Hello !
Recent Appearances... Rantburg

Britain
Archbishop Of Canterbury Withdraws Award From Muslim Cleric Who Praised Osama bin Laden
2026-09-18
[BBC] The Archbishop of Canterbury has withdrawn an award given to a Muslim cleric who praised Osama Bin Laden.

Hafiz Muhammad Tahir Mehmood Ashrafi received the award for reconciliation and interfaith cooperation from Dame Sarah Mullally last week, on the 25th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks.

Lambeth Palace faced a backlash after it emerged Ashrafi praised Bin Laden - the architect of the 2001 attacks - as someone who had "been fighting for Islam against the Russians, Americans and British", in comments from 2007.

Ashrafi also reportedly said he would give Bin Laden the title Saifullah, which means "Sword of God". He told the BBC his remarks had been "totally taken out of context".

Lambeth Palace now says "comments made by Imam Ashrafi have come to light that have led (us) to reconsider this award and we can now confirm that the award has been withdrawn".

In presenting the award last week, the Archbishop's office said Ashrafi was being honoured for "his outstanding work as an ambassador of interfaith harmony in Pakistan, known for his commitment to promoting religious tolerance".

His award was presented by Dame Sarah in a ceremony that coincided with the 25th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks in the US in which nearly 3,000 people were killed.

Ashrafi told the BBC that his remarks had been "totally taken out of context" and the backlash had been "an unfair campaign" against him.

He said that he was only speaking about Bin Laden in 2007 in response to "the hurt felt by many Muslims" over a knighthood being awarded to the Satanic Verses author Sir Salman Rushdie.

But he defended the comparison he made between an author and a man who was behind the deaths of thousands of people.

Criticism of Ashrafi has gone beyond his comments about Bin Laden.

In giving him his award for promoting interfaith harmony last week, Lambeth Palace had cited the fact that Ashrafi had intervened in the 2012 case of Rimsha Masih, a young Christian girl in Pakistan falsely accused of blasphemy.

But Ashrafi has otherwise been supportive of Pakistan's blasphemy laws that have led to an estimated 2,000 people being prosecuted since the late 1980s.

They include a disproportionately high number of Pakistan's minority Christians and Ahmadis in particular, but many majority Sunni Muslims too.

Ashrafi claimed the blasphemy laws actually "save lives", stopping people taking matters into their own hands.

But Human Rights Watch said last year that "the laws perpetuate religious discrimination and are used to target the poor and minorities in unlawful evictions and land grabs".

The organisation has called on the Pakistani government to urgently reform the laws to prevent them "being weaponised to [...] attack marginalised communities".
Related:
Archbishop of Canterbury 07/14/2026 Church of England backs study of Palestinian Christian document accusing Israel of genocide
Archbishop of Canterbury 04/09/2026 Britain conquered: As If on Cue, There's a New Royal PR Crisis Involving Islam
Archbishop of Canterbury 01/11/2026 Churchgoers say they will stop donating to collection plates if it goes to slavery reparations

Related:
Hafiz Muhammad Tahir Mehmood Ashrafi 06/04/2021 LHC acquits Christian couple who faced death penalty for blasphemy after 7-year on death row
Hafiz Muhammad Tahir Mehmood Ashrafi 02/27/2015 UN legislation against blasphemy is a must: Ashrafi

Link


Home Front: WoT
US jury convicts man on terror charges for stabbing and gravely wounding Salman Rushdie
2026-07-31
[IsraelTimes] ​Pro-Hezbollah assailant found guilty on all counts relating to 2022 attack that prosecutor says was ‘a chilling reminder of the global reach of Iranian terrorism’

A man was convicted Wednesday of federal terrorism charges in the 2022 stabbing of Salman Rushdie, the author who has faced a decades-old death threat over his novel "The Satanic Verses."

After just a couple of hours of deliberations, a jury found Hadi Matar guilty of all the charges against him, including engaging in an act of transnational terrorism.

Rushdie, who was about to speak on writers’ safety, was slashed 15 times on an amphitheater stage in 2022. He was gravely maimed and lost the sight in his right eye.

Prosecutors asserted that Matar was motivated by the late Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini ’s 1989 call for Rushdie’s death because of "The Satanic Verses."

"His brutal attack on Mr. Rushdie during a peaceful speaking event is a chilling reminder of the global reach of Iranian terrorism," Assistant Attorney General for National Security John Eisenberg said in a statement after the verdict, adding that "justice has been done." Iran’s government has denied involvement in the attack.

MATAR’S DEFENSE: NO EVIDENCE OF HIS STATE OF MIND
Messages seeking comment on the verdict were sent to Matar’s attorneys and Rushdie’s assistant. During the trial, defense lawyer Nathaniel Barone said the government had no proof of what was in Matar’s head.

Matar himself declined to testify. Rushdie did, telling jurors: "I can’t say what his ambitions or his aim was, but the wounds were dispersed across my body."

Matar, 28, is already serving a 25-year New York state prison sentence on an attempted murder conviction in the stabbing. His federal sentencing is set for November 3, when he faces a potential life term.

Rushdie won Britannia’s prestigious Booker Prize for his 1981 novel "Midnight’s Children," about his native India. "The Satanic Verses," a novel of magical realism about the lives and dreams of two actors who survive a plane explosion, followed in 1988.

It drew critical acclaim in the United Kingdom but engendered protests around the Moslem world over what some believers saw as blasphemous suggestions about Islam’s Prophet Muhammad, particularly in a dream sequence. Over the ensuing years, at least 45 people were killed in riots over the book, a Japanese translator was stabbed to death, and an Italian translator and Norwegian publisher were attacked.

Rushdie, who was born into a Moslem family, has said the dream sequence was just that. But he went into hiding for years, gradually emerging after Iran’s government distanced itself in 1998 from Khomeini’s fatwa, or religious edict.

"For two decades or more, I led a public life without a hint of trouble," Rushdie testified at the trial in Buffalo, New York.

Yet the fatwa was never rescinded; indeed, Khomenei’s successor, the late Ayatollah Ali Khamenei
...the very aged actual dictator of Iran, successor to Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini...>
, indicated in 2017 that it remained in effect. An Iranian foundation has offered a more than $3 million bounty for killing Rushdie.

PROSECUTORS: MATAR’S MESSAGES SHOWED HIM ZEROING IN ON RUSHDIE
Matar broached the fatwa with contacts in messaging apps in 2021 and 2022, according to exhibits shown in court. The messages showed Matar fuming that he felt Rushdie had attacked Islam and, by surviving, emboldened others to insult the faith. Matar alluded to a 2006 comment along those lines by the late Hezbollah terrorist group leader His Eminence Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah
...The late, lamented satrap of the Medes and the Persians in Leb...>
, the messages showed.

Born in the US, Matar also holds citizenship in Leb
...home of the original Hezbollah, which periodically starts a war with the Zionist Entity, gets Beirut pounded to rubble, and then declares victory and has a parade....
, where Hezbollah is based. Prosecutors said that photos in Matar’s New Jersey bedroom and on his computer indicated his support for Hezbollah.

Matar "spent months planning and preparing to carry out what he hoped would be the execution of Salman Rushdie," US Attorney Michael DiGiacomo said in a statement Wednesday.

The messages showed Matar initially talked about wanting to "expose" Rushdie, then about taking his life. In a private note to himself, he wrote: "We need to kill him ASAP," Assistant US Attorney Timothy Lynch said in an opening statement on July 22. The prosecutor said Matar framed the planned killing as part of what he considered a jihad, or holy war.

By spring 2022, the electronic chats showed, Matar wrote that he had discerned where Rushdie lived and was tracking his public appearances, eventually pointing out his scheduled August 2022 talk at the Chautauqua Institution, a western New York arts and intellectual center.

As Rushdie was being introduced, his attacker climbed on stage behind him, then stabbed him as the audience gasped. Spectators and another speaker, Henry Reese, scrambled to aid Rushdie. Law enforcement officers, assigned to the event, arrested the attacker — soon identified as Matar — after civilians restrained him.

Rushdie published a 2024 memoir about the attack, then returned to fiction with last year’s "The Eleventh Hour." The author, who was knighted by Britannia’s late Queen Elizabeth II, received a Dayton Literary Peace Prize lifetime achievement award in November.
Related:
Salman Rushdie 03/02/2026 Sucks to be a mullah right now
Salman Rushdie 11/20/2025 The Blue-Green Axis: Much More than a Dalliance
Salman Rushdie 05/24/2025 At least 12 injured in knife attack at Hamburg train station: emergency services

Related:
Hadi Matar 05/17/2025 Assailant who stabbed author Salman Rushdie sentenced to 25 years
Hadi Matar 02/22/2025 Man who stabbed author Salman Rushdie found guilty of attempted murder
Hadi Matar 02/07/2025 A Critically Important Trial Has Just Begun, and No One Involved Will Speak About Motive

Link


Syria-Lebanon-Iran
Sucks to be a mullah right now
2026-03-02
[LawDogFiles] 1983: proxies for the Iranian mullahs car-bomb the US embassy in Beirut, Lebanon. 17 American killed.

1983: proxies for the Iranian mullahs car-bomb the US Marine barracks in Lebanon. 241 US servicemen killed.

1984: proxies for the Iranian mullahs kidnap the CIA station chief in Lebanon, and spend 15 months torturing him — let me rephrase that: they tortured this man with electric drills, hammers, electricity, pliers, and anything else they thought of; and in-between torture sessions he was locked in a cage too small to stand, and too narrow to lay down for a year and three months. He was reduced to an animal, mind gone, gibbering in terror, before his heart finally gave out under torture. We know this, because the Iranian proxies sent us video recordings of the torture sessions.

1984: proxies for the Iranian mullahs hi-jacked aeroplanes, singled out American passengers, and murdered them.

1988: proxies for the Iranian mullahs kidnapped the head of the United Nations Peacekeeping Mission in Lebanon — an American — and tortured him. They sent us a video of his murder via slow strangulation when they got bored with the torture.

1996 to 1998: proxies for the Iranian mullahs car-bombed US Airforce housing in Saudi Arabia, and United States embassies in Tanzania and Kenya, killing Americans.

2003 to 2011: the mullahs set up a factory making Explosively-Formed Penetrators of a Russian design, and trained militiamen in their use for the specific purpose of attacking US servicemembers in Iraq. They succeeded in killing or injuring several hundred US troops with these EFPs.

The mullahs have attempted attacks inside America’s border — the most famous of which being the 2022 stabbing of Salman Rushdie in New York, where he lost an eye.

The Iranian mullahs have used the natural resources of Iran to become the #1 sponsor of International terror since 1979. If there is a terror group killing innocents, wrecking economies, and generally disrupting the world, there’s a pretty good chance the mullahs gave that terror group a wad of cash.

That’s a very brief account of the butcher’s bill in American lives directly laid at the feet of the mullahs in Iran.

I don’t think any long-term Gentle Reader has any doubts about where my feelings lay regarding this morning’s festivities, however:

Strategically: Long overdue, and necessary for world stabilization and American interests.

Politically: I’m sure the oppo party on Congress is tuning up their shrieking, but given that they shriek about literally every-bloody-thing — no matter how small or insignificant — that the current Oval Office occupant does ... ok.

Legally: I don’t know — and neither does anyone with a fresh degree in Legal Studies or International Strategic Studies from Google U. I would surmise that a man with access to the finest legal minds in the country probably has pretty firmly crossed his ’t’s and dotted his ’i’s, but we won’t know for a bit.

Personally: Kill as many of the mullahs as you want. Matter of fact kill all of them. Send the souls of every mullah, basiji, and IRGC thug — from highest to the least — shrieking into the bottomless dark, and bury their bodies in the cesspits where they belong.

There is going to be a lot of chatter on social media. A lot of claims of damage, lack of damage, targets hit, and targets missed will be circulating, aided by bot-driven disinformation and misinformation entities.

Take every report with a huge boulder of salt, until reliable Battle Damage Assessment reports come in — and those will be weeks away. Try not to aid the spread of social media bushwa just because it happens to jive with your personal feelings on the situation.

As far as the US military: Stay frosty, watch your buddies, and do the work. Good luck, God speed, and bring the hate onto the heads of the deserving.
Link


Olde Tyme Religion
The Blue-Green Axis: Much More than a Dalliance
2025-11-20
[AmericanThinker] As New York City celebrates a socialist-Islamist mayor and we approach the tenth anniversary of the ISIS-inspired terrorist attack in San Bernardino, it is worth reflecting on the many commonalities that unite the Blue-Green (Democrat-Islamist) alliance.

Many have remarked on the absurdities of these misfit ideologies as bedfellows. LGBTQ often professes love for Hamas irrespective of the latter’s nonnegotiable religious injunction to sentence gays to death.

Feminists who rage against the so-called white western patriarchy offer unconditional support for an unyielding theocratic movement that would institute shariah law, subjugating females as the dhimmified chattel of Muslim men.

Bitter and ofttimes non-telegenic progressive women (AWFLs) are indifferent to the industrial scale rape and sex trafficking of native European girls by male Muslim migrants, perhaps even gratified that tens of thousands of innocent working-class girls are physically and emotionally maimed for life provided it contributes to burning down "the system" or "the West" and furthers the progressive cause.

Still, despite the glaringly inescapable contradictions, birds of a feather flock together. And upon closer examination, the progressive and Islamist movements, both global in scope, have far more in common than meets the eye. Here are ten key ways in which the two totalitarian movements are conjoined at the hip in their marriage of convenience.

Often willing to kill and die for The Cause. Both ideologies are obsessed with destroying their perceived enemies. What do James Hodgkinson, Thomas Crooks, Luigi Mangione, and Tyler Robinson have in common with Mohamed Atta, Nidal Hasan, Omar Mateen, and San Bernardino’s Tashfeen Malik? All were willing to kill and/or die for The Cause. All were obsessed with politics and tribal identity. None were schizophrenic or conventionally crazy. In fact, thanks to DEI and political correctness, Hasan was a frequently promoted and highly compensated psychiatrist in the U.S. Army. If such people could somehow douse lighter fluid on all their perceived enemies, they’d light the match and giggle maniacally while snuffing out countless innocent lives.

Intolerant hatred of any competing ideology. Haters are moved to destroy and it is far easier to destroy than to build. It took seven years to construct the World Trade Center towers and less than two hours to destroy them. For progressives, the objects of their hatred are Republicans, white men, capitalists, and conservatives generally. For Islamists, it’s infidels, women, and gays. (As a bonus, both are really, really united in hatred for Jews and Christians).

Sadism and a total lack of empathy. Think of Antifa beating up innocent passersby just for kicks, or BLM enthusiasts executing random people in the streets. Or Virginia attorney general Jay Jones and his voters. Or consider Palestinians torturing and dismembering children and babies in Israel. Neither ideological group ascribes any humanity to their objectified victims. Both groups actually enjoy seeing others suffer as it creates a dopamine rush and makes them feel good about themselves. The ubiquitous yard sign proclaiming "Hate Has No Home Here" is an irony utterly lost on progressive homeowners.

Lying/taqiyya Islamic dawah (proselytizing) requires nonstop noble lying (taqiyya) in defense or furtherance of the faith. Similarly, think of the incessant lying and lies of omission by most of the western news media (for a noble cause, in their view) and the vast majority of university professors. Both groups are shrewd at deceiving and confusing the public, euphemizing and inverting objective truth in the service of turning oppressors into victims and victims into oppressors.

Playing the eternal victim Material envy, all-consuming resentment, and self-pity are unmistakable hallmarks of the progressive and Islamist mindset. Whether it’s Michelle Obama constantly whining about her massively privileged life or your garden-variety Islamist at a routine traffic stop, the practitioners of both ideologies stand shoulder to shoulder atop the winner's podium in the victimhood Olympics.

Holier than thou. Moral exhibitionists feel an irresistible urge to purify and sterilize, casting stones while believing they alone are without sin or fault. Muslim clerics frequently issue fatwas targeting infidels (e.g. Salman Rushdie, Geert Wilders, countless others) for death. Progressives also routinely issue public death threats on social media, along with constant doxing and swatting of high-profile conservatives in the hopes they will be murdered.

Grandiosity/exaggerated sense of self-importance. The AWFLs may loudly despise their own race or seek to emasculate Christians or white men but they enact these performative psychodramas to elevate themselves. Their grandiosity is further fed by their hashtags, symbolic gestures, and Bluesky or X posts. They are not self-loathing, as some conservative critics claim, although many do fear public mockery if they are exposed as hypocritical frauds. And the heroes of the Muslim world deemed worthy of emulation are not creators or inventors (and sorry, algebra was created centuries before the advent of Islam), but rather conquerors (e.g. Muhammad, Saladin) who annexed geographical territory and spread the faith.

Obsessed with status/public image. Both ideologies have positioned themselves as heroic vanguards of the oppressed masses. Interestingly, the progressive ditzes who revere terrorists as brown "noble savages" care nothing for the widespread persecution, slavery, and outright genocide suffered by peaceful Christian people of color at the hands of Islamists in Africa, the Middle East, and South Asia. It is not suicidal empathy but rather narcissism that allows progressives to climb atop the corpses of their own children in order to plant the flag of ISIS or Boko Haram or Hezb’allah as a way to preen and promote themselves.

Entitled, with a massive chip on the shoulder. Neither progressives nor Islamists observe the Golden Rule. Both are convinced they are owed whatever they want, irrespective of the common good, and they demand it now. Entitled progressives covet easy money, likes, and notoriety merely for stamping their feet and "shouting" their abortion, or proclaiming the need to abolish the police and empty the prisons. Islamist grievances are similarly endless and impossible to mollify, and those who kill in the name of Allah believe they are promised nonstop coitus in heaven with dozens of virgins; the sense of erotic entitlement creates a pretty powerful incentive to wage jihad and kill infidels.

Absolute unwavering self-belief. Self-esteem is not a problem for imperious children trapped in adult bodies imposing their totalitarian values on the world. Contra George W. Bush, Islam does not mean peace, it means submission. You will submit, convert, or be killed under shariah law. Or think of the unshakable fanaticism of the college student who can’t name the river or the sea or formulate a coherent sentence but nevertheless drips with towering sanctimony that she’s right about whatever it is she’s babbling about at any given moment.

With the Blue-Green axis, it’s noteworthy that the socialist megalomaniac Adolf Hitler rued that medieval Germany had not become Islamicized. Hitler considered Christianity soft and weak and contemptible, but believed Islam, with its unapologetic militancy and conquering ethos, would’ve been the perfect vehicle for the German people to conquer Europe and the world.

Indeed, the former Austrian corporal would be right at home in today’s Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) political party, right there alongside Mamdani, AOC, and, ironically, Bernie Sanders.
Link


Europe
At least 12 injured in knife attack at Hamburg train station: emergency services
2025-05-24
[GEO.TV] A knife attack at the main station in the German city of Hamburg left at least 12 people injured with some of them in a life-threatening condition, local emergency services said.

"According to initial information, a person injured several people with a knife at the main train station," Hamburg police said in a post on X.

"The suspect was apprehended by the responding forces."

A front man for the Hamburg fire department told AFP that 12 people had been injured in the attack.

Among them were "six people with life-threatening injuries", the front man said.

Some of the victims were being treated in trains, according to the German daily Bild.

Germany has been rocked by a series of violent mostly peaceful attacks in recent months.

On Sunday, four people were maimed in a stabbing at a bar in the city of Bielefeld.

The investigation into the attack had been handed over to federal prosecutors after the suspect in the attack told the coppers who arrested him that he had murderous Moslem beliefs.
The Times of Israel adds:
German police on Friday said they had arrested a woman after at least 17 people were maimed in a knife attack at the main station in the northern city of Hamburg.

Some of the victims sustained life-threatening injuries in the stabbing, which took place in the middle of the city’s evening rush hour, emergency services said.

The suspect, a 39-year-old German woman,
…which does not tell us whether she was Moslem, nuts, or both…
was arrested at the scene by law enforcement, a Hamburg police front man said said.

Officers "approached her, and the woman allowed herself to be arrested without resistance," Florian Abbenseth told journalists in comments carried by public broadcaster ARD.

"We have no evidence so far that the woman may had a political motive," Abbenseth said.

"Rather, we have information based on which we now want to investigate whether she may have been experiencing a psychological emergency."

The suspect was thought to have "acted alone," Hamburg police said in a post on X.

Four of them had suffered life-threatening injuries, the front man said, revising down an initial figure.

A previous statement by the fire department said six people were in a life-threatening condition.

Among the 17 victims were six severely injured people and seven people with light injuries, the front man for the fire department said.

The attack was reported by German media to have taken place just after 6:00 p.m. local time on one of the platforms in front of a standing train.

The suspect was thought to have turned "against passengers" at the station, a spokeswoman for the Hanover federal police directorate, which also covers Hamburg, told AFP.
Courtesy of Skidmark, more from Breitbart:
Twelve people are injured and three of them are in “mortal danger” after a mass stabbing at Germany’s Hamburg Central railway station.

Update 2100 — Four are in critical condition

A clearer picture of today’s mass stabbing in Germany is developing, with Die Welt reporting the number of known injured has risen to four in critical condition. A further six are seriously injured and seven more suffering light wounds. 17 in all were injured.

The attack is the second mass stabbing in Germany in a matter of days. As previously reported, a stabbing in the early hours of Sunday morning in Bielefeld, North Rhine-Westphalia, allegedly by a Syrian migrant was days later classified as a possible terror attack after Islamist literature was found on the attacker and at his home. As well as using a knife, the man is alleged to have wielded a spear and a bottle of petrol.

More from Breitbart about the Bielefeld attack:
A Syrian migrant, identified 35-year-old as Mahmoud Mhemed, was arrested on Monday by police on attempted murder charges in relation to a mass stabbing in Bielefeld in North Rhine-Westphalia. Five people were injured, and four of them seriously: the German Justice minister revealed they “barely escaped with their lives”.

The bar where the attack took place said in a social media post that one of those “critically injured” men had been a member of the public who had bravely fought the knifeman to end the attack. They said: “Had it not been for him, things would probably have been even worse”.

Now the investigation into that attack has been taken over by the Federal Prosecutor on suspicion of a religious terrorism motive. Per a report by Germany’s Die Welt, they believe they have found evidence for Islamism, that the suspect had an interest in the Islamic State, and had been in contact with a known Islamist fundamentalist.

It is stated the attack, which took place at a bar in the city, saw football fans attacked by a man wielding a knife and a home made spear, being a knife tied to a pole. A group of patrons fought back, causing the suspect to flee. As previously reported, the man dropped a bag containing “multiple knives, a liquid that smelled of gasoline, and personal documents indicating Syrian nationality”.

Zeit states a spokesman for the Federal Prosecutor, which has specialist counter-terror investigators and takes suspected terror cases over from local non-specialised prosecutors, who said the mass stabbing is being treated as an attack on Germany’s liberal democratic order and that at the time of the suspect’s arrest “a document was found on him that suggests the crime may have been religiously motivated.”

Further, images concerning Hezbollah and the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) are said to have been found at the suspect’s apartment.

Suspect Mhemed entered Europe through the territory of Turkey and was granted temporary refugee status by the German Migration Office in 2023. Earlier reports that he had no police record have been superseded, Focus reports, noting he had previously been investigated for “politically motivated crime” .

He was arrested on Monday after leading police on a 100 mile chase through Germany, taking several trains and other public transport from Bielefeld to Essen and to other towns beyond, finally being found in an apartment of a relative in Heiligenhaus.
Related:
Hamburg: 2025-05-12 'The Russians Are Coming!' Why Britain Killed Thousands of Soviet POWs
Hamburg: 2025-04-06 Belize's Great Blue Hole hides a 'concerning secret', scientists say after drilling to the bottom of the mysterious 410ft cave
Hamburg: 2025-03-20 Kursk II: On the streets are cemeteries of NATO equipment, and in the destroyed and looted houses are people, living and dead
Related:
Knife attack 05/17/2025 Assailant who stabbed author Salman Rushdie sentenced to 25 years
Knife attack 04/14/2025 Detroit Police and media say a fugitive ''woman'' was arrested over the brutal knife attack on a dog and cat
Knife attack 04/03/2025 Bulgaria to put five on trial over deaths of 18 Afghan refugees

Related:
Bielefeld: 2024-09-29 Giulio Meotti: How long will the UN continue to dine with the devil?
Bielefeld: 2024-08-28 Germany Mass Stabbing Suspect Pledged to ISIS, Groundswell to Mandate Enforcing Deportation Orders
Bielefeld: 2024-08-25 ISIS claims responsibility for German festival attack, Syrian knifeman turns himself in
Link


Home Front: WoT
Assailant who stabbed author Salman Rushdie sentenced to 25 years
2025-05-17
[IsraelTimes] The man who stabbed and partially blinded novelist Salman Rushdie onstage at a Western New York arts institute in 2022 was sentenced to 25 years in prison on Friday for an attack that also maimed a second man, the district attorney says.

Rushdie, 77, has faced death threats since the 1988 publication of his novel "The Satanic Verses," which Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, then Iran’s supreme leader, denounced as blasphemous, leading to a call for Rushdie’s death, an edict known as a fatwa.

Hadi Matar, 27, a US citizen from Fairview, New Jersey, was found guilty in February of attacking the author in the Chautauqua County Court in Mayville, New York. He faced a maximum sentence of 25 years in prison on the attempted murder charge.

Video that captured the assault shows Matar rushing the Chautauqua Institution’s stage as Rushdie was being introduced to the audience for a talk about keeping writers safe from harm. Some of the video was shown to the jury during the seven days of testimony.

"He’s traumatized. He has nightmares about what he experienced," Chautauqua County District Attorney Jason Schmidt says after the sentencing hearing, referring to what Rushdie suffered.

"Obviously this is a major setback for an individual who was starting to emerge in his very later years of life into society after going into hiding after the fatwa."

Also hurt in the attack was Henry Reese, co-founder of Pittsburgh’s City of Asylum, a nonprofit that helps exiled writers. He was conducting the talk with Rushdie that morning.

Schmidt said Matar was sentenced to 25 years in prison for the second degree attempted murder charge stemming from the attack against Rushdie and seven years for a second degree assault charged for the stabbing of Reese. The sentences will run concurrently.

Rushdie, an atheist born into a Moslem Kashmiri family in India, was stabbed with a knife multiple times in the head, neck, torso and left hand. The attack blinded his right eye and damaged his liver and intestines, requiring emergency surgery and months of recovery.

Matar did not testify at his trial. His defense lawyers told jurors that the prosecutors had failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt the necessary criminal intent to kill needed for a conviction of attempted murder, and argued that he should have been charged with assault.

Matar’s attorney Nathaniel Barone said his client will file an appeal.

"I know if he had the opportunity, he would not be sitting where he’s sitting today. And if he could change things, he would," Barone said.

Matar also faces federal charges brought by prosecutors in the U.S. attorney’s office in Western New York, accusing him of attempting to murder Rushdie as an act of terrorism. Prosecutors accuse him of providing material support to Leb
...Formerly inhabited by hardy Phoenecian traders, its official language is now Arabic, with the usual unpleasant side effects....
’s bully boy Hezbollah group, which the US. has designated as a terrorist organization.

Matar is due to face those charges at a separate trial in Buffalo.
More from the Times of Israel:
Hadi Matar, 27, stood quietly as the judge pronounced the sentence. He did not deny attacking Rushdie, and when he was invited to address the court before being sentenced, Matar got in a few last insults at the writer. He said he believed in freedom of speech but called Rushdie “a hypocrite.”

“Salman Rushdie wants to disrespect other people,” said Matar, clad in white-striped jail clothing and wearing handcuffs. “He wants to be a bully, he wants to bully other people. I don’t agree with that.”

Video of the assault, captured by the venue’s cameras and played at trial, shows Matar approaching the seated Rushdie from behind and reaching around him to stab at his torso with a knife. As the audience gasps and screams, Rushdie is seen raising his arms and rising from his seat, walking and stumbling for a few steps with Matar hanging on, swinging and stabbing until they both fall and are surrounded by onlookers who rush in to separate them.

A jury found Matar guilty of attempted murder and assault in February after deliberating for less than two hours.

Judge David Foley told Matar that he thought it was notable that he had chosen to try and kill Rushdie at the Chautauqua Institution, a summer retreat that prides itself on the free exchange of ideas.

“We all have the right to have our own ideals; we all have the right to carry them,” Foley said. “But when you interfere with someone else’s ability to do that by committing a violent act, in the United States of America, that has to be an answerable crime.”

Matar’s lawyer, Nathaniel Barone, had asked the judge for a sentence of around 12 years, citing his lack of a previous criminal record.

Matar next faces a US federal trial on terrorism-related charges. While the first, state-level trial focused mostly on the details of the knife attack itself, the next one is expected to delve into the more complicated issue of motive. He has pleaded not guilty. If convicted of the federal charges, Matar faces a maximum penalty of life in prison.

Authorities said Matar, a dual American-Lebanese citizen, was attempting to carry out a decades-old fatwa, or Islamic legal ruling, when he traveled from his home in Fairview, New Jersey, to target Rushdie at the summer retreat about 70 miles (110 kilometers) southwest of Buffalo.

Matar believed the fatwa that called for Rushdie’s death, first issued by Iran’s then-Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini in 1989, was backed by Iran’s Lebanese proxy Hezbollah and endorsed in a 2006 speech by the group’s slain chief Hassan Nasrallah, according to US federal prosecutors.

Khomeini had issued the fatwa after the publication of Rushdie’s novel, “The Satanic Verses,” which some Muslims consider blasphemous. Rushdie spent years in hiding, but after Iran announced it would not enforce the decree, he traveled freely over the past quarter century.
Related:
Hadi Matar 02/22/2025 Man who stabbed author Salman Rushdie found guilty of attempted murder
Hadi Matar 02/07/2025 A Critically Important Trial Has Just Begun, and No One Involved Will Speak About Motive
Hadi Matar 07/04/2024 Lebanese-American accused of stabbing Rushdie rejects plea deal

Related:
Salman Rushdie 02/22/2025 Man who stabbed author Salman Rushdie found guilty of attempted murder
Salman Rushdie 02/07/2025 A Critically Important Trial Has Just Begun, and No One Involved Will Speak About Motive
Salman Rushdie 11/09/2024 India lift 36-year ban on Salman Rushdie’s The Satanic Verses

Link


Home Front: WoT
Man who stabbed author Salman Rushdie found guilty of attempted murder
2025-02-22
[IsraelTimes] Hadi Matar has no reaction to the verdict except to mutter ‘Free Palestine’ as he is lead out of court; still faces Federal terrorism charges

A New Jersey man was convicted Friday of attempted murder for stabbing author Salman Rushdie multiple times on a New York lecture stage in 2022.

Jurors, who deliberated for less than two hours, also found Hadi Matar, 27,
...Lebanese-American reared un-Islamicly in New Jersey by a single mother. He went to Hezbollahstan a few years ago to visit his dad and came back primed for Shiite jihad. Despite failing to kill Mr. Rushdie, the government of Iran has awarded the misceant a full quarter acre of farmland to show their appreciation…
guilty of assault for wounding a man who was on stage with Rushdie at the time.

Matar ran onto the stage at the Chautauqua Institution where Rushdie was about to speak on Aug. 12, 2022, and stabbed him more than a dozen times before a live audience. The attack left the 77-year-old prizewinning novelist blind in one eye.

Rushdie was the key witness during seven days of testimony, describing in graphic detail his life-threatening injuries and long and painful recovery.

Matar, sitting at the defense table, looked down but had no obvious reaction when the jury delivered the verdict. As he was led out of the courtroom in handcuffs, he quietly uttered, "Free Paleostine," echoing comments he has frequently made while entering and leaving the trial.

The judge set sentencing for April 23. Matar could receive up to 25 years in prison.

His public defender, Nathaniel Barone, said Matar was disappointed but also well-prepared for the verdict.

District Attorney Jason Schmidt played a slow-motion video of the attack for the jury Friday during his closing argument, pointing out the assailant as he emerged from the audience, walked up a staircase to the stage and broke into a run toward Rushdie.

"I want you to look at the unprovoked nature of this attack," Schmidt said. "I want you to look at the targeted nature of the attack. There were a lot of people around that day but there was only one person who was targeted."

Assistant public defender Andrew Brautigan told the jury that prosecutors have not proved that Matar intended to kill Rushdie. The distinction is important for an attempted-murder conviction.

"You will agree something bad happened to Mr. Rushdie, but you don’t know what Mr. Matar’s conscious objective was," Brautigan said. "The testimony you have heard doesn’t establish anything more than a chaotic noisy outburst that occurred that injured Mr. Rushdie."

Matar had with him knives, not a gun or bomb, his attorneys have said previously. In response to testimony that the injuries were life-threatening, they noted that Rushdie’s heart and lungs were uninjured.

Schmidt said while it’s not possible to read Matar’s mind, "It’s foreseeable that if you’re going to stab someone 10 or 15 times about the face and neck, it’s going to result in a fatality."

Rushdie, 77, was the key witness during testimony that began last week. The Booker Prize-winning author told jurors he thought he was dying when a masked stranger ran onto the stage and stabbed and slashed at him until being tackled by bystanders. Rushdie showed jurors his now-blinded right eye, usually hidden behind a darkened eyeglass lens.

Schmidt reminded jurors about the testimony of a trauma surgeon, who said Rushdie’s injuries would have been fatal without quick treatment.

He also slowed down the video showing Matar approaching the seated Rushdie from behind and reaching around him to stab at his torso with a knife. Rushdie raises his arms and rises from his seat, walking and stumbling for a few steps with Matar hanging on, swinging and stabbing until they both fall and are surrounded by onlookers who rush in to separate them.

Rushdie is seen flailing on the ground, waving a hand covered in bright red blood. Schmidt freezes on a frame showing Rushdie, his face also bloodied, as he’s surrounded by people.

"We’ve shown you intent," Schmidt said.

The recordings also picked up the gasps and screams from audience members who had been seated to hear Rushdie speak with City of Asylum Pittsburgh founder Henry Reese about keeping writers safe. Reese suffered a gash to his forehead, leading to the assault charge against Matar.

From the witness stand, institution staff, and others who were present on the day of the attack pointed to Matar as the assailant.

Stabbed and slashed more than a dozen times in the head, throat, torso, thigh, and hand, Rushdie spent 17 days at a Pennsylvania hospital and more than three weeks at a New York City rehabilitation center. He detailed his long and painful recovery in his 2024 memoir, "Knife."

Throughout the trial, Matar often took notes with a pen and sometimes laughed or smiled with his defense team during breaks in testimony. His lawyers declined to call any witnesses of their own and Matar did not testify in his defense.

Public Defender Nathaniel Barone said Matar likely would have faced a lesser charge of assault were it not for Rushdie’s celebrity.

"We think that it became an attempted murder because of the notoriety of the alleged victim in the case," Barone told news hounds after testimony concluded Thursday. "That’s been it from the very beginning. It’s been nothing more, nothing less. And it’s for publicity purposes. It’s for self-interest purposes."

A separate federal indictment alleges that Matar, of Fairview, New Jersey, was motivated to attack Rushdie by a 2006 speech in which the leader of the terror group Hezbollah endorsed a decades-old fatwa, or edict, calling for Rushdie’s death. Iranian leader Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini issued the fatwa in 1989 after the publication of the novel "The Satanic Verses," which some Moslems consider blasphemous.

Rushdie spent years in hiding. But after Iran
...a theocratic Shiite state divided among the Medes, the Persians, and the (Arab) Elamites. Formerly a fairly civilized nation ruled by a Shah, it became a victim of Islamic revolution in 1979. The nation is today noted for spontaneously taking over other countries' embassies, maintaining whorehouses run by clergymen, involvement in international drug trafficking, and financing sock puppet militias to extend the regime's influence. The word Iran is a cognate form of Aryan. The abbreviation IRGC is the same idea as Stürmabteilung (or SA). The term Supreme Guide is a the modern version form of either Duce or Führer or maybe both. They hate Jews Zionists Jews. Their economy is based on the production of oil and vitriol...
announced that it would not enforce the decree, he had traveled freely over the past quarter century.

A trial on the federal terrorism-related charges will be scheduled in US District Court in Buffalo.
Related:
Salman Rushdie 02/07/2025 A Critically Important Trial Has Just Begun, and No One Involved Will Speak About Motive
Salman Rushdie 11/09/2024 India lift 36-year ban on Salman Rushdie’s The Satanic Verses
Salman Rushdie 08/07/2024 Pakistani man with alleged ties to Iran arrested in political assassination plots including Trump

Link


Home Front: WoT
A Critically Important Trial Has Just Begun, and No One Involved Will Speak About Motive
2025-02-07
[PJMedia] When the defendant entered the courtroom, he was dressed respectably in a blue button-down shirt and dark slacks. When his presence was announced, he stood up, said "Good morning," and gave all present a cheery wave. And thus began one of the most important trials of our age, although everyone involved is doing everything possible to ignore all the reasons why it is so important.

Hadi Matar
...Lebanese-American reared un-Islamicly in New Jersey by a single mother. He went to Hezbollahstan a few years ago to visit his dad and came back primed for Shiite jihad. Despite failing to kill Mr. Rushdie, the government of Iran has awarded the misceant a full quarter acre of farmland to show their appreciation…
finally went on trial Tuesday for attempting to murder the novelist Salman Rushdie back in Aug. 2022. There is little, if any, doubt about Matar’s guilt, even though he has pleaded not guilty
"Wudn't me."
, for he stabbed Rushdie multiple times in full view of a shocked crowd at the Chautauqua festival. Matar was supposed to have gone on trial in Jan. 2024, but Rushdie wrote a book about the attack, and Matar’s defense attorney, public defender Nathaniel Barone, received a delay in the trial so that he could review the book. It’s hard to fathom how what the victim thought about what happened might affect the guilt of his client, but nevertheless, Barone managed to delay the trial for over a year.

Now that it has begun, both Barone and his opposite number, Chautauqua County District Attorney Jason Schmidt, seem curiously intent on preventing any discussion of Matar’s motive. Matar tried to kill the man who, at the time of the stabbing had carried for 33 years the most famous bounty on his head since the days of the Wild West.

It was on Valentine's Day, Feb. 14, 1989, that Iran’s Ayatollah Khomeini called for Rushdie to be killed for supposedly blaspheming against Muhammad in his novel "The Satanic Verses." By 2022, Iran’s bounty on Rushdie’s head was $3 million. Without Khomeini’s death fatwa on Rushdie, Matar wouldn’t have tried to kill him, and there would be no trial. Nevertheless, neither the prosecution nor the defense wants any talk of that as Matar is tried.

Matar himself was upfront about why he stabbed Rushdie. Back in Aug. 2022, he said: "I respect the ayatollah. I think he’s a great person. That’s as far as I will say about that." Of Rushdie, Matar said: "I don’t like the person. I don’t think he’s a very good person. I don’t like him. I don’t like him very much. He’s someone who attacked Islam, he attacked their beliefs, the belief systems." Matar isn’t the most articulate person in the world, but what he said was clear enough to establish that he wanted Rushdie dead in accord with Khomeini’s fatwa.

Schmidt, however, insists all that is irrelevant, saying: "Here, I don’t believe we have to get into issues of Mr. Matar’s religious beliefs, his nationality, and his background to prove an attempted murder charge, which is what we’re doing. The allegation is that Mr. Matar stabbed Mr. Rushdie and stabbed Mr. Reese in an unprovoked attack. Therefore, I think we can prove that without getting into matters that give rise to prejudice of our jury pool."

Schmidt added: "From my standpoint, this is a localized event. It’s a stabbing event. It’s fairly straightforward. I don’t really see a need to get into motive evidence, whether that’s applicable or not applicable and what that consists of. I’d like to avoid all of that."

Well, all right, but isn’t examination of motive ordinarily a staple of murder trials? There are numerous reasons for this, including determination of the gravity of the offense, and the likelihood of similar incidents in the future. But Barone is only too happy to leave Matar’s motives out of the trial, as he wanted jurors screened for dislike of Islam. "They’ve talked about the reason why this alleged crime supposedly occurred was because of this book involving Moslems, all that. So it’s kind of like the barn door’s been opened," Barone said, and he wants that barn door closed.

All this is unfolding just days after Salwan Momika, an Iraqi critic of Islam, was murdered in Sweden for burning the Qur’an. The trial of Hadi Matar carries extraordinarily important implications for the future of the freedom of speech and freedom of expression in the West. Will Western countries defend the freedom of speech in connection to criticism of Islam, or abandon it? Hadi Matar blinded Salman Rushdie in one eye and caused permanent damage to one of his arms because of Rushdie’s criticism of Islam, and now at his trial, both attorneys want to pretend that this was some random and inexplicable murder attempt. The implication is that Hadi Matar was right to want Rushdie silenced, and now the attorneys are joining in the silencing.
Related:
Hadi Matar 07/04/2024 Lebanese-American accused of stabbing Rushdie rejects plea deal
Hadi Matar 02/22/2023 Iranian foundation offers land to Salman Rushdie's attacker - state media
Hadi Matar 02/08/2023 Rushdie says 'very difficult' to write after stabbing

Related:
Salman Rushdie 11/09/2024 India lift 36-year ban on Salman Rushdie’s The Satanic Verses
Salman Rushdie 08/07/2024 Pakistani man with alleged ties to Iran arrested in political assassination plots including Trump
Salman Rushdie 07/04/2024 Lebanese-American accused of stabbing Rushdie rejects plea deal

Link


Olde Tyme Religion
India lift 36-year ban on Salman Rushdie’s The Satanic Verses
2024-11-09
[KhaamaPress] An Indian court has lifted the decades-old ban on the import of Salman Rushdie’s novel The Satanic Verses, as authorities were unable to locate the original order imposing the restriction.
Not a matter of priniciple? Bummer. Lost paperwork sets no precedents. But still, lifting the ban is good thing unless you’re one of the various flavours of totalitarian.
Rushdie’s novel, published in 1988, was banned in India due to the controversies it sparked.

India became the first country to ban the book because of its portrayal of Islam and the Prophet Muhammad, which many Moslems found blasphemous, leading to protests and threats against the British-Indian author.

The ban became the subject of a petition filed in 2019 by an individual named Sandipan Khan, who challenged the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs at the Delhi High Court.

Khan questioned the legality of the 1988 order, which prohibited the book’s import under India’s 1962 Customs Act, claiming it contained alleged blasphemous content.

In his petition, Khan argued that the ban violated the fundamental right to freedom of expression, and he requested the court to allow the book’s import.

According to legal documents, Khan asked the judiciary for a copy of the order that banned the book’s import. However,
it's easy to be generous with someone else's money...
he was informed that the document could not be found.

Records show that the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs requested multiple extensions from May 2019 to May 2024 from the Delhi High Court to locate the document. Eventually, they informed the court that "the text of the order is untraceable and thus cannot be provided."

In the final hearing on the matter this week, the Delhi High Court ruled that "there is no alternative but to assume the non-existence of such a notice."

In the ruling issued on November 5, the court stated that "the petitioner shall be entitled to proceed with actions related to this book as per the law."

This ruling underscores a turning point in freedom of expression in India, as a long-standing ban on a controversial work is lifted, allowing new discourse on sensitive literary content in the country.
Related:
Salman Rushdie 08/07/2024 Pakistani man with alleged ties to Iran arrested in political assassination plots including Trump
Salman Rushdie 07/04/2024 Lebanese-American accused of stabbing Rushdie rejects plea deal
Salman Rushdie 08/08/2023 Oberlin College Sues Insurance Companies for Refusing to Reimburse $40 Million Settlement

Link


Home Front: WoT
Pakistani man with alleged ties to Iran arrested in political assassination plots including Trump
2024-08-07
[JustTheNews] The U.S. Justice Department charged Asif Merchant, 46, a Pak man with alleged ties to the Iranian government with plotting to carry out political liquidations, according to an indictment revealed on Tuesday.

The arrest on July 12 resulted in enhanced security for former President Donald Trump
...The tack in the backside of the Democratic Party...
and certain U.S. government officials who the FBI
...Formerly one of the world's premier criminal investigation organizations, something for a nation to be proud of. Now it's a political arm of the Deep State oligarchy that is willing to trump up charges, suppress evidence, or take out insurance policies come election time...
reportedly determined were the suspect's targets.

A Justice Department official confirmed the case involving Merchant was the threat that Secret Service was aware of when it became to ramp up Trump's security in the lead up to the Butler, Pa. rally where he was shot.

Federal prosecutors filed the charges in Brooklyn against Merchant, who reportedly traveled to New York City and collaborated with hitmen on the plot.

Merchant is currently in federal custody after getting arrested while allegedly planning to leave the U.S.
The Times of Israel has a photo of the miscreant, and adds:
A Pakistani man with ties to Iran has been arrested for allegedly plotting to assassinate a US official in retaliation for the killing of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps commander Qassem Soleimani, the Justice Department said Tuesday.

Federal officials identified Asif Raza Merchant, 46, as a Pakistani citizen who has said he has a wife and children in Iran. He traveled frequently to Iran, Syria and Iraq, the Justice Department said and allegedly sought to hire a hitman to assassinate a politician or a US government official in the United States.

Soleimani, who headed the IRGC’s Quds Force, a US-designated terrorist group, was killed in a US drone strike in Baghdad in January 2020. Iranian officials have repeatedly vowed to take “revenge” for the killing.

Court documents do not identify any of the potential targets, but the case was unsealed just weeks after US officials disclosed that a threat on Donald Trump’s life from Iran prompted additional security in the days before a Pennsylvania rally last month in which Trump was injured by a gunman’s bullet.

FBI Director Christopher Wary said the Pakistani national had “close ties to Iran” and that the alleged murder-for-hire plot was “straight out of the Iranian playbook.”

Asif Merchant traveled to New York in April for the purpose of hiring hitmen, even paying a $5,000 advance to two would-be assassins who were actually undercover law enforcement officers.

The instructions prosecutors say he gave to the men he thought he was hiring were for killings to take place in August or September — after he had left the country.

Merchant was arrested on July 12 as he planned to leave the country.

In August 2022, the United States charged a member of the Revolutionary Guards with plotting to assassinate former US National Security Advisor John Bolton. The Justice Department said Shahram Poursafi, who remains at large, had offered to pay an individual in the United States $300,000 to kill Bolton.

Iran has dismissed the claim that it had plotted to kill Bolton as “fiction.”
Related:
Shahram Poursafi 12/04/2022 Iran said using more hired assassins in plots against dissidents, Israelis and Jews
Shahram Poursafi 08/19/2022 Iranian Operatives Are On American Soil Conducting ‘Pattern Of Life’ Analyses
Shahram Poursafi 08/13/2022 'The murder plots on US soil inspired by Tehran: John Bolton, Mike Pompeo and a Brooklyn dissident have been 'targeted for assassination by Iran' in recent weeks - as Salman Rushdie fights for his life after stabbing attack

Link


Home Front: WoT
Lebanese-American accused of stabbing Rushdie rejects plea deal
2024-07-04
[An Nahar] The man charged with stabbing author Salman Rushdie has rejected a plea deal that would have shortened his state prison term but exposed him to a federal terrorism-related charge, the suspect's lawyer said.

Hadi Matar, 26, has been held without bail since the 2022 attack, in which he is accused of stabbing Rushdie more than a dozen times and blinding him in one eye as the acclaimed writer was onstage, about to give a lecture at the Chautauqua Institution in western New York.

Matar's attorney, Nathaniel Barone, confirmed that Matar, who lived in Fairview, New Jersey, rejected the agreement Tuesday in Mayville, New York.

The agreement would have had Matar plead guilty in Chautauqua County to attempted murder in exchange for a maximum state prison sentence of 20 years, down from 25 years. It would have also required him to plead guilty to a federal charge of attempting to provide material support to a designated terrorist organization, which could result in an additional 20 years, attorneys said.

Rushdie, who detailed the attack and his recovery in a memoir, had spent years in hiding after the Ayatollah Khomeini issued a fatwa, or edict, in 1989 calling for his death over Rushdie's novel "The Satanic Verses," which some Muslims consider blasphemous. The author reemerged into the public the late 1990s and has traveled freely over the past two decades.

Matar was born in the U.S. but holds dual citizenship in Lebanon, where his parents were born. His mother has said that her son had become withdrawn and moody after visiting his father in Lebanon in 2018.

Rushdie wrote in his memoir that he saw a man running toward him in the amphitheater, where he was about to speak about the importance of keeping writers safe from harm. The author is on the witness list for Matar's upcoming trial.
Related:
Hadi Matar 02/22/2023 Iranian foundation offers land to Salman Rushdie's attacker - state media
Hadi Matar 02/08/2023 Rushdie says 'very difficult' to write after stabbing
Hadi Matar 10/24/2022 Report: Salman Rushdie lives, but loses use of eye and hand

Related:
Salman Rushdie 08/08/2023 Oberlin College Sues Insurance Companies for Refusing to Reimburse $40 Million Settlement
Salman Rushdie 03/04/2023 Australian journalist Julian Assange 'taken hostage by US', action at UN may follow. PM Albanese's record stained forever if he dies, Tribunal hears
Salman Rushdie 02/22/2023 Iranian foundation offers land to Salman Rushdie's attacker - state media

Link


-Lurid Crime Tales-
Oberlin College Sues Insurance Companies for Refusing to Reimburse $40 Million Settlement
2023-08-08
[NR] Oberlin College is embarking on another legal battle now that it has finally paid out $36.59 million in damages to a local bakery for falsely accusing the business owners of racism. This time, the college is suing four of its insurance providers after they failed to reimburse the school for the multimillion-dollar judgment in the Gibson Bakery’s case.

After a years long legal battle, Oberlin agreed to pay the massive sum to the bakery in September 2022.

Gibson’s Bakery sued the college in 2017, accusing the school and one of its administrators of hurting its business and libeling it over an incident in which the son of the bakery owner stopped three black Oberlin College students, one of whom was stealing wine bottles from the store, in November 2016.

Students from the school protested the bakery after the arrest, handing out fliers outside the shop telling patrons to shop elsewhere. The fliers also accused the Gibsons of having a long history of racial profiling, citing the November 2016 incident. Witnesses who testified at the trial said Oberlin College Dean of Students Meredith Raimondo participated in the protests, handing out stacks of fliers for others to distribute.
So, they dragged their heels on paying, now the shoe's on the other foot.
Now the college is pursuing legal action against Lexington Insurance Company of New York; United Educators Insurance of Bethesda, Maryland; Mount Hawley Insurance Company of Peoria, Illinois; and StarStone Specialty Insurance Company of Cincinnati.

The school filed the suit in Lorain County Common Pleas Court in April accusing the companies of wrongfully refusing to "to honor promises they made in their respective policies to protect the interests of Oberlin College" and the school’s former vice president and dean of students, Meredith Raimondo.

The college had $25 million in commercial umbrella liability coverage from Lexington and another $10 million from Mount Hawley. The school had an additional $5 million from StarStone and $25 million in overlapping educators legal liability coverage from United Educators, according to the lawsuit.

"These policies were intended to provide seamless coverage for lawsuits like the Gibson litigation," the complaint says. "Unfortunately, the defendant insurers have failed to pay a penny toward the $36,590,572.48 sum that Oberlin paid the Gibson plaintiffs. They also have failed to pay for the full cost of Oberlin’s appeals, which were pursued at the behest of the insurers in order to reduce their collective exposure."

The college claims its insurers said that "some, if not all, of the damages" would be covered.
Related:
Oberlin College: 2023-02-22 Iranian foundation offers land to Salman Rushdie's attacker - state media
Oberlin College: 2022-12-16 Oberlin College pays $36.6 million judgement in full
Oberlin College: 2022-12-12 Finally, The Gibson's Bakery Family Has Been Paid By Oberlin College
Related:
Gibson’s Bakery: 2022-12-16 Oberlin College pays $36.6 million judgement in full
Gibson’s Bakery: 2022-12-12 Finally, The Gibson's Bakery Family Has Been Paid By Oberlin College
Gibson’s Bakery: 2022-09-19 Victory in lawsuit against Oberlin shows the wages of woke zealotry
Link


-12 More