Hello !
Recent Appearances... Rantburg

Home Front: WoT
The Illegal CIA Operation That Brought Us 9/11
2019-01-28
[Truthdig] In the latest installment of "Scheer Intelligence," the journalists tell Truthdig Editor in Chief Robert Scheer how an interview with Richard Clarke, the counterterror adviser to Presidents Bill Clinton and George W. Bush, led them to a jaw-dropping revelation regarding two hijackers involved in the infamous attacks. As it turns out, Khalid Muhammad Abdallah al-Mihdhar
...who is in our archives in abbreviated form as Khalid al-Midhar
and Nawaf al-Hazmi, two men linked to al-Qaida, were staying at an FBI informant’s home in San Diego in 2000, and they were being tracked by the National Security Agency.

Despite knowledge of the men’s ties to the terrorist organization responsible for 9/11, neither was investigated by the FBI. Clarke and others believe that this may have had to do with a CIA attempt to turn the two men into agency informants.
Link


Home Front: Culture Wars
Streisand Cancels LA Times Subscription
2005-12-09
LOS ANGELES - Barbra Streisand has canceled her subscription to the Los Angeles Times over the firing of the paper's liberal columnist. The newspaper dropped Robert Scheer and several other columnists last month; Scheer speculated he was let go because the Times had tired of his politics.
Or maybe it’s because the LA Times is going broke.
Perhaps the most liberal voice on the paper's opinion pages, Scheer had been a Times columnist for 12 years. He was a reporter for the newspaper for 17 years before that. "Robert Scheer's column, with its often singular voice of dissent and groundbreaking expositional content, has been among the most notable features that have sustained my interest in subscribing to the LA Times for many years now," Streisand wrote in a letter she sent to the newspaper and posted on her Web site.
That’s a pretty complex sentence for Babs. I hope her ghost blogger got a raise.
Streisand, a well-known supporter of Democratic candidates and liberal causes, wrote that by firing Scheer the Times had reduced the diversity of voices on its opinion pages. A shortened version of her letter was printed in the Times Nov. 23. The full letter is posted on her Web site.

In a note to its readers, the Times reported Nov. 15 that hundreds of readers had written or called to complain about Scheer's departure.
An L.A. Times “hundreds” actually means dozens.
As the Captain notes, the LA Times edited her letter and upset her even more. Heh.
Link


Iraq-Jordan
VD Hanson -- Year Three -- Where do we stand in this disorienting war?
2004-06-28
ELF -- it’s good to know, GWB reads him.

Snipped the entire first part of this writing from his website


What a litany of distractions! Words — preemption," "unilateralism," "hegemony," — whiz by and lose all meaning. Names — "Halliburton," "Chalabi," "INC" — become little more than red meat. Vocabulary is turned upside down: "Contractors," who at great risk restore power and water to the poor, are now little more than "profiteers" and "opportunists"; killers are not even "terrorists" but mere "militants." "Neo-cons" are wild-eyed extremists; "realists" are no longer cynics — inclined to let thousands die abroad unless the chaos interrupts transit of oil or food — but rather "sober" and "circumspect," and more likely Kerry supporters.

A depressing array of transitory personalities parades before our screen, entering stage left to grab 15 minutes of notoriety for their scripted invective, only to exit on the right into oblivion. Who can remember all these one-tell-all-book, one-weekend-on-the-Sunday-news-programs personalities — a Hans Blix, Scott Ritter, Howard Dean, Paul O’Neil, Joe Wilson, Richard Clark, or Richard ben Veniste? In between their appearances on Sunday morning television or 60 Minutes, a few D.C. functionaries are carted out for periodic shouting — an unhinged Al Gore, a puffed-up Ted Kennedy, a faux-serious Bob Kerry, and occasionally a Senator Byrd or Hollings. And since the very day after 9/11 we’ve gotten the Vietnam-era retreads — a Peter Arnett, Noam Chomsky, Michael Moore, Robert Scheer, John Dean, or Seymour Hersh — tottering out with the latest conspiracies about the old bogeymen and "higher-ups."

We are winning the military war in Iraq and Afghanistan. The terrorists are on the run. And slowly, even ineptly, we are achieving our political goals of democratic reform in once-awful places. Thirty years of genocide, vast forced transfers of whole peoples, the desecration of entire landscapes, a ruined infrastructure, and a brutalized and demoralized civilian psyche are being remedied, often under fire. All this and more has been achieved at the price of political turmoil, deep divisions in the West — here and abroad — and the emergence of a strong minority, led by mostly elites, who simply wish it all to fail.

Whether this influential, snarling minority — so prominent in the media, on campuses, in government, and in the arts — succeeds in turning victory into defeat is open to question. Right now the matter rests on the nerve of a half-dozen in Washington who are daily slandered (Bush, Rumsfeld, Cheney, Rice, Wolfowitz), and with brilliant and courageous soldiers in the field. They are fighting desperately against the always-ticking clock of American impatience, and are forced to confront an Orwellian world in which their battle sacrifice is ignored or deprecated while killing a vicious enemy is tantamount to murder.

No, we — along with those brave Iraqis who have opted for freedom — could very easily still lose this war that our brave troops are somehow now winning.

Link


Iraq-Jordan
Real thugs unworthy of apology
2004-05-06
By STEVEN ZAK
Special to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution
To judge from the endless expressions of American penitence, one might think we’d finally seen evil and it is us.

The incidents at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq have, as one might expect, provided grist for the left’s endless America-bashing mill. Thus, for instance, the Los Angeles Times’ Robert Scheer concluded that "Americans too can be ’evildoers’" and argued further that the nonlethal humiliation of a few terrorists compares with Saddam Hussein’s decades of "torture chambers and rape rooms." Likewise, self-described "human rights" activist Leonard S. Rubenstein in The Washington Post said that the incident "shamed every American," and then went on to fret that the Geneva Convention hasn’t been deemed applicable by the Bush administration to the al-Qaida terrorists at Guantanamo, Cuba.

Actually, the Geneva Convention does not and ought not apply to unlawful combatants who don’t themselves honor them. Iraqi "insurgents" are terrorists, many foreign. Iraqi "cleric" Moqtada al-Sadr and his followers are open allies of Hezbollah and Hamas, which alone would disqualify them from any legal entitlement to humane consideration.

It’s no great surprise that a shame-filled leftist wouldn’t buy that, but one might expect otherwise from conservatives. Alas, the usually level-headed Jed Babbin in National Review Online worried too about the Geneva Convention, not to mention "common decency." Ralph Peters in the New York Post did likewise and upped the ante by calling the accused American MPs the "thugs of Abu Gharaib." A strong word, "thugs," better applied to, say, mass murderers such as Saddam or former Hamas terrorists Sheikh Ahmed Yassin and Abdel Aziz al-Rantissi. One can only describe as alarming this new brand of self-flagellating moral equivalence, and the way Americans have finally come together -- to bash ourselves.

I suppose everyone is entitled to his own threshold of revulsion. But some might find such an outpouring of loathing and rage more appropriately occasioned by, say, terrorist hatefests where Americans are burned alive and hung from a bridge over the Euphrates. Or by the cold-blooded murders of a pregnant 34-year-old Israeli mother and her four daughters — the youngest age 2 — gunned down point blank by the Islamic allies of our enemies in Iraq. None of this is to argue that Americans ought to torment even irredeemably evil captives, but only to suggest that the incidents at Abu Ghraib may better be explained not by reference to sadism but to frustration. We’re at war with an evil not seen since the Third Reich, yet we can’t seem to wage it without an attitude of remorse. Let’s be clear: We’re there because Iraqis, collectively, have created a hellhole that threatens the world, not to mention a nightmare for themselves. Nearly 800 Americans have died trying to clean up their mess, and for that we owe no apologies — not for damaged mosques that house terrorists, not for occupied "holy" cities, not for anything we’re trying to accomplish. If the contrite way we wage war makes you apoplectic, imagine what it feels like to the troops on the front lines. Imagine, even, that you were in custody of enemy combatants who would happily burn you alive if the situation were reversed. Do you think you might, just might, be tempted to do a little venting?
Steven Zak is an attorney and writer in California.

The geopolitical aspects of all this are way above my level of competency. I'm not smart enough to sort out all the implications of it, though I can see the damage inflicted on the U.S. military, both in the view of the Muslim world and the self-estimation of what's at its core a professional and well-disciplined fighting force.

But I have to disagree that it can "better be explained not by reference to sadism but to frustration." The pictures show a kind of barracks-room grab-ass sadism that I thought was the Army had left behind 30 years ago at least. It's not frustration, it is petty sadism. It's not something that's sanctioned by the system, or that's a natural outgrowth of the system. It's the sort of thing kids do when left unsupervised. With Congress (or at least one end of it) trying to hang responsibility on the highest levels of command, it's actually the sort of thing that's can be found only at the lowest levels. There's a lieutenant and some sergeants who weren't doing their jobs keeping control of their troops, maybe at the highest level a captain and a first sergeant who wasn't paying attention. And because of that, the entire Army's damaged.

The military's not the place for psychosexual games. It's a place where mission is supposed to come first. Obviously in this case the mission wasn't at the top of somebody's mind.
Link


Fifth Column
The Last Bastion of the Left’s Sanity Slowly Slipping Away
2003-11-26
’Evidence’ for Link Is Administration Ploy
By Christopher Scheer
Christopher Scheer is the co-author of the "The Five Biggest Lies Bush Told Us About Iraq," co-published this month by Seven Stories Press and Akashic Books.
(Sounds like a moderate to me)
Two weeks ago, a flurry of opinion polls from CBS News and elsewhere showed that Americans were increasingly unhappy with the war in Iraq and didn’t believe that it had achieved its aims or made us any safer. The following week, the Weekly Standard, the organ of the neoconservative wing of the Republican Party, published extensive excerpts of a leaked, top-secret memo sent to the Senate Intelligence Committee the previous month by Undersecretary of Defense Douglas J. Feith, a leading neocon ideologue in the Bush administration.
(So explain to me how these two things are connected? How about that poll that shows the majority of Americans believe that Saddam and Al-Qaeda had ties? Makes more sense doesn’t it?)
The memo sought to retroactively defend the debunked claims that Saddam Hussein and Osama bin Laden had meaningful ties. Coincidence? Perhaps. But the leak and publication of the Feith memo, which selectively presented a few dozen raw intelligence items plucked from more than a decade of debriefings by national and foreign intelligence agencies, not only shows a certain desperation on the part of the administration to shore up support for the occupation, but it also fits squarely into the cynical pattern of abusing Americans’ trust we have seen since 9/11. That, you will remember, was when the administration made the calculated political decision to exploit American anger and grief as the launching pad for an unrelated and extremely reckless foreign policy hatched up in a pair of right-wing think tanks.
(What did you just say? Give me some of that stuff you’re smoking.)
"This is made to dazzle the eyes of [those] not terribly educated" about intelligence methods, said Greg Thielmann, a longtime veteran of the State Department’s Bureau of Intelligence who retired in late 2002.
(So this is why you didn’t use the more relevant poll. I believe it’s called Susan Sarandon Syndrome (SSS). If you don’t believe what I believe then you’re, how shall I say it, not terribly educated. Harumph!)
For those who have watched this pattern, the modus operandi is familiar: Leak to the media or place in speeches intelligence nuggets of questionable value — aluminum tubes, Nigerian uranium, the undocumented Prague meeting — then retreat when pressed. Keep the story alive in the friendly pockets of the media, like William Safire’s column or Fox News. When the factoid’s cracks start showing, replace it with a new one. Repeat as needed.
(Yup, there’s that Conservative Media Bias everyone keeps telling me about.)
Is this just business as usual for American government? No, it is not. Despite all our tough talk about not trusting politicians, Americans living in a democracy are always forced to some extent to trust our leaders to not exploit our lack of knowledge by lying to us, especially about matters of national security. This is one reason the intelligence agencies have long-established ground rules for how intelligence is vetted and distributed within the government: to make it less open to political manipulation. Raw intelligence, for example, shouldn’t be divulged publicly because it is riddled with unverifiable hearsay. But these best practices have been ignored at the Pentagon, where Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld has bypassed the department intelligence agency in favor of an ad hoc, Feith-based system where any flotsam that echoes the White House position is deemed solid.
(Don’t touch the Memo. Attack the Memo writer. It doesn’t matter that the Memo was a response to specific questions from the Senate Intelligence Committee asking for the specific "raw-intelligence" that Feith used in his prior testimony before the panel. Oh right, but the Intelligence your using to back your assertions is above pale. How silly of me.)
Feith, who has been playing the cherry-picking role as an amateur intelligence chief for two years, could have just as easily gone into the mountains of intelligence data assembled every year to paint a picture of the much stronger links between Al Qaeda and the Saudi royal house, for example, or the Pakistani intelligence agency —
(Don’t say it if you don’t really mean it. However, since you mentioned it, we’re a little busy right now. Give us some time to clear our schedule and then will consider you proposal for squeezing the Saudis and Pakistanis. Thanks for the input.)
both from nations that are our allies. But the White House position since the first days after 9/11 has been that remaking Iraq was to be the centerpiece of the "war on terror." Unfortunately for the president heading into an election year, it doesn’t wash. An NBC/Wall Street Journal poll found that a full 79% of Americans didn’t believe the war in Iraq had made them safer from terrorism.
(10 bucks the poll asking Americans if the Dems make them feel safer comes in at less than 15%.)
This is why eight months after we took Baghdad, the conservatives continue to leak questionable secrets to justify their actions. The simple fact is, Al Qaeda didn’t need Iraq to pull off 9/11 or any of its other savage attacks, and
(brace yourselves)
even if all the anonymous statements in Feith’s memo panned out, there still would be no evidence Iraq significantly aided the extremists.
(Thank you Perry Mason. Better change that poll to less than 10%.)
We are, whatever the neocons might want us to believe, waging the wrong war in the wrong way.
(Do I detect a little War envy?)

Long-time listener, first-time ranter.

Painful, huh? You’re witnessing the destruction of the foundation of the Bush-hater’s worldview. You’ve been warned. It won’t be pretty. At any moment, we’ll get word from any of the multiple top Al-Qaeda or Iraqi prisoners further detailing the relationship. It’s painfully obvious.

The Democrats hitched their party’s success on the Saddam Hussein billion-to-one longshot. They haven’t quite grasped the ramifications of it yet, even though they have caught glimpses of it (lost seats in the House and Senate in 2002, a Republican Gov. of California, lost Governorships in Kentucky and Mississippi).

Bush will get re-elected and Republicans will gain seats in the House and Senate. Ushering in a period in which the Republicans will run the show much like FDR and the Democrats did during the 1930s.


This is a political screed, so hopefully nobody's taking it too seriously. Wonder if Christopher Scheer is related to Robert Scheer? He sounds about equivalently biased. Nepotism at the LA Times?

I don't know who Greg Thielmann is, but I suspect he wasn't in the collection, analysis and reporting end of things. He sounds like a consumer, even though he's said to have retired from the Department's Bureau of Intelligence. (I think it used to be called something else, can't recall what off the top of my head.)

Finished intel — presumably what Thielmann read as a consumer — is made up of bits and pieces of raw data, much like the bits and pieces of raw data we see every day on Rantburg. Given a large enough quantity of bits and pieces, they form the overall picture that makes up the finished product. As the pieces of data wend their weary way through the process they pick up bits of spot analysis — rather like the comments on Rantburg articles. Significant items can be the subject of fairly lengthy meetings, where they're subjected to a peer review process. The larger picture tells you which pieces aren't valid — if Abu Tourab was captured this week, he wasn't really bumped off six months ago. Some data fits recognizable patterns and some doesn't — strikes in Europe make me think first of al-Tawhid; seeing Jemaah Islamiyah or Jaish e-Mohammad fingered would make me thing there was either something wrong or that there was a basic change in the way the Bad Guys were operating. The "few dozen raw intelligence items plucked from more than a decade of debriefings" passes that smell test, while Scheer's vitriol doesn't convince me of the opposite.
Link


Thumping Scheer
2003-05-21
Hugh Hewitt's got a blog. At the moment, he's taking apart Robert Scheer of the LA Crimes Times. Glenn Reynolds and Roger Simon (and a host of others) also administer well-deserved lumps to Scheer, who seems to have swallowed whole the BBC story asserting that Jessica Lynch's rescue was a staged event, complete with blanks and flash-bangs to make it look neat, thereby drawing even more support for the war from a gullible public.
"We were surprised," Dr. Anmar Uday told the BBC about the supposed rescue. "There was no military, there were no soldiers in the hospital. It was like a Hollywood film. [The U.S. forces] cried 'Go, go, go,' with guns and blanks without bullets, blanks and the sound of explosions," Uday said. "They made a show for the American attack on the hospital — [like] action movies [starring] Sylvester Stallone or Jackie Chan."

The footage from the raid, shot not by journalists but by soldiers with night-vision cameras, was fed in real time to the central command in Qatar. The video was artfully edited by the Pentagon and released as proof that a battle to free Lynch had occurred when it had not.

This fabrication has already been celebrated by an A&E special and will soon be an NBC movie. The Lynch rescue story — a made-for-TV bit of official propaganda — will probably survive as the war's most heroic moment, despite proving as fictitious as the stated rationales for the invasion itself.

If the movies, books and other renditions of "saving Private Lynch" were to be honestly presented, it would expose this caper as merely one in a series of egregious lies marketed to us by the Bush administration.
Beebs had already begun backing off the story by the time Scheer bought it, making him look even more mendacious (Andrew Sullivan's term, I believe) than usual, which is difficult. It's amusing to watch the process, and Scheer certainly deserves the bruising, but I think by now most people put him in the same class as Maureen Dowd — they're not analyzing anything, not producing real thought, they just hate Bush. And the rest of us had better straighten up, too.
Link


Home Front
Never trust content from Robert Scheer!
2001-09-28
Kaus Files
You know the 9/11 angle that implicitly criticizes the U.S. government because earlier this year it "gave the Taliban a forty-three-million-dollar grant for banning poppy cultivation," as a New Yorker lead editorial put it? It turns out to have been too good to check. Dan Kennedy has what seems to be the real story (which is that the money was Afghan relief aid specifically not given to the Taliban). ... The main culprit in fathering the falsehood seems to have been the LAT's Robert Scheer, who apparently misread a NYT story when writing a column back in May. (Scheer didn't respond when asked to comment, Kennedy reports.) Scheer tried to discreetly clean up his mess in a post-9/11 column, but too late to stop the mostly-bogus angle from being prominently recycled, in the New Yorker and elsewhere. ... (9/27)
Link


Home Front
Sullivan debunks Scheer
2001-10-10
  • AndrewSullivan.com
    SCHEER MADNESS: An overdue hit-job on the insufferable and mendacious Los Angeles Times columnist, Robert Scheer, by the often sharp and fair website, Spinsanity. Ben Fritz is particularly acute in pointing out how Scheer first invented the notion that the United States had given $43 million in aid to the Taliban and so was hypocritical in turning on the mullahs in Kabul and Kandahar after 9/11. In fact, that $43 million was food aid, dispensed through the U.N. and non-governmental agencies, bypassing the Islamo-fascist leadership. Well, we all make mistakes. What's truly troubling about Scheer is that even after this was revealed, he continued disseminating the lie. In fact, he larded it up, hedged it with new spin, and fomented its repetition in such places as The Nation, The New Yorker, The Denver Post and Salon. Read this piece and never read Scheer again.
  • Link


    -8 More