyazov’s funeral, including Mikhail Fradkov, the prime minister, and Alexei Miller, the head of Gazprom, the natural gas monopoly, were expected to remain in the republic for talks about gas supplies and revenues. Arkady Dubnov, an expert on central Asia, and commentator for Vremya Novostei, a Russian daily newspaper, said: “None of Turkmenistan’s export revenues go through the budget. It is most important for the new government [when it is established] to access the hard currency accounts.” Kurbanguli Berdmukhamedov, Turkmenistan’s interim president, said the date of an election to choose a successor to Niyazov would be announced on Tuesday. In a televised statement, Mr Berdmukhamedov said the People’s Council would name candidates for the presidency. Russian analysts said the results of the election would be pre-determined. Turkmenistan’s Majlis, or parliament, appointed Niyazov president for life in 1999.
Link


Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
Security tight as Turkmen prepare to bury Niyazov
2006-12-22
So long, Wayne...
ASHGABAT (Reuters) - Soldiers and police stepped up their presence on the streets of Turkmenistan's capital on Friday as the Central Asian nation prepared to bury absolute ruler Saparmurat Niyazov, who died with no obvious successor.
Problem? He ruled that it was illegal for him to die...
Local people said they had seen bread queues in some parts of Ashgabat, and the acting president, in a sign of nervousness ahead of Sunday's funeral, urged officials running the Soviet-style command economy to ensure people had enough to eat.

Niyazov, who fostered an extravagant personality cult, crushed all dissent and had himself elected president for life, died on Thursday at 66 of a heart attack after two decades at the helm of the gas-rich desert nation of 5 million.

Under a dark cloudy sky, green national flags flew at half-mast as workers in orange uniforms repainted road markings and cleaned the city's broad streets for the funeral.

Security was tighter than usual with groups of plainclothes security officers guarding road crossings and soldiers seen at key sites such as the telegraph office. The town is largely closed to foreign visitors.

In the first sign of a struggle over the succession, security forces led by Defense Minister Agageldy Mamedgeldyev set up a special State Security Council, naming Deputy Prime Minister Kurbanguly Berdymukhamedov as acting head of state. This violated the constitution, which requires the parliament chairman to take over.
Oh...formalities, formalities...
The unidentified Council members met the cabinet on Friday to discuss "the most important issues of state life."
"Brittney: Slut or Pig?", "Trump vs. O'Donnell: Who are we rooting for?"
At the meeting, Berdymukhamedov urged officials to ensure there were sufficient food supplies in the country and "firmly control all aspects of national life," state news agency Turkmen Khabarly reported.
That don't sound good...
The country's top representative body will meet on Tuesday to set a date for elections and decide on the succession. Turkmenistan has never held an election judged fair by Western monitors.
Looks like a job for...you know who.
Turkmenistan-watchers forecast a turbulent transition period as Russia and the West vie for influence in an ex-Soviet state whose gas reserves are important to Europe.

Restaurants were closed across Ashgabat for seven days of national mourning. But there were no public displays of grief.
"I was first shocked, then dazed, then I stopped caring," said Anna, a 35-year-old woman working at a local market.
Sounds like me. Except for the shocked and dazed part...
Some said they were worried that the country, divided for centuries among nomadic tribes, would collapse into tribal rivalry and chaos. "I just hope they don't start thinking about who belongs to which tribe," said Takhir, a scientist in his late 30s.

Niyazov, who ran Turkmenistan as a personal fiefdom, was criticised in the West for flouting freedoms and allowing torture in a country largely closed to foreign visitors. Since gaining independence from Moscow in 1991, Turkmenistan has forged what it calls a neutral foreign policy.
If they think Wayne's nuts, everyone will leave us alone...
Russia's Gazprom buys most of the gas from the huge Turkmen gas fields and controls export routes. Gazprom said it was not worried about the gas deals and saw "no reason to change the terms of these contracts whoever becomes Turkmenistan's leader."
Just a different name on the check...
Acting president Berdymukhamedov, 49, is seen as a transitional leader. He will hold the position until elections, in about two months, but is banned by the constitution from standing for the presidency in that vote.
...and it sounds like they're real big on the constitution...
Speaking to the nation on television on Thursday night, he showered praise on "Saparmurat Turkmenbashi (Head of the Turkmen) the Great" and pledged to uphold his political legacy.
Let the insanity continue! Wayne would've wanted it that way...
A former communist apparatchik, Niyazov fostered a quirky personality cult in which thousands of portraits and statues of him were set up around the country. A gilded statue of him in Ashgabat rotates to keep his face to the sun.
What if the sun didn't come out?
"Many foreigners found Niyazov's personality cult amusing," Human Rights Watch said in a statement. "But to people in Turkmenistan living under his regime it was no laughing matter."
Admit it, HRW. You thought Wayne was funny too...
Link


Good... ummm... afternoon
2006-12-21
SF Strippers pitch in tips to bring Christmas joy to children in need<span class=Inverse>Turkmenbashi</span> turns toes-up, Turkmenistan in turmoilNATO claims killing 50 TalibanCleric weighs 1-month cease-fire in IraqErrant Paleo Rocket injures 3 Gaza TotsBritain, Israel, US to 'vanish like the pharaohs': AhmadinejadZimbabwe Leader: Dissent to Be Crushed
Link


Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
Turkmenbashi turns toes-up, Turkmenistan in turmoil
2006-12-21
He'll be missed...well only for his comic relief value. I think we'll work up a proper RB Viking funeral tonight for the man who named one of the days of the week after his Mom.
Turkmenistan's President-for-life Saparmurat Niyazov died on Thursday after 21 years of iron rule in which he crushed all dissent and made his Central Asian state one of the world's most isolated countries. He was 66. State television and government sources said Niyazov, who basked in a unique and bizarre personality cult while ruling a country with the world's fifth-biggest natural gas reserves, died overnight of cardiac arrest.

His funeral was set for December 24 and the government fixed December 26 for the desert state's highest representative body to meet to decide on a successor. Until then, Deputy Prime Minister Kurbanguly Berdymukhamedov will be acting head of state. But Niyazov, who held all the top posts, left no designated heir and his sudden death raised concerns about the transfer of power in the ex-Soviet nation of 5 million, where foreign oil and gas companies are keen to invest in vast energy reserves.

Flags flew at half-mast from public buildings in the capital Ashgabat, a Soviet city grandly reconstructed to showcase Niyazov's power. Originally a Soviet apparatchik, Niyazov took the title of "Turkmenbashi (Head of the Turkmen) the Great" and had thousands of portraits and statues of him set up throughout the country. They include a revolving statue in gold leaf that rotates to face the sun in Ashgabat. He renamed the month of January after himself and his name was also given to a sea port, farms, military units and even a meteorite.

On Thursday, workers removed all New Year decorations from the streets, and television ran still images of a national flag in a black-bordered frame as an orchestra played solemn tunes. In an early statement eulogising Niyazov's achievements, the government suggested his tough and isolationist policies would be maintained. "The internal and external policies proclaimed earlier will be continued further," said the statement read on state television. "The nation must stay united and unshaken," it said.

Niyazov tolerated no dissent and was regularly criticised by Western human rights groups for flouting basic freedoms. Most civil society campaigners and critical journalists have been driven into exile or jailed, and rights groups have accused him of using torture against his opponents.

Turkmenistan-watchers were monitoring for any signs of trouble in the country, which borders Iran, that could affect its gas deliveries, much of which go to Ukraine via the Russian gas monopoly Gazprom. "If Niyazov's death results in political instability and social unrest, this may lead to the gas supply from Turkmenistan to RosUkrEnergo (Russian-Ukraine energy joint venture) and Ukraine being disrupted," said a research note from Deutsche UFG Bank in Moscow.

Berdymukhamedov, the new acting president, is said by the opposition to be related to Niyazov. He was earlier named to head a commission handling the funeral. In Soviet times, the person appointed to that task usually became the successor, but it was not clear if this precedent would be followed in Turkmenistan.

In an early reaction, exiled Turkmen opposition activists said they intended to immediately try to return home. "Our first task is to return to Turkmenistan within hours. We are discussing now how to do it. In Turkmenistan there is no opposition, they all sit in prisons or under home arrest. But outside the country opposition exists and it is coming back," one activist, Parakhad Yklymov, told Reuters by telephone from Sweden.

Russia said it hoped Turkmenistan would stick to Niyazov's course. "We count on the new Turkmenistan leaders continuing their course and further developing bilateral ties," top Kremlin aide Sergei Prikhodko told Itar-Tass news agency.
Link


China-Japan-Koreas
Turkmenbashi: Read my book, go to heaven
2006-03-21
The President of Turkmenistan, Saparmurat Niyazov, has told his people that reading his book on morality would make them smarter and could help them go to heaven. Turkmenistan's President for life, often known by his official title - Turkmenbashi the Great - was addressing a gala concert to celebrate the traditional central Asian new year, Nu Ruz, on the first day of spring. He told his audience that when he was writing the two volumes of the Rukhnama - his book of Turkmen history and homespun philosophy - that he prayed to God to bless those who read the book three times aloud. He said he had asked God to send such people straight to heaven.
I'm sorry. I just have a hard time taking somebody who adopts the epithet "the Great" seriously. Maybe naming one of the months after his Mom has something to do with it. I mean, what was the matter with "Thermidor"?
Link


India-Pakistan
What is to be done?
2006-02-24
M.A. NIAZI
The Muslim world, awakened, refuses to go back to sleep. If one was to take the precedent of the Quranic desecration at Guantanamo Bay, the protests should have petered out by now. But they continue. Muslim governments all have a hard task containing the rage that Muslims are feeling because of the insult to their Prophet (PTUI PBUH), and which is being fuelled by their sense of helplessness at what is to be done.
The current round of tiresome riots is lasting longer because it's consciously being fuelled by your local Learned Elders of Islam. Your "sense of helplessness" isn't tugging at my heartstrings, because you're not too helpless to incinerate a few embassies. The rubes are always willing to be whipped up, and the holy men are always happy to whip them up, and do date there hasn't been any penalty to either of them, with the exception of a few corpses here and there — who're never the holy men and seldom the guys waving their fists.
There is now a move to convene the OIC Foreign Ministers on this issue. That it has come so late indicates that it is not an initiative from the member governments, but is the result of a need felt to dissipate the heat the members are facing. Because the members' interests are disparate, it is unlikely to come up with any strong action.
That's kinda the story of the OIC, the Arab League, the EU, and the UN, isn't it? If everybody's interests are different, joining them together in a single body makes no real sense — it's a "government of national unity" on an international scale. The net result is some really good lunches and a fairly hefty printer's bill.
It has already been warned by the European Union that any sanctions against Denmark will be met with all-EU sanctions against the sanctioners.
Look, Maudette! Vertebrates!
While one head of government might be willing to take on the EU head-on, as Iranian President Mehmood Ahmedinejad has done over his country's nuclear issue, for 57 heads of government to do so is almost unthinkable.
For 57 heads of government to all agree on anything is almost unthinkable. The results, should they manage to accidentally do so, would be even more unthinkable.
One solution would be for the OIC to issue guidelines suggesting various levels of sanctions, which members could adopt as they wished, but who would vote for them, and then not follow them? The easiest way out would be to pass a resolution condemning the cartoons in the strongest of terms, maybe call on the Danish government to apologise, and to call for the passage of laws by Western countries protecting religious figures from blasphemy.
That's the ultimate objective, isn't it? If I were to hop into my trusty time machine and go back to 1955 and tell my father that the world was considering imposing blasphemy laws like they have in half-savage Pakistan he'd look at me like I was stoopid. If I were to go back to 1804 and tell President Jefferson he'd look at me the same way.
There would be no 'or-else'. If the countries addressed refused to tremble in their shoes, too bad.
I dunno about you, but I refuse to tremble in my shoes.
Yet it is certainly interesting that the OIC is moving to tackle this issue. The last parallel protests, during the Rushdie affair, moved the OIC Foreign Ministers' Conference in 1990 in Cairo to insert as Item 87 (of 95) of its Final Declaration the following: "The Conference expressed profound concern on the continued attempts to vilify or denigrate the noble values of Islam, its most respected and revered personalities and places of sanctity. It urged the Member States to take steps to safeguard the lofty Islamic principles and to adopt coordinated efforts to face any blasphemous attempt. The Conference urged the international community to respect the sentiments of all religious communities and not to allow any transgression of norms of civility and morality under the cover and pretext of freedom of thought or expression."
That was when Salman Rushdie published the Satanic Verses and ended up with a fatwah on him from the Islamists in Iran. At the time rest of the Muslim world joined in the hooraw, with similar riots and mayhem to those going on today. Some things never change; they're just events that are supposed to lead to an ultimate objective.
The OIC members were much more militant and upbeat then, as the meeting was in progress (31 July-5 August) when Iraq invaded Kuwait (August 2), and the loss of innocence that followed the Gulf War was still in the future, and 9/11 not even on the horizon.
The OIC spent its time after the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait dithering and ultimately sold Kuwait down the (Euphrates) river, as did the Arab League.
Therefore, the OIC governments are feeling much more heat this time around, and feel the need to relieve pressure from their publics.
It's a good thing the civilized world feels no pressure from its publics. It might lead to a clash of civilizations.
Are Muslims more radicalised now than then?
Lots of them are, but not all. Arabs and Paks seem to be more nutty than most, but that's always been the case.
Perhaps. Have their frustrations at their helplessness grown?
Somehow they're frustrated at living in kleptocracies and dictatorships, but somehow also they prefer to emigrate rather than hang their tormentors. The ones who don't emigrate are rewarded by occasionally being allowed to riot and burn down a few embassies or churches.
Probably. Have they grown more dissatisfied with their regimes, more disillusioned with their ability to defend not just their vital national interests, but also the collective interests of the Muslims as a whole? It seems likely. Will they be fobbed off with a mere resolution at the OICFMC? Probably not.
I'd guess they will be.
Will they be moved to do something about it? At this point, unlikely.
"Doing something about it" at this point would be a stoopid move. First of all, not all of the Muslim world is willing to be ordered around by the nearest holy man. Second, not every Muslim majority country is willing to lie down with the holy dogs for fear of catching fleas. It's still early in the game to be expecting them to be willing to join the lemmings.
The problem is that the civilised solutions to this issue are simply not satisfying enough.
Ain't that the truth? And the civilized solutions aren't going to come from the Muslim world, either.
The special reverence in which the Prophet (PTUI PBUH) is held, demands that the blasphemers be punished according to Sharia, which prescribes the death sentence, and the death sentence alone.
You're free to impose the death sentence on each other, but keep your grimy ways out of our countries.
However, that is not a feasible option at this point.
Not at this point.
A Muslim government may emulate the Israeli example of sending in assassins (as it did with Iraqi nuclear scientists), but it would come under tremendous pressure, perhaps too much to expect it to bear.
Somebody might finally get the idea of sending assassins back, and the targets would be the holy men.
A boycott of Danish goods is questionable: pork is not halal even if it is Pakistani (a few wild pigs are consumed by foreign and local non-Muslims); milk will not become haram just because it is Danish.
Too bad. You're picking on Denmark because it's not a European economic powerhouse and you expected it to fold quickly. It's tried to be accomodating, but it hasn't groveled, which is what you demand. And I'm willing to eat more havarti and Danish ham's perfectly halal for me. Life's tough, ain't it?
The demand for legislation protecting the revered figures of all religions is compatible with the concept of freedom of expression, because it is feasible to place restraints on freedom.
No, it's not. In most of the West the constraints are placed by good taste, which isn't legislated, and which is routinely violated with regard to Christian and Jewish religious figures.
However, it could lead to rather odd situations. It might mean, for example, that anyone who claims some form of prophethood within the Abrahamic tradition, as did Joseph Smith, founder of the Mormons, and Mirza Ghulam Ahmed, founder of the Ahmadi Jamaat, in the 19th century, or even godhead within the Vedic or Buddhist tradition, as did the Maharishi in the 20th, would be as protected as Muhammad (PTUI PBUH), Jesus Christ, Buddha or Ram.
So much for the Mormons, the Ahmadis, and the Maharishi School of Yogic Flying. And then, there are the Jews. There's gotta be some way to keep them from being covered...
It might even provoke a spate of declarations of revelation, for the Western understanding of freedom of expression, freedom of conscience and toleration equates these religious leaders with whoever else might make a claim.
L. Ron Hubbard, call your office!
It is also not just a matter of hurt feelings. Blasphemy against the Prophet (PTUI PBUH) is severely punished, even though other forms of abuse, while hurtful, are to be ignored, or merely rebutted. Denials of the prophethood of Muhammad (PTUI PBUH) can be ignored, for example, or debated, but they are not in themselves blasphemous. After all, a non-Muslim by definition is a denier. However, it is reasonably clear that certain mocking or insulting portrayals or epithets are unacceptable, such as the Danish cartoons.
So what's your bitch? You've just negated your own argument.
So should Muslims ask for very specific legislation about the person of the Holy Prophet (PTUI PBUH)?
Sure they will. They're just working out the wording right now, aren't they?
They can ask, and probably should, but this creates difficulties of its own. The USA was the first state to declare a complete separation between church and state. No religion is to be 'established' in the USA under the First Amendment, in the sense of having special privileges or any superiority over others. To ask it to pass a law specific to the Holy Prophet (PTUI PBUH), would technically be asking it to 'establish' Islam.
No "technically" about it. Your god's no more important than my god or lack thereof.
Here we do see the seeds of a clash of civilisations. The honour of the Prophet (PTUI PBUH) is not open to compromise for Muslims. Nor is the prohibition on 'establishing' any religion for Americans of whatever creed. Ask we must. Refuse they must. And pity the poor soul who is both 'we' and 'they'. Muslims hold that they are bound by everlasting and immutable limits, prescribed by the Almighty Himself in the Quran and through the Sunnah. Americans (and the West as a whole) hold that the only absolute is freedom, and any limits are determined by the people, who can change them as they will. These are incompatible. Either Muslims must accept mutability, or the West must reject its own principles.
I can see a reasonable compromise. How about if we keep our freedom, treasuring it and exploring its practical limits the more each and every day. We can laugh and have fun and pinch girlies and argue over the fine points of individual liberty and whether pigs have wings. We'll invent things, and we'll send men to the moon and we'll cure cancer. And you can remain in your Islamic paradises, speaking only to other Believers™, trading only with other Believers™, marrying only your own close relatives. Withdraw from international bodies that include Infidels™. Return to your immutable world and keep doing the same things over and over, generation after generation, just like they do in Peshawar. Keep on bitching about the effects while you're revering the Cause.
Meanwhile, of course, expect Muslims to subside into inaction once again, at least until next time. Many have noted that all the Muslims of today need is the right leader, who is not present among the luminaries gracing OIC Summits.
Don't worry the Mahdi's out there, just waiting for the main chance. Though I don't think much of a society that needs a leader for everything...
If pushed enough, though, the Ummah will search for a leader in earnest, and find him, even if it means forcing him to accept the task.
They're big on Fearless Leaders™...
The main problem before the world today is not how to avert a clash of civilisations, but how to manage it in a way that prevents some form of ultimate disaster. After all, even in warfare, there is a difference between warfare between 'terrorists' and counter-terrorists, in which anything goes, and that between two armies observing the rules of war, and the courtesies of the profession of arms.
Yeah. Jihad is the only answer.

AN AFTERTHOUGHT...
The real difference between the civilized world and the Third World is the latter's search for that Fearless Leader™. They've gotta have him. They're enthralled by the idea of standing around in large groups, chanting in unison, of believing in something. It can be a holy man like Qazi or Tater, or it can be a tin hat dictator like Sammy or Hugo or Bob Mugabe, but they've got to have somebody with all the answers.

We in the West elect our leaders and they then begin their inevitable slide in popularity until they're safely out of office. We feel free to disagree with them, even make fun of them, even the ones we like. We change "leaders" with only slightly less frequency than we change our socks (or pantyhose, as the case may be). Once you're in power in the Third World you can stay there until you die, even if you're a nut like Turkmenbashi, or a complete incompetent like Bob. And the chances are that your kids or other close relatives will follow you.

I think this is why so many of us feel a visceral aversion to the giant papier mache puppet crowd that comes crawling out from under their rocks for every summit meeting. They're people in search of Fearless Leader™. They've got to have someone tell them all the answers, rather than discovering them for themselves. To get those answers they're happy to tromp through the streets, exulting in the bravery of numbers. If they ever get their way we, too, can live in a soiety where innovation is ordered from the top, rather than emanating from garages or small businesses or people's dreams.
Link


Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
Placing a book in orbit, Turkmenistan aims for the stars
2005-08-26
The ex-Soviet Central Asian republic of Turkmenistan claimed to have joined the ranks of the world's space powers by sending a container into Earth's orbit carrying a spiritual guide written by the country's idiot idiosyncratic leader, newspapers reported Friday.

"The book that conquered the hearts of millions on Earth is now conquering space," said the official daily Neitralnyi Turkmenistan. "The sacred text of Rukhnama was chosen because it contains all the wisdom of the Turkmen people, thanks to its creator, Turkmenbashi," the article said, using the name the country's president, Saparmurat Niyazov, has given himself, meaning "Guide of All Turkmens".

The container was launched on Wednesday aboard a Russian Dnepr rocket that blasted off from the Russian launch facility at Baikonur in Kazakhstan on a mission to place two Japanese research satellites into orbit.
Link


Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
Turkmenistan celebrates Melon Day
2005-08-15
Either Dean Martin or Turkmenbashi with a liberal application of Grecian Formula. I'm not sure which...
Turkmenistan's leader on Sunday congratulated citizens of the ex-Soviet republic on the Turkmen Melon Day he established to honour the favourite fruit of the sun-drenched Central Asian nation.
"Happy Melon Day, my fellow citizens!"
"And a happy Melon Day to you, too, O Turkmenbashi!"
The nation currently grows 500 varieties of melon, including the Czar Melon, grown to honour President Saparmurat Niyazov, and the Golden Age, meant to symbolise prosperity under the president, the Agriculture Ministry said. "Let the life of every Turkman be as beautiful as our melons," Niyazov said in a statement.
"Let's party hearty! Let the feast begin!"
"What're we having?"
"Melons."
"There is nothing like that in any country of the world," the state-run Neutral Turkmenistan daily said in a headline.
No ther country has a month named "Mom," either.
Niyazov has led the former Soviet republic, a largely desert nation rich in natural gas, since 1985 as Communist Party chief. He was elected president in 1992 in the wake of the Soviet collapse, and has since gone completely bonkers created a personality cult around himself.
Link


Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
The Great and Venerable Turkmenbashi closes all libraries
2005-04-30
President Saparmurat Niazov has added public libraries to the long list of things banned in Turkmenistan — a bitter blow to many in the Central Asian republic who say their last window on the world has been slammed shut. Turkmen have grown used to living without opera, ballet, cinemas and even circuses — all forbidden by Niazov — but they say his decision to close all libraries cuts especially deep.
"First they came for the opera, but I said nothing, because I didn't like opera..."
Olga told IWPR she regularly took her 12-year-old son to the central library in Ashgabat, where he seemed inspired to read. "The library has a completely different spirit, a different atmosphere which gives rise to a thirst for knowledge," she said.
Dictators and despots generally not too keen on that "thirst for knowlege." They much prefer to have the populace actually thirsty, and compliant.
"Now I'm afraid our children won't be interested in anything except futile street activities, so they will lack a basic familiarity with the works of the great writers and poets of world literature. Because of the closure of the libraries, they have been deprived of this opportunity." A 60-year-old pensioner from Ashgabat said the library provided a welcome chance to socialise with friends and discuss the books they'd read. "Now we've been deprived of that too," she said. "I used to come to our district library and get out various books several times a week. You could also read a selection of magazines here, which I couldn't afford to buy on my meagre pension."

Various NGOs including Human Rights Watch and the International Helsinki Federation have protested the late February decision by Niazov — known as Turkmenbashi, or father of all Turkmen — to shut down the libraries. His explanation at a meeting of cabinet ministers was simple, "No one goes to libraries and reads books anyway." Also problematic appears to be the fact that most literature in Turkmenistan's libraries is printed in Cyrillic. Since 1996, schools have been teaching in a Latin-based alphabet.

Only the national library appears to have escaped the purge, so, according to Niazov, it can house new Turkmen literature as well as historical texts. The president said any more libraries are unnecessary as most books that Turkmen need — many written by Niazov himself — should already be in homes, workplaces and schools. Those include the Niazov-penned Rukhnama — a spiritual treatise that is the basis of the country's education system - poems written by the president as well biographies of him and his parents. A recent addition to the school curriculum is the "Source of Wisdom", a book for secondary school students with excerpts in alphabetical order from Niazov's three greatest poetic works. "To read all these books it is not necessary to go to the library as all these books should be close at hand for everyone," Niazov said.
"Or else," he added.
The order to close the libraries came during the cotton harvest under the pretext the buildings were being renovated or inventories done. However, libraries have long been out of favour with the president and this was just an excuse, analysts believe. In the late 1990s, he ordered classics of Turkmen literature written by authors including Berdy Kerbabaev, Rakhim Esenov, Beki Seitakov, Tirkish Jumageldyev, Khydyr Deryaev and Nurmurad Sarykhanov pulled from the shelves and burned. A literature professor at an Ashgabat university said these writers fell out of favour with the president because "they describe the material and spiritual contribution of Soviet republics to the culture of the Turkmen people, their spiritual enrichment and the formation of the Turkmen land".

Crucially, these works contradict Turkmenbashi's own writings, particularly his most important work, the Rukhnama, which denies any influence by civilisation, science or culture on the development of the Turkmen people. It also says the Turkmen invented the wheel and writing. Observers worry about the effect this information vacuum is having on Turkmen and warn of mass ignorance of the people, especially among the younger generation who are deprived of the opportunity to learn about the modern world. Though universities still have libraries, the supplies of books have not been updated for ten years while many works on history, literature and biology have been removed and destroyed. Bookshops elegantly display the president's works, but no other literature is sold. Bringing books into the country privately has become almost impossible as the government has set high customs duties on the import of printed material.

Certain magazines including Cosmopolitan are available from private shops and stalls but since June 2002 subscriptions to foreign periodicals have been prohibited. Access to the web is expensive and limited and as a result most young people have never heard of the internet. One Turkmen observer said, "The plans announced at the dawn of independence to remove communist ideology from national education have ended with government programmes becoming even more ideological. "But now the ideology is different, with scientifically unfounded historical, social and political theses declared by the authorities of the country which go directly against historical facts."
Honest, we don't make this stuff up.
Link


-12 More