Hello !
Recent Appearances... Rantburg

Fifth Column
Islamism Is Winning The Cognitive War -- Thanks To Manipulative And Gullible Journalists
2013-04-07
Why France's fifth (!!) bite at the Mohammed al Durah apple matters.
[Telegraph] Anyone who remembers the halcyon dreams of the 1990s, of civil society spreading the world over, heralding a new peaceful, global millennium, must marvel at the path the young 21st century has taken. Even those who paid attention to global Jihad before the millennium could not imagine how vulnerable the West would prove in the coming, wildly asymmetrical war. Those who, over the course of the last 13 years, have awakened to the ever-growing danger of Islamism and to the astonishing inability of decent people -- Mohammedans and non-Mohammedans -- to effectively oppose its aggressions, owe themselves a brief lesson in cognitive warfare, and a second look at the nuclear bomb of that warfare, the Muhammad al Durah affair.

All asymmetrical wars take place primarily in the cognitive arena, with the major theater of war the enemy's public sphere. The goal is to convince your far more powerful enemy not to fight. In defensive cases, from the Maccabees to the Vietnamese, this has meant getting imperial powers to "go home." But Islamists who want to spread Dar al Islam conduct an offensive campaign: how to get your targets to surrender on their own home ground? In this seemingly absurd venture, they have had remarkable success.

The mainstream news media -- their journalists, editors, producers -- constitute a central front of this cognitive war: the "weak" but aggressive side cannot have success without the witting or unwitting cooperation of the enemy's journalists. The success of global Jihad in eliciting our media's cooperation with their goals

Paleostinians, like most belligerent armies, propagate stories about how vicious and hateful the enemy. The primary audience for this propaganda is the home front, which it incites to vengeance of the most ruthless kind, even justifying killing children in cold blood.

But since 2000, and for reasons that beg for serious investigation, the Western media has almost systematically presented these "lethal narratives" as news even though some/many of them are patently false. The dominance of such "lethal journalism," undermines the very fabric of the civil society upon which, ironically, Western journalists depend for their freedom.

The nuclear bomb of current Jihadi cognitive warfare, is the Al Durah Affair. The story first hit the airwaves on September 30, 2000, and marks the takeover of "lethal journalism" among Western Middle-East correspondents. According to La Belle France2's correspondent from Jerusalem, Charles Enderlein, Israeli troops targeted and killed a defenceless 12-year-old boy and badly maimed his father. The story spread like wildfire, an icon of hatred. Not only did global Jihadis use it to recruit for Jihad, but Europeans seized upon it for a substitution theology that freed them of Holocaust guilt: the Israelis were the new Nazis and the Paleostinians the new Jews

"Human Rights" NGOs made Israel the global villain, and at Durban, with Muhammad al Durah as the patron saint of the hatefest, this "conference against racism" laid out a plan for the systematic delegitimization and eventual destruction of Israel -- a battle plan that suited both "progressive forces" in the West (like Judith Butler) and the global Jihadis whom the "Left" embraced in the war against imperialism (like Hamas, always the voice of sweet reason, and Hizbullah).

In the saturnalia of scapegoating that followed, the press played a critical role: it delivered Paleostinian lethal narratives about Israeli evil into the information circulation of the West as news. Starting the with orgy of stories about the "Jenin Massacre", Western mainstream news inverted the reality (at Jenin the Israelis acted with more concern for enemy civilians than any army in the history of warfare), in favor of the invented Paleostinian accusations. And with each cycle of violence, the news media electrified both the forces of Jihad and a global audience among whom this narrative carried immense emotional resonance. This lethal journalism has poisoned the West, given wings to global Jihad, and literally allowed an aggressive Mohammedan Street to take root in Europe and other Western democracies.

A year ago, the shooting spree of French-born Jihadi Muhammad Merah included small children at a Jewish school, to get Dire RevengeĀ™ for "the Jews [who] kill our brothers and sisters in Paleostine". This man grew up in a world that constantly reported to him the Israel is a child-killer, both on Arabic channels and mainstream French channels like La Belle France2. His media-inspired rampage, rather than inspiring horror, made him a hero in his own community, and the media, a year later, reports the affair as a psychotic breakdown with no mention of media and religious incitement. This bodes very poorly for a nation (and a continent) that is, now over a decade late, beginning to awaken to the threat to its civic fabric.

On April 3, 2013, the French court will decide for the fifth time in a defamation case brought by Charles Enderlin and (state-owned) Franc2 against a private citizen, Philippe Karsenty who, in 2004, called for the station's director and Enderlin to resign for "having been duped and duping the public." In terms of legal issues it's something of a no-brainer: citizens in a democracy have a right to publicly criticise public figures; journalists have a responsibility to the public with whom they have a privileged relationship of access. The idea that a state-owned news agency should use the courts to throttle legitimate criticism is, democratically speaking, scandalous.

In terms of both intellectual integrity and civic sanity, there's no question. In the last round, on January 16, Karsenty once again demolished Enderlin and La Belle France2's news reporting before the court, and La Belle France2's only answer was to replay the news reports that used the staged footage Karsenty had just shown to the court. Even the judges seemed puzzled at the lack of substance (and his technical incompetence -- unlike earlier times, no one from the company was there alongside Enderlin who couldn't even run the videos he wanted to show).

There are two possibilities, and if the past is any guide, they will play out as follows. 1) The court has the integrity to find against Enderlin's effort to silence criticism, and the mainstream news media will either fall silent or complain about restrictions on freedom of the press; or 2) a politicised court will find against Karsenty, and the press will trumpet the victory as proof that the Israelis killed Muhammad al Durah. Decades in the future, acute observers may look back at this moment as a turning point -- for good or ill -- in the battle for democracy in the West.

Yesterday, the court, without explanation, delayed its decision until May 22. For those arguing a politicised court which would naturally side with state-owned and politically correct La Belle France2, this needs explanation. A kangaroo court does not hesitate. If it hesitates, it's because the evidence is so "badly" in Karsenty's favor that the judges hesitate to defy it. Whether for fear of contradiction, or some (significant but not decisive) remaining elements of intellectual integrity, this is good news.

The fact that they remain uncommitted, rather than deciding for Karsenty's obvious right to criticise a journalist, however, means the weight of public honour (Enderlin's, La Belle France2′s, the Paleostinians') remains inappropriately significant in their calculations.

While the court's failure to defend the values of civil society would just add one more to a long list of such failures on the part of Western elites to defend a legacy of freedom and human dignity it took many centuries of great suffering and struggle to achieve, a defense of those principles could inspire the forces needed to turn around this great ship, now being led by its allegedly progressive elite into civilizational suicide.

(For evidence and analysis of the original incident, see Second Draft and for ongoing discussion of the controversy, The Augean Stables.)
More at PJMedia here.
Link


Africa North
Egypt's Mufti Urges Muslims To Endure Insults Peacefully
2012-09-22
Mohammedans angered by cartoons mocking the Prophet Muhammad should follow his example of enduring insults without retaliating, Egypt's highest Islamic legal official said.

Western embassies tightened security in Sanaa, fearing the cartoons published in a French magazine on Wednesday could lead to more unrest in the Yemeni capital where crowds attacked the US mission last week over an anti-Islam film made in America.

In the latest of a wave of protests against that video in the Islamic world, several thousand Shiite Mohammedans demonstrated in the northern Nigerian town of Zaria, burning an effigy of US President Barack Obama
This is a teachable moment...
and crying "Death to America™".

In the Pak capital, about 1,000 stone-throwing protesters clashed with police as they tried to force their way to the US embassy on Thursday and the government shut down mobile phone services in more than a dozen cities as part of security arrangements ahead of protests expected on Friday.

The US embassy in Pakistain has been running television advertisements, one featuring Secretary of State Hillary Clinton
... sometimes described as America's Blond Eminence and at other times as Mrs. Bill, never as Another Dean Rusk ...
, emphasizing that the US government had nothing to do with the film.

The US and French embassies were closed on Friday in Jakarta, capital of Indonesia, which has the world's biggest Mohammedan population, and diplomatic missions in the Afghan capital, Kabul, were on lock-down.

The cartoons in La Belle France's Charlie Hebdo satirical weekly have provoked relatively little street anger, although about 100 Iranians demonstrated outside the French embassy in Tehran.

In Tunisia, the birthplace of the Arab Spring revolts, the Islamist-led government decreed a ban on protests planned on Friday against the cartoons. Four people died and almost 30 were maimed last week when protesters incensed by the movie about the Prophet Muhammad stormed the US embassy.

An Islamist activist called for attacks in La Belle France to avenge the perceived insult to Islam by the "slaves of the cross".

Muawiyya al-Qahtani said on a website used by Islamist bully boyz and monitored by the US-based SITE intelligence group: "Is there someone who will roll up his sleeves and bring back to us the glory of the hero Muhammad Merah?"

He was referring to an al Qaeda-inspired gunman who killed seven people, including three Jewish children, in the southern French city of Toulouse
...lies on the banks of the River Garonne, half-way between the Atlantic Ocean and the Mediterranean Sea. The Toulouse metropolitan area is the fourth-largest in La Belle France...
in March.

Condemning the publication of the cartoons in La Belle France as an act verging on incitement, Egypt's Grand Mufti Ali Gomaa said on Thursday it showed how polarized the West and the Mohammedan world had become.

Gomaa said Muhammad and his lover companions had endured "the worst insults from the non-believers of his time. Not only was his message routinely rejected, but he was often chased out of town, cursed and physically assaulted on numerous occasions.

"But his example was always to endure all personal insults and attacks without retaliation of any sort. There is no doubt that, since the Prophet is our greatest example in this life, this should also be the reaction of all Mohammedans."

His statement echoed one by Al Azhar, Egypt's prestigious seat of Sunni learning, which condemned the caricatures showing the Prophet naked but said any protest should be peaceful.

An official at the Coptic Orthodox Church in Egypt, whose population of 83 million people is 10 percent Christian, also condemned the cartoons as insults to Islam.

Last week, some Egyptian protesters scaled the US Embassy walls and tore down the flag. They clashed with police for four days, although most of the thousands of Egyptians who erupted into the streets did so peacefully.

Mohammedan grievances

Gomaa said insults to Islam and the response, including the killing of the US ambassador in Libya and attacks on other Western embassies in the region, could not be dissociated from other points of conflict between the West and the Mohammedan world.

He cited the treatment of Mohammedans at the US detention center in Guantanamo, the US-led war in Iraq, drone attacks in Yemen and Pakistain, and the demonisation of Mohammedans by far-right European parties as "underlying factors" for the tension.

"To then insist on igniting these simmering tensions by publishing hurtful and insulting material in a foolhardy attempt at bravado - asserting the superiority of Western freedoms over alleged Mohammedan closed-mindedness - verges on incitement," he said in his statement published on the Rooters blog FaithWorld.

After the invasion of the US embassy in Tunis on Friday last week, the Tunisian Interior Ministry has banned protests against the cartoon this Friday "to prevent human and material losses".

The European Union
...the successor to the Holy Roman Empire, only without the Hapsburgs and the nifty uniforms and the dancing...
issued a joint appeal, through its foreign policy chief, with the Arab League
...an organization of Arabic-speaking states with 22 member countries and four observers. The League tries to achieve Arab consensus on issues, which usually leaves them doing nothing but a bit of grimacing and mustache cursing...
, African Union
...a union consisting of 53 African states, most run by dictators of one flavor or another. The only all-African state not in the AU is Morocco. Established in 2002, the AU is the successor to the Organisation of African Unity (OAU), which was even less successful...
and Organisation of Islamic Cooperation for "peace and tolerance".

"We condemn any advocacy of religious hatred that constitutes incitement to hostility and violence," the EU said.

"While fully recognizing freedom of expression, we believe in the importance of respecting all prophets, regardless of which religion they belong to."

Iran's Foreign Ministry front man, Ramin Mehmanparast, condemned the cartoons as "a systematic plot" against Islam.

"The coordinated and continued silence of Western countries towards these hateful anti-Islamic actions, is the primary reason for the repetition of such insulting actions," he said.

He was speaking a day after French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius called the publication of the cartoons a provocation.

The Danish cartoonist who outraged Mohammedans with a drawing of the Prophet seven years ago said the West could not let itself be muzzled by fear of offending Islamic sensibilities.

Kurt Westergaard, whose lampoon of Mohammad in the Jyllands-Posten paper nearly got him killed by an axe-wielding assassin in 2010, told Austrian magazine News he had no regrets about his work and said freedom of speech was too precious to relinquish.

"Should we in future let ourselves be censored by Islamic authorities in deeply undemocratic countries?" he asked.

For many Mohammedans, any depiction of Muhammad is blasphemous.

The furore over the anti-Islam film and the cartoons has presented a tough challenge to new authorities in Arab countries where popular uprisings have tossed entrenched autocrats.

In Libya, where militias that helped overthrow Muammar Qadaffy
...Custodian of Wheelus AFB for 42 long years until he was ejected from the gene pool by his indignant citizens...
still wield much power, the foreign minister offered a further apology for US ambassador Christopher Stevens' death to visiting US Deputy Secretary of State William Burns on Thursday.

Stevens and three other Americans died in an attack on the US consulate in the eastern city of Benghazi by gunnies among a crowd protesting against the film that denigrated the Prophet.
Link


-2 More