Warning: Undefined array key "rbname" in /data/rantburg.com/www/pgrecentorg.php on line 14
Hello !
Recent Appearances... Rantburg

Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Israeli Jailed In Egypt Sends Letter To PM Urging Action For His Release
2014-05-16
[Ynet] After 14 years in prison, Israeli Bedouin Ouda Tarabin accuses Netanyahu: 'You and your government have forgotten me'.

An Israeli citizen serving a 15-year jail sentence in Egypt wrote a letter to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu recently, criticizing the government for what he called their incompetence in attempts to secure his release.

"I'm the Israeli citizen, Ouda Tarabin, who you and your government have forgotten, imprisoned in Egypt," he wrote.

Tarabin, a resident of Rahat in southern Israel, is a member of the Bedouin community in Israel. He was tossed in the slammer
I ain't sayin' nuttin' widdout me mout'piece!
14 years ago in Egypt where he was convicted of being an Israeli spy.

"Your government hasn't helped me unfortunately because I'm an Arab and that's completely clear," wrote Tarabin in the letter obtained by Ynet before being passed on to the Prime Minister's Office.

"If I were a Jew or a Druze, the government would be fighting for me and my freedom, and I wouldn't have been sitting in an Egyptian prison for 14 years."

"Mr. Prime Minister, this is the truth that everyone knows," he continued. "Mr. Prime Minister, this government is a tragedy for my country, that's supposed to be a democracy in the Middle East."

In his letter, Tarabin tells the prime minister of his hardships in prison, claiming that he has been deprived and treated poorly for being an Israeli citizen.

"They sentenced me with 15 years in prison by a military court for being an Israel spy and I've never made an appearance in court. I haven't even been allowed to see a judge to try and defend myself," he said.

"The Egyptian government knows I'm innocent but because I'm an Israeli citizen, I've been very obviously targeted."

Tarabin wrote about the difficulties of being far from his homeland, his family and judged that Israel was to blame saying, "You're government hasn't raised a finger for my release by the Egyptians who are considered a friendly country and one of joint interests with Israel."

Despite the lack of past action by the Israeli government, Tarabin's letter urged the prime minister, "to act immediately to put an end to my suffering and the suffering of my family, to engage the Egyptian government, and act quickly to ensure my release."

He concluded by saying that, "I want to feel that I'm a citizen who has a country and government that cares for its citizens, that worries about their interests and doesn't discriminate between them."

Tarabin's lawyer, Itzhak Meltzer, told Ynet, "You can't blame Ouda. He saw how Azzam (Azzam, an Israeli Druze locked away
Drop the heater, Studs, or you're hist'try!
in Egypt for eight years) was released while he stayed in prison. He saw what Israel did in order to secure the release of Gilad Shalit and Ilan Grapel while he stayed in prison."

"Tarabin's incarceration in Egypt puts a heavy financial burden on his family," said Meltzer. "I turned to different sources like the finance minister and his deputy, the prime minister and president of the country and I asked them to support the family, but none of them paid any attention."

Tarabin was imprisoned in 2000 for 15 years after being convicted of collecting intelligence information for Israel. His trial was carried out without his knowledge or presence. According to Tarabin, he was taken into custody after crossing the border to visit his family in Sinai.

More than three years ago, there was hope that Tarabin would be released as part of a deal in which Ilan Grapel, who was in Egyptian prison for four months, but in the end Tarabin wasn't included in the agreement.
Link


Africa North
Cairo to Try 5 Mossad Officers, 3 Egyptians for 'Spying'
2014-02-03
[An Nahar] Five officers from Israel's Mossad spy agency and three Egyptians will stand trial on Wednesday on charges of spying for the Jewish state, judicial sources said.

Egyptian prosecutors have accused the eight of espionage and supplying Israel with information impacting Egypt's national security, the sources said on Sunday.

The trial is expected to open with none of the defendants present, the sources said, because the Mossad officers are "on the run" while it is not clear if the three Egyptians had been tossed in the clink
Drop the rod and step away witcher hands up!
.

The Egyptian suspects hail from Rafah, on the border with the Paleostinian Gazoo Strip, they said, adding that the trial will be held in the Suez canal city of Ismailiya.

The trial of a Jordanian engineer accused of having spied for Israel is also underway in Egypt.

In October 2011, Israel freed 25 Egyptians in exchange for the release of a U.S.-Israeli called Ilan Grapel, who had been held in Cairo for four months on spying charges.

Egypt signed a peace treaty with Israel in 1979, the first Arab country to have done that.
Link


Africa North
Clearing The Decks For Action: Israel To Trade 65 Egyptians For Israeli Beduin
2012-05-10
J'lem, Cairo involved in intensive negotiations to secure release of Israeli Beduin jailed for a decade for alleged espionage.

Jerusalem and Cairo are involved in intensive negotiations to secure the release of Ouda Tarabin, the Israeli Beduin locked away
Drop the gat, Rocky, or you're a dead 'un!
in Egypt for over a decade for espionage, Egyptian media reported Wednesday.

Egypt's state-run Al-Ahram newspaper reported that Tarabin and several other Israelis convicted of spying would be exchanged for 65 Egyptians held in Israeli jails.

The daily reported that Egyptian authorities have also been in contact with their Israeli counterparts in order to ascertain the conditions of Egyptian prisoners who last month joined hundreds of Paleostinian prisoners in an indefinite hunger strike.

Tarabin, 31, has been held in Egypt since 1999, when he was sentenced in absentia under the country's Emergency Law to 15 years in prison for espionage.

The Tarabin Beduin are a large tribe spread across the Negev and Sinai. In the Negev, the Tarabins' territory is concentrated around Beersheba, while in Sinai, their lands are situated along the Israeli border south of the resort of El- Arish as well as on the Gulf of Suez and on the Red Sea around Nuweiba.

Since the mid-1990s the tribe has been heavily involved in smuggling, both across the Egypt-Israel border and to the Gazoo Strip. Still, the Israeli government and Tarabin's family have rejected accusations of espionage as baseless, and the prisoner's brother maintains he had crossed into Egypt merely to visit their sister in El-Arish.

Speculation over Tarabin's release began during last year's US-mediated Egyptian-Israeli negotiations for the release of Ilan Grapel, an Israeli-American law student held for nearly five months on charges of spying for Israel. Grapel was freed last October year in exchange for 25 Egyptian security prisoners.

At the time, Druse MK Ayoub Kara (Likud) unsuccessfully lobbied US Ambassador Daniel Shapiro to include Tarabin in the deal.

In 1996 Azzam Azzam, an Israeli Druse textile worker, was sentenced to 15 years of hard labor after being convicted of espionage, a charge both he and the Israeli government firmly denied. Following the intervention of the Shin Bet (Israel Security Agency), Azzam was released in 2004 in exchange for six Egyptians convicted of planning terror attacks. Tarabin now occupies the same cell in a Cairo jail where Azzam was once held.
Link


Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Another Israel-Egypt swap in works?
2011-10-29
Three prisoner swaps in one month? Bedouin Israeli Ouda Tarabin, who has been imprisoned in Egypt for 11 years now, will be returning to Israel next month as part of a prisoner swap with Israel, Kuwaiti daily al-Jarida reported Saturday.

According to a senior Egyptian official, Tarabin will be released after the Feast of Sacrifice, a Muslim holiday that will be celebrated in mid-November this year.

The swap, which is expected to resemble the recent Ilan Grapel deal, will see Tarabin released from prison in exchange for Egyptian inmates held in Israel. According to the same source, this time the Jewish state will release "political prisoners" rather than detainees held for drug or weapon smuggling offences.

The Egyptian official did not say how many prisoners will be freed by Israel in the framework of the swap, but stressed that Cairo is engaging in negotiations in order to "gain the greatest profits." He hinted that "additional spies" may be discovered in Egyptian jails and prompt further negotiations.
"Awright, which one of you is Brian?"
"I'm Brian!"
"I'M Brian!"
"I'm Brian, and so's my wife!"
Tarabin was detained in Egypt some 11 years ago and imprisoned after being convicted of espionage. In the wake of the Grapel swap, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said that Israel's government will do everything in order to secure Tarabin's release as well.
Link


Africa North
Ex-army official claims Egypt to receive jets in swap for Israeli Ilan Grapel
2011-10-28
Egypt (Ma'an) -- A former Egyptian major general and military expert says the deal to release suspected Israeli spy Ilan Grapel was less about prisoners and more about agreements between America and Cairo.

Sameh el-Yazal said Egypt asked the Americans to include Israel in the deal "as a third party" in order to increase the weight of the agreement and bring citizens home.

Egypt has failed to conclude recent agreements with the US that would allow it to purchase F16 fighter jets, as Israel pressured the Americans to prevent the sale of some weaponry to Cairo, he says.
Not to mention that Egypt is about to have starving mobs roaming the streets. Selling them more fighter jets would be throwing an anvil to a man drowning in the ocean
This time, however, Egypt reached an agreement to receive F16s from the US while the Americans mediated with Israel to release over 20 detainees in exchange for an American-Israeli national, el-Yazal says.
I have an idea: let Israel trade their F-16s to Egypt; in return we let Israel buy some F-22s.
A US State Department spokeswoman did not return calls Thursday.
Later they issued a statement denying any connection between the sale of F-16s and Grapel's release.
In 2009, the US and Egypt reached an agreement over a contract for 24 F16s to Egypt, officials said at the time. It was to be implemented sometime in 2010, officials said. Egypt's Air Force is estimated to be the fourth largest F16 operator in the world.

An Egyptian military official told Ma'an that Egypt refused to free suspected spy Odeh Tarabin, another Israeli national who was jugged in 2000, along with Grapel in exchange for 81 Egyptian prisoners. Tarabin has been sentenced to 25 years in prison for spying for Israel.
Link


Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Ilan Grapel returned to Israel, to leave Friday for America
2011-10-28
Publicly thanked the Israeli and American officials who got him released and the Egyptian authorities who treated him so well "in accordance to the tenets of their religion," ate a hamburger and French fries with Prime Minister Netanyahu, and prepared to fly home to America with his parents in the morning.

From the comment thread following the article:

(rant on)

Ilan Grapel: "I want to thank the Israeli people..."

Great. You're welcome. Be thankful we only had to release some drug dealers and other criminals trying to undermine Israel to get you out of there, and not 1027 terrorists.

Now, what the heck were you thinking going there in the first place in the middle of their revolution? Did you think that was a smart place for an Israeli American Jew who had served in the IDF to be, in Tahrir Square in Cairo of all places. Your idiocy is astounding. At least, your family must be relieved you're out of there. Tell us, are you thinking of going back to another Arab Muslim country so they can arrest you again on any trumped up charge? Your walking around Tahrir Square with the kipa on your head shows everyone you must be mentally challenged.

(rant off)
Link


Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Egypt, Israel agree to swap alleged spy for prisoners
2011-10-25
Egypt and Israel said Monday they have finalized arrangements to exchange an alleged Israeli spy for 25 Egyptians held in Israeli jails, on the heels of a Hamas-Israel prisoner swap. "A final agreement has been reached to release Israeli spy Ilan Grapel for 25 Egyptian prisoners, including three children," Egypt's state TV said. The swap is expected to take place "in the next two days."

Grapel, a dual US-Israeli national held since June 12, is accused of being an agent of Israel's Mossad spy agency and of sowing sectarian strife during Egypt's uprising which ousted president Hosni Mubarak in February. Israel has strongly denied the charges, insisting the whole thing was a mistake and accusing Egyptian authorities of "bizarre behavior."
Link


Africa North
Dupe URL: Egyptians more valuable than Palestinians
2011-10-23
Or so the official rumour mill reports.
Egypt will release suspected Mossad agent Ilan Grapel in exchange for 19 Egyptian prisoners being held in Israeli jails, Egypt's MENA News Agency reported on Saturday.

Egypt's state-run Nile TV reported that Grapel would be released for 28 prisoners.

Previous reports had suggested that Grapel would be released for 81 prisoners.
Link


Africa North
Egyptians more valuable than Palestinians
2011-10-23
Or so the official rumour mill reports.
Egypt will release suspected Mossad agent Ilan Grapel in exchange for 19 Egyptian prisoners being held in Israeli jails, Egypt's MENA News Agency reported on Saturday.
"We'll trade your Zionist spy for 1000 Egyptians held in Zionist jails!"
"We don't have a thousand Egyptians in our jails!"

Egypt's state-run Nile TV reported that Grapel would be released for 28 prisoners.
"Then how about if we release him in exchange for 500 al-Masris?"
"Nope. We don't have 500 denizens of the Land of the Nile."
"250?"
"Nope."
"How about 81?"
"We don't... Wait. Let me take a look."

Previous reports had suggested that Grapel would be released for 81 prisoners.
More here:
Grapel is a US-Israeli dual citizen Egypt charges with spying, sedition and inciting Egyptians to violence during the 18-day revolution that unseated president Hosni Mubarak. The 27-year-old's release was reportedly worked out as part of the deal that brought home Gilad Schalit last week after five years in Hamas captivity.
That explains, in part, the delay: the Egyptians wanted their cut as well.
Last week Egyptian media reported Cairo was expecting to receive all 81 Egyptians jugged in Israel - most of them on charges of illegal entry, drug trafficking and arms possession.
"Yeah. We got 81. You want them all? The narcos and the button men, too?"
"Sure! We... Ummm... Lemme check with my government."

Grapel emigrated to Israel in 2005 from New York and served in the IDF during the 2006 Leb War, where he was maimed in action. Currently enrolled as a law student at Emory University in Atlanta, Grapel was at the time of his arrest working for Saint Andrew's Refugee Services, a non-governmental organization, in Cairo. Friends, family and US and Israeli officials have dismissed the charges against him as "bizarre" and "ludicrous."
"How many is that without the narcos?"
"28."
"And without the button men?"
"19."
"We'll take it."

Link


Africa North
'Cairo wants dozens of prisoners in exchange for Grapel'
2011-10-12
‘Al-Ahram:’ Egyptians seek release of inmates held in jails in Israel and the United States in return for alleged spy

Egypt is demanding the release of dozens of Egyptian prisoners in Israel in return for Ilan Grapel, the American- Israeli law student detained in Cairo since June on suspicion of spying for Jerusalem.

Al-Ahram newspaper reported that a top-ranking Egyptian military official discussed an Egyptian-Israeli prisoner exchange during US Defense Secretary Leon Panetta’s visit to Cairo last week. The deal would reportedly include some 25 of the 80 Egyptians held in Israel, most of them convicted of security-related offenses or border infiltration. The paper reported that some two dozen Egyptians could be released from US prisons as well.

Egyptian media have reported that Washington has threatened to reduce military aid to Egypt if Grapel remains detained, but has indicated willingness to increase aid should the US-Israeli dual citizen be released. Reports that Grapel could leave Cairo with the defense secretary turned out to be premature.

US and Israeli officials, and Grapel’s family and friends, have dismissed allegations of espionage as “absurd,” and say the 27-year-old Emory University law student traveled to Egypt to volunteer with an organization aiding African refugees.

Maj.-Gen. Sameh Seif El-Yazel, described by Al-Ahram as a security expert, said a prisoner exchange could pave the way for discussions of modifying national security and armament agreements between Egypt and Israel.

“[T]here is a desire by both sides to hold a more critical dialogue about issues that were previously probed infrequently,” he said. “It would not do Egypt any good to keep the spy behind bars when there can be more benefits – this is standard procedure on such matters in most countries.”

This weekend the daily quoted Mohamed Said Lotfi, head of the campaign to free Egyptian prisoners from Israeli jails, as saying Grapel should not be released but should be tried as a spy.

“However, if he must be released, then the deal should be in return for the release of all Egyptian prisoners in Israeli jails,” he said.

Al-Ahram also reported that the son of Omar Abdel-Rahman (also known as the “Blind Sheikh”) has filed a request for his father to be included in a prospective exchange. Abdel- Rahman, leader of the radical group Al-Gama’a al-Islamiyaa, is serving a life sentence in North Carolina for seditious conspiracy for his part in planning and promoting a series of terrorist attacks on US targets.

On Monday the Islamist group held a protest outside the American Embassy in Cairo calling for Abdel-Rahman’s release.

Last week Deputy Regional Development Minister Ayoob Kara asked US Ambassador Daniel Shapiro to demand that along with Grapel, Cairo release Ouda Tarabin, an Israeli Beduin shepherd held in Egypt for more than a decade after illegally crossing the border.

“This is the last chance [to secure Tarabin’s release] before the rise of the Muslim Brotherhood. Everyone knows what they will do and what his fate will be,” the Likud lawmaker said.

In 1999 Tarabin was sentenced under Egypt’s Emergency Law to 15 years in prison for espionage, a crime his family and the Israeli government say he did not commit.

In 1996 Azzam Azzam, a Druse-Israeli textile worker, was sentenced to 15 years of hard labor after being convicted of espionage, a charge both he and the Israeli government denied. Following the intervention of the Shin Bet, Azzam was released in 2004 in exchange for six Egyptians convicted of planning terror attacks.
Link


Africa North
'Cairo wants dozens of prisoners in exchange for Grapel'
2011-10-12
'Al-Ahram:' Egyptians seek release of inmates held in jails in Israel and the United States in return for alleged spy
Returning to an old fashioned Arab tradition. Once upon a time they did this kind of thing in Montezuma, but then they gave it up for some reason.
Egypt is demanding the release of dozens of Egyptian prisoners in Israel in return for Ilan Grapel, the American- Israeli law student jugged in Cairo since June on suspicion of spying for Jerusalem.
No.
Al-Ahram newspaper reported that a top-ranking Egyptian military official discussed an Egyptian-Israeli prisoner exchange during US Defense Secretary Leon Panetta
...current SecDef, previously Director of the Central Intelligence Agency. Panetta served as President Bill Clinton's White House Chief of Staff from 1994 to 1997 and was a member of the United States House of Representatives from 1977 to 1993....
's visit to Cairo last week. The deal would reportedly include some 25 of the 80 Egyptians held in Israel, most of them convicted of security-related offenses or border infiltration. The paper reported that some two dozen Egyptians could be released from US prisons as well.
"...And a pony with a long pink mane for me to brush!"
Egyptian media have reported that Washington has threatened to reduce military aid to Egypt if Grapel remains jugged, but has indicated willingness to increase aid should the US-Israeli dual citizen be released. Reports that Grapel could leave Cairo with the defense secretary turned out to be premature.

US and Israeli officials, and Grapel's family and friends, have dismissed allegations of espionage as "absurd," and say the 27-year-old Emory University law student traveled to Egypt to volunteer with an organization aiding African refugees.

Maj.-Gen. Sameh Seif El-Yazel, described by Al-Ahram as a security expert, said a prisoner exchange could pave the way for discussions of modifying national security and armament agreements between Egypt and Israel.

"[T]here is a desire by both sides to hold a more critical dialogue about issues that were previously probed infrequently," he said. "It would not do Egypt any good to keep the spy behind bars when there can be more benefits -- this is standard procedure on such matters in most countries."

This weekend the daily quoted Mohamed Said Lotfi, head of the campaign to free Egyptian prisoners from Israeli jails, as saying Grapel should not be released but should be tried as a spy.

"However,
those who apply themselves too closely to little things often become incapable of great things...
if he must be released, then the deal should be in return for the release of all Egyptian prisoners in Israeli jails," he said.

Al-Ahram also reported that the son of Omar Abdel-Rahman (also known as the "Blind Sheikh") has filed a request for his father to be included in a prospective exchange. Abdel- Rahman, leader of the radical group Al-Gama'a al-Islamiyaa, is serving a life sentence in North Carolina for seditious conspiracy for his part in planning and promoting a series of terrorist attacks on US targets.

On Monday the Islamist group held a protest outside the American Embassy in Cairo calling for Abdel-Rahman's release.

Last week Deputy Regional Development Minister Ayoob Kara asked US Ambassador Daniel Shapiro to demand that along with Grapel, Cairo release Ouda Tarabin, an Israeli Beduin shepherd held in Egypt for more than a decade after illegally crossing the border.

"This is the last chance [to secure Tarabin's release] before the rise of the Moslem Brüderbund. Everyone knows what they will do and what his fate will be," the Likud politician said.

In 1999 Tarabin was sentenced under Egypt's Emergency Law to 15 years in prison for espionage, a crime his family and the Israeli government say he did not commit.

In 1996 Azzam Azzam, a Druse-Israeli textile worker, was sentenced to 15 years of hard labor after being convicted of espionage, a charge both he and the Israeli government denied. Following the intervention of the Shin Bet, Azzam was released in 2004 in exchange for six Egyptians convicted of planning terror attacks.
Link


Africa North
Egypt charges Grapel with setting fire to police stations
2011-10-12
In addition to espionage, American-Israeli is accused of throwing fire bombs at Egyptian Interior Ministry following revolution, 'Al-Ahram' reports.
"She turned me into a newt!"
Egypt added setting fire to cop shoppes to the list of charges faced by American-Israeli law student Ilan Grapel, who has been jugged in Cairo since June on suspicion of spying for Jerusalem, state-run Egyptian newspaper Al-Ahram reported on Monday.

The state reportedly accused Grapel of throwing fire bombs at police headquarters at the Egyptian Interior Ministry in the wake of Egypt's January revolution, based on witness statements. The charges are in addition to espionage.

US and Israeli officials, and Grapel's family and friends, have dismissed allegations of espionage as "absurd," and say the 27-year-old Emory University law student traveled to Egypt to volunteer with an organization aiding African refugees.

Grapel's parents were allowed to visit him for the first time late last month, along with US Consul-General to Egypt, Robert Powers.

He served in the IDF and was maimed in the Second Leb War, an incident that was well publicized.

An Egyptian court ruled to extend the remand of Grapel by 45 days on September 14, Al-Ahram reported.

Grapel was set to sit in solemn silence in a dull, dark dock, in a pestilential prison with a life-long lock at his downtown Cairo hotel by Egyptian state security officers in June on suspicion of working for Israeli intelligence to foment sectarian strife and gather intelligence on post-revolution Egypt.
Link



Warning: Undefined property: stdClass::$T in /data/rantburg.com/www/pgrecentorg.php on line 132
-12 More