Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Al-Qaeda involved in attack on Ingush president |
2006-04-22 |
The Russian Prosecutor General's Office says it has evidence pointing to the involvement of Al Qaeda emissaries in the terrorist act perpetrated against Ingush President Murat Zyazikov in April 2004. A CD recording of the terrorist act was found in the home of the father-in-law of Al-Qaeda emissary Abu Dzeit in the village of Tsotsin Yurt in Chechnya's Kurchaloi district, Deputy Prosecutor General Nikolai Shepel told Interfax. "Investigators verified the information and confirmed that they were dealing with a recording of the terrorist act against Zyazikov. The CD caption (blasting Zyazik) was another proof that they were right," Shepel said. Notorious warlord Shamil Basayev claimed responsibility for the terrorist act. "Obviously, Abu Dzeit, who was killed last year, took part in the planning of the terrorist act," he said. |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Count Dooku profile |
2006-01-10 |
From a (sorta) pro-Chechen source, but still some good info.![]() A veteran of the 1994-96 war, Umarov served as security minister in Aslan Maskhadov's postwar government. Umarov began the current war in 1999 as a field commander working closely with warlord Ruslan Gelaev. After the dual disasters of the evacuation of Grozny and the battle of Komsomolskoe in early 2000, Umarov and Gelaev crossed the mountains into the Pankisi Gorge of Georgia, where they rebuilt their commands. Georgian intelligence reported Umarov leading 130-150 fighters in the Gorge before his return to Chechnya in the summer of 2002 (Civil Georgia, January 20, 2003). Gelaev gave Umarov several Strela missiles, which Umarov's forces used to good effect against Russian helicopters in the fighting around Shatoi in 2003 (Chechenpress, December 4, 2002). Gelaev was killed in February 2004 after a disastrous attempt to lead a group of fighters over the mountains of Dagestan into Georgia. After Gelaev's death, many of his men joined Umarov's command. Russian security services created a scenario based on the alleged testimony of a prisoner (Baudi Khadzhiev) in which Umarov urged Gelaev to undertake an operation in Dagestan that he knew would be fatal in order to take over Gelaev's command. The allegation was part of a long tradition of Russian reports about feuding commanders and dissension in the Chechen ranks. Gelaev's family was quick to point out that their clan and the Umarov family are closely related (an important consideration in clan-conscious Chechnya). In early February of this year, Russian security suggested that Umarov and Basaev were arranging a meeting of Chechen and Arab field commanders in Grozny to mark the one-year anniversary of Gelaev's death (Vremya no. 16, February 2, 2005). Later in the month Maj.-Gen. Ilya Shabalkin, spokesman for the Russian command in the North Caucasus, claimed that Russian special forces had destroyed three units of Umarov's command on their way to Azerbaijan to wipe out Gelaev's family at a ceremony marking the first anniversary of Gelaev's death. The family's alleged declaration of blood vengeance against Umarov provided the motive. The details of this unlikely plot came from the interrogation of a mortally wounded Chechen (RIA Novosti, February 25, 2005). Several Ingush clans have also been reported as having declared blood vengeance against Umarov as a result of deaths suffered in the Nazran operation of 2004. Like most Chechen field commanders, Umarov has been declared dead on several occasions. In the last year Russian forces have intensified their efforts to eliminate him. In January 2005, he was reported killed in a gun battle with Russian commandos near the Georgian border. In March, Umarov was reported as having been seriously wounded by a spetsnaz assassination team. After stepping on a landmine sometime later, Umarov was reported to have lost a leg, but was only injured. In April, Russian special forces destroyed a small guerrilla unit in a sevenâhour battle in Grozny after receiving intelligence that Umarov was with them, but he was not found among the dead. Umarov struck back in an attack on Roshni-Chu in August, but in September the Russian Interior Ministry declared victory over Umarov's fighters, finding Umarov's "grave" in the process. In October, Umarov was again reported dead in the raid on Nalchik. In a new tactic designed to put pressure on resistance leaders, masked men in uniform abducted Umarov's father, brother, wife and baby. Umarov believes those responsible are members of the "Oil Regiment," a notorious loyalist unit better known for kidnappings than its nominal mission of guarding pipelines. Chechen Duma Deputy Ruslan Yamadaev suggests that Umarov is currently part of Basaev's "terrorist wing" of the Chechen resistance, but Umarov distanced himself from Basaev after the latter claimed responsibility for the Beslan outrage (Interfax, March 9, 2005). Only a few months earlier, Umarov had played a leading role with Basaev in organizing the military assault on Nazran in Ingushetia (June 21-22, 2004). Umarov firmly refuted the value of terrorist attacks such as Beslan: "In the eyes of the resistance such operations have no legitimacy," he said. "We ourselves were horrified by what they did in Beslan" (RFE/RL, July 28, 2005). During the crisis Umarov was repeatedly identified by security services as the leader of the Beslan hostage-takers, a claim that has never been substantiated in any fashion. Umarov emphasized the military nature of his own war: "Our targetsâthese are the Russian occupation forces, their bases, command HQ's, and also their armed servicemen from the numbers of local collaborationists, who pursue and who kill peaceful Muslims. We will attack, where we think it's necessary. Civil objects and innocent civilians are not our targets" (Kavkaz Centre, July 1, 2004). I think they're being a little too credulous of Doku here. In May 2005 , Maj. Gen. Shabalkin accused Umarov of joining warlord Shamil Basaev and President Sadulaev in planning a suicide truck-bombing in Grozny. The trio were also said to be planning large-scale civilian massacres in several towns of the North Caucasus by using cyanide "in highly populated areas, key installations and in reservoirs." A Jordanian emissary of both al-Qaeda and the Muslim Brotherhood allegedly provided the cyanide. Proof of the plot was provided in the form of a photo of a Russian in a white lab-coat holding a vial of clear liquid, identified as cyanide. The strategic advantage the Chechen leadership might hope to gain through committing such outrageous atrocities remains unexplained. The allegations came at the same time Sadulaev was trying in his public statements to distance the resistance from terrorist methods. Um, no offense but you could sorta say the same thing about Beslan or the 2002 theater hostage seige. That didn't stop Basayev from doing it ... Four days after Shabalkin made these allegations, Umarov responded by promising large-scale military activities within Russia before the end of the year. This promise seems to have been fulfilled by the October raid in Nalchik, in which Umarov played a leading role (Chechenpress, May 9, 2005). Umarov is one of the last veteran commanders from the 1994-96 Chechen-Russian war still alive and active in the fighting. He bears the scars and limp of multiple wounds, but his commitment to the conflict remains inflexible. He regards death in battle as an inevitability, and has publicly expressed his hope that those Chechen men who have not fully participated in the war "will all burn in the fire of Hell!" Although Umarov admits he has grown much closer to Islam during the last decade of conflict, he is openly scornful of suggestions that he is a "Wahhabi" or radical Islamist: "I have a whole [military] front," he said. "I go along that front and I don't see people fighting to bring the world Wahhabism or terror" (RFE/RL, July 28, 2005). It is unlikely that Umarov's new role as vice-president will interfere with his ongoing military operations. These days there is not a great deal of paperwork to do in the resistance government. Nevertheless, the appointment was hardly symbolic, considering the record of three successive violent deaths of Chechen presidents (four including the Russian-backed presidency of Akhmad Kadyrov). In the volatile and dangerous world of Chechen politics, Dokku Umarov now stands next in line for the leadership of the Chechen resistance, barring renewed aspirations for this role by Shamil Basaev. |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Ex-Guantanamo Prisoner Detained in Russia |
2005-11-12 |
![]() Deputy Prosecutor General Nikolai Shepel said witnesses, along with Kudayev's own confessions, confirmed his involvement in preparing and carrying out the Oct. 13 attacks on government and law enforcement offices in Nalchik, the capital of the troubled Kabardino-Balkariya region. At least 139 people died in the nearly simultaneous daytime assaults on law enforcement offices, including the 94 accused attackers, according to official tallies. Shepel said more than 40 people have been detained on suspicion of involvement. Alexandra Zernova, a lawyer for Kudayev, said that her client was physically too weak to participate in the attacks and said he had been tortured into confessing. Kudayev was imprisoned at Guantanamo Bay after being captured in Afghanistan and linked to the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan, a terror group with alleged ties to al-Qaida. Since his release last year, he and his family have been repeatedly harassed by police, said his mother, Fatimat Takayeva. Shepel also said that Ruslan Nakhushev, a respected Islamic expert and well-known government critic who has been missing since being questioned by security officers Nov. 4, has been charged with instigating the attack. |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
4 arrested in Beslan back-up plot (Ingush school targeted) |
2005-09-05 |
Four people have been arrested on suspicion of planning to seize a school in Ingushetia if the Sept. 1, 2004, attack in Beslan had failed, Deputy Prosecutor General Nikolai Shepel said Saturday. Shepel said the four suspects would be tried for involvement in a plot to seize the school in the Ingush village of Nesterovskaya. He did not give their identities or say when the arrests took place. "They are giving evidence, including on the organization of the terrorist act in Beslan," Shepel said, Interfax reported. He said Chechen rebel warlord Shamil Basayev had prepared a reserve plan to seize hostages in Nesterovskaya in case the Beslan raid did not succeed. On Friday, Shepel said police and security forces had killed an accomplice to the Beslan militants, Interfax reported. The Ingush Interior Ministry said it had no such information. Alikhan Mirzoyev was killed Friday in a private home after resisting arrest, the ministry said. |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Failed assassination attempt against Ingush leader |
2005-08-25 |
Two bombs exploded Thursday on a roadside in Ingushetia, wounding the southern Russian republic's prime minister in an apparent assassination attempt, officials said - the latest sign of growing violence across the heavily Muslim North Caucasus region. Ingushetia Prime Minister Ibragim Malsagov was hospitalized after the attack in the city of Nazran, but his life was not in danger, said Fyodor Shcherbakov, an aide to the Kremlin envoy to the region. Malsagov's driver was killed and two other people were wounded in addition to Malsagov, said Nikolai Ivashkevich, a spokesman for the southern regional branch of the Emergency Situations Ministry. Malsagov, the second highest-ranking official in the region, was hurt in the hand and the leg. The top police official in Ingushetia, Interior Minister Beslan Khamkhoyev, said two explosives placed about 10-15 yards apart detonated within 10 seconds, the Interfax news agency reported. The attack occurred near one of the city's outdoor markets as Malsagov's motorcade passed. Lying in a hospital bed with bandages wrapped around his head and hand, Malsagov told state-run Channel One television that he had been traveling on a road near his home in the middle of a three-car motorcade when there was an explosion in front by the first vehicle. ``Naturally, I automatically jumped out to run over and see what happened, and then there was another explosion,'' Malsagov said. He blamed ``forces that want to destabilize the situation.'' Russian television networks showed footage of what appeared to be Malsagov's black Mercedes, its rear window a maze of cracked glass, and of a deep crater by the roadside. Nazran is the main city in the Ingushetia region, which has suffered frequent spillover violence from neighboring Chechnya to the east, as well as attacks by its own militants and criminal gangs. The top prosecutor for southern Russia, Deputy Prosecutor General Nikolai Shepel, said in televised comments that the attack seemed to have ``the same signature'' as other terrorist attacks that have struck the North Caucasus, adding, ``I mean the international organizations that unfortunately are present in the south of Russia.'' Russian authorities are eager to link their fight against militants in the North Caucasus with the international struggle against terror, and often point to alleged international involvement in attacks in the region. Government critics say flawed Kremlin ethnic policy and corruption among regional leaders are major causes of the violence. Last week, Nazran police chief Dzhabrail Kostoyev was wounded when unknown assailants detonated a radio-controlled land mine as his car was passing. The republic's police and security forces were also targeted in a devastating overnight assault by militants in June 2004, in which some 90 people were killed. Chechen rebel leader Shamil Basayev claimed responsibility for that attack and for the hostage crisis that killed more than 330 people last September at a school in Beslan in North Ossetia, which borders both Chechnya and Ingushetia. The republic on Chechnya's eastern border, Dagestan, has also been plagued by frequent bombings and other attacks targeting government and law enforcement officials. Authorities in other republics of the North Caucasus have also battled militants they say are Islamic extremists. Analysts have expressed concern that major violence could break out in the region even as Russian and local government officials assert that life is returning to normal in Chechnya, devastated by two separatist wars in the past decade. In the Stavropol region, north of the band of largely Muslim republics, one police officer a two gunmen were killed in a shootout Thursday in the village of Yanangui, a duty officer at the regional Interior Ministry said. Another gunman was detained. The Interfax news agency quoted an unidentified regional police official as saying the gunmen were suspected Islamic extremists. |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Basayev's claim of non-involvement in Beslan is a lie |
2005-07-29 |
Russian Deputy Prosecutor General Nikolai Shepel said Chechen warlord Shamil Basayev's claim that he was not involved in last year's school siege in the North Ossetia town of Beslan was a lie. "Terrorist Basayev's statement that denies his involvement in the death of hundreds of children in Beslan is a total lie. His guilt in numerous crimes, including the death of Beslan children, has been fully confirmed by both the materials from the criminal cases and the testimony given by guerrillas, including Nurpasha Kulayev, the only [Beslan] raid participant who survived" the operation conducted by special forces to release the hostages, Shepel said. |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Basayev involved in Znamenskoye attack |
2005-07-27 |
![]() Shepel made this statement in remarks about media reports saying that Basayev has claimed responsibility for the blast in Znamenskoye which left 14 people dead, most of them policemen. Shepel also said that Basayev and another Chechen guerilla leader Doku Umarov's involvement in the terrorist attack has figured in the probe as the main theory. "Intelligence suggests that Basayev's group is the most likely organizer of the attack. But northern Chechnya is controlled by Umarov, so his involvement in the terror attack is also being checked," Shepel said. "If Basayev's complicity is proved, one more episode will be added to the criminal charges brought against him," he said. Shepel said that among the suspects already detained, is the owner of the motor vehicle blown up in Znamenskoye. |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Search for truth in Beslan trial |
2005-06-17 |
"You should be killed and your body thrown to the pigs!" was the daily curse that mothers of children killed in last September's Beslan school attack hurled at the sole surviving hostage-taker, Nur-Pashi Kulayev, when he went on trial in a Vladikavkaz court last month. Yet as Kulayev's version of events inside the school unfolded, it contradicted the version put forward by the authorities in crucial details. As the hearings continued, the women's attitude began to change. After having heard officials publicly lie about the number of hostages inside the school and make other contradictory statements during the crisis, the mothers said they had no confidence in the prosecutor's version of events and found Kulayev's testimony more plausible. Some even started to show signs of sympathy for the suspected terrorist as he told his story of the storming of Beslan's School No. 1, in which more than 330 hostages, many of them children, died. "They've dumped the blame onto this one man; they've found a scapegoat," said a voice from the crowd of relatives and witnesses at the North Ossetian Supreme Court as a handcuffed Kulayev was led past them on Tuesday. The relatives say they believe this haggard and gloomy young man, who avoids looking them in the eyes and speaks in stumbling Russian from the defendant's steel cage, is their only hope to learn the truth about what happened to their loved ones. They say they are even prepared to ask the judge for leniency or a pardon, if Kulayev can tell them the truth. "We need him to tell the truth. And we need for no force to be used against him by interested institutions. ... We need to be confident that he won't die of a heart attack or fall down the stairs," Susanna Dudiyeva, who leads the activist group Committee of Beslan Mothers, said in court Tuesday. At a hearing last week, Kulayev testified that a bomb that had been set up by the hostage-takers detonated on Sept. 3 after Russian snipers shot a gunman who was keeping his foot on the detonators. This contradicted what the authorities said, which was that a bomb in the school gym, where the more than 1,200 hostages were being held, went off after it fell from a basketball hoop. The official version had the bomb going off after tape fixing it to the hoop came loose because of heat and humidity, causing it to fall. The explosion set off the storming of the building by security services and local vigilantes, in which hundreds of hostages died in a hail of bullets and explosions. Kulayev was among a group of 33 gunmen who had been sent by Chechen warlord Shamil Basayev and had arrived at the school early on the morning of Sept. 1. He told the court that there were other gunmen inside who opened fire into the crowd of children and parents in the schoolyard. He testified that the gunmen had so much arms and ammunition that they could not have brought it all with them. Kulayev's account tallied with claims by Beslan residents that the terrorists had prepared the raid well in advance and hidden supplies of weapons at the school. Federal officials have denied that such a weapons cache existed, though several witnesses among the hostages said it did. Kulayev's statements also contradicted the official account that there were only 33 attackers, and that none of them managed to flee the school. Prosecutors say they are not surprised by Kulayev's revelations. "This is his line of defense," Deputy Prosecutor General Nikolai Shepel, the lead prosecutor in the case, said last week. But for those who have lost relatives, Kulayev's testimony appears to fit with their suspicions of a coverup by the authorities, whom they blame as much as the terrorists for the bloody conclusion to the hostage-taking drama. "I will claim all the compensation from the state. What use is there in seeking damages from Kulayev?" Alexander Gumetsev, whose daughter was killed in the school, said at the courthouse on Tuesday. In total, 1,343 people are registered as plaintiffs in the case, in which Kulayev faces life in prison if convicted of all charges. He has denied all but one charge: participating in an illegal armed formation, the legal term the state uses for rebel fighters in Chechnya. After survivors and hostages' relatives showed irritation with Kulayev's long hair on the first day of the trial, Kulayev's head was shaved. During the trial, Kulayev said that his testimony in court was different from what he was reported as saying during the investigation because of his poor knowledge of Russian and that he had signed interrogation protocols without reading them. Dudiyeva asked him Tuesday whether he had been beaten during the investigation. "How come they haven't been beating me? Of course, I was beaten," he said. What followed, no one predicted. "If you tell the truth, we are ready to appeal for a pardon for you," Dudiyeva said. "Just tell the truth about what you know." Prosecutor Maria Semisynova reacted by saying in a mocking tone that maybe Kulayev's status in the trial should be changed from that of defendant to victim. "Who set up the booby traps and hung the bombs in the gym that exploded and killed your children?" Semisynova said. "Were these people not terrorists?" Also on Tuesday, the plaintiffs announced that they would demand to have Kulayev's court-appointed defense lawyer, Albert Pliyev, changed, citing Pliyev's inertness in defending his client. In an interview with Izvestia last week, Pliyev said that he had agreed to take Kulayev's case after being begged to do so by the head of North Ossetian lawyers' association. Other lawyers in the republic had refused to defend Kulayev. Not all of the relatives and survivors believe that Kulayev deserves leniency. Natalya Salamova, whose daughter -- a teacher at the school -- died in the attack, told the court Thursday that Kulayev should be handed over to the mothers so they could tear him apart. During the same court session, Roza Alikova, who lost two sisters and three nephews in the attack, called for Kulayev's execution, even though capital punishment has been suspended in Russia, Interfax reported. Another witness and mother of one of the children held hostage, Ella Dzasarova, told the court Thursday that she saw Kulayev run around the gym on the first day of the hostage-taking, shouting curses at hostages and threatening to shoot them, the agency reported. Two psychiatrists who offered differing expert opinions in another high-profile North Caucasus court case, the murder trial of Colonel Yury Budanov, said they did not believe that survivors of the Beslan attack were suffering from "Stockholm syndrome," a condition that can occur when hostages come to sympathize with their captors and blame the authorities for their plight. "For this to happen, people need to put themselves in the place of a hostage-taker, to understand his motives," said Lyubov Vinogradova, a director at the Independent Psychiatric Association. "This is probably not the case at the Vladikavkaz court." The Serbsky Institute of Psychiatry's Tamara Pechernikova, a senior psychiatrist who during the Soviet era was involved in the cases of several prominent dissidents, said that the plaintiffs were pursuing the only available, and absolutely rational, strategy for learning the truth about the events that affected their lives so tragically. "Kulayev is the only person whom they believe may tell them something in the court that would allow them to demand punishment of all those guilty in what happened," she said. "After his sentence is announced -- and it will most probably be a long one -- these victims will demand more punishment for him," she said. |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Basayev planned suicide plane attack long before 9/11 |
2005-06-15 |
Chechen rebels planned to fly an airplane into the Kremlin 10 years ago, a top prosecutor said this week as Russia marked the 10th anniversary of the Shamil Basayev-led raid on Budyonnovsk where hundreds of civilians were taken hostage in June 1995. "The Prosecutor General's Office has reported that it has established the identity of 195 members of the Shamil Basayev gang, which committed the terrorist act in Budyonnovsk," the Moskovsky Komsomolets daily reported Wednesday. "Investigators have acquired data on 195 members of the gang. 30 were eliminated, another 20 convicted," Deputy Prosecutor General Nikolai Shepel said. An accomplice of the terrorists, Roza Dundayeva, testified that the gang originally intended to raid Mineralnye Vody in southern Russia but then the militants were forced to revise their plans, Shepel said. "The former head of the Federal Counterintelligence Service, Sergei Stepashin, announced that according to his information, the terrorists intended to reach Mineralnye Vody, to hijack a plane and then fly into the Kremlin." |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Basayev formed special unit for Beslan |
2005-05-18 |
Deputy Prosecutor General Nikolai Shepel told the court in Vladikavkaz that defendant Nurpasha Kulayev belonged to a group formed specially for capturing the school in Beslan by Shamil Basayev, Aslan Maskhadov and other Chechen field commanders. Shepel started reading the indictment against Kulayev in the North Ossetian Supreme Court on Tuesday. "Basayev, Maskhadov, Magomed Khashiyev and a Saudi Arabian national named Taufik al-Jadani, know as Abu-Dzeib - chiefs of numerous regular militant teams, in July to August 2004 planned a large-scale act of terrorism in North Ossetia involving hostage-taking and the murder of civilians and law enforcement officers," Shepel said. The organizers had the objective of undermining public security, intimidating the public and pressuring the authorities to withdraw federal troops from Chechnya, he said. "A group of over 30 persons from Chechnya, Ingushetia and other Russian territories and also foreign mercenaries was set up to carry out these criminal plans. Nurpasha Kulayev also joined in," Shepel said. At the beginning of the trial, responding to questions from the prosecution, Kulayev said he is married and has two children - a two- year-old son and one-year-old daughter. |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Hearing held for surviving Beslan killer |
2005-04-20 |
A court held preliminary hearings Tuesday for the only surviving suspected hostage-taker in last year's deadly school seizure in southern Russia, and his trial will begin May 17. The trial of Nur-Pashi Kulayev will take place in the Supreme Court of North Ossetia, the Russian province where the raid took place, and it will be open to the public, said Deputy Prosecutor General Nikolai Shepel. Chechen warlord Shamil Basayev has claimed responsibility for the attack in which a group of gunmen held more than 1,000 hostages in a school for nearly three days in the town of Beslan. The raid ended Sept. 3 in gunfire and explosions, killing 330 people more than half of them children. Shepel, the lead prosecutor in the case, said 317 of the victims were hostages and the others were 10 special forces officers, two emergency workers and one Beslan resident. Officials said that of 32 assailants who took part in the raid, 31 were killed. Shepel said the authorities had identified 20 of them, including two Chechen women who wore explosives belts around their waists. Kulayev has confessed to participating in the school raid, but insisted he didn't kill anyone. He has been charged with terrorism, hostage-taking, murder and attempts on the life of law enforcement officers among other charges. The charges carry either a life prison sentence or the death penalty. However, Russia has maintained a moratorium on the death penalty since 1996 as condition for joining the Council of Europe, the continent's leading human rights organization. The school hostage crisis was the deadliest in a string of terror attacks staged by militants outside Chechnya, where Russian forces are battling separatist rebels. President Vladimir Putin has ordered security forces to deal "more severely" with suspected Islamic militants in the south, and law enforcement agencies recently have launched a series of sweeps to target suspected extremists outside Chechnya. Shepel said violence in southern Russia was fomented by international terrorists striving to carve out an Islamic state in the Caucasus Mountains region, echoing a claim by Putin and other officials. Shepel's aide, Sergei Prokopov, said investigators uncovered evidence of international terrorist activity in the region while investigating the Beslan attack and a raid in December on a drug control agency office in the southern province of Kabardino-Balkariya. He did not elaborate. |
Link |
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia |
Maskhadov killed by his own men |
2005-04-03 |
Chechen rebel leader Aslan Maskhadov was shot by an aide at his request to avoid being captured alive, Deputy Prosecutor General Nikolai Shepel said Friday, in a remarkable departure from the previous official version of Maskhadov's death. "Maskhadov died from multiple bullet wounds that were inflicted at his request by individuals who were with him in the bunker," Shepel told reporters at his offices in Vladikavkaz, Interfax reported. "He had a suicide belt on him at the time, but he did not want to detonate it because he wanted his accomplices to live. So he asked them to shoot him," he said, Itar-Tass reported. The Federal Security Service, or FSB, has said Maskhadov was killed in a bunker during a raid by FSB commandos in the Chechen village of Tolstoy-Yurt on March 8. It said three aides who were with Maskhadov, as well as with the owner of the house above the bunker, were arrested during the raid. The detained rebels told investigators that one of them killed Maskhadov after FSB commandos blew up the top of the bunker and were preparing to move in, Shepel said, Interfax reported. In addition, investigators have confirmed that Maskhadov was killed with a gun and that the gun belonged to one of the detained rebels, Shepel said. Also, bullet holes in the bunker are consistent with the rebels' testimony, he said. Authorities destroyed the house over the bunker a short time after Maskhadov's death, saying they feared it contained booby traps. Offering one of the first accounts of Maskhadov's death, Chechen Deputy Prime Minister Ramzan Kadyrov said on March 8 that one of the rebel leader's bodyguards had accidentally shot him. The headquarters of the federal forces in Chechnya insisted that Maskhadov had died when FSB commandos tossed grenades into the bunker, and Kadyrov withdrew his account, calling it a joke. Kadyrov, however, said Friday that he had not been joking and that Shepel had effectively confirmed his initial account, Interfax reported. Shepel said officials who offered the earlier accounts of Maskhadov's death had jumped to conclusions, and that he was relating the findings of a careful investigation. "It was previously said that the death occurred from bullet injuries. But those injuries also could have been caused by a shock wave from an explosion," he said, RIA-Novosti reported. "The injuries had to be thoroughly examined, and that is why we ... gave experts time to conduct a complete examination." The FSB could not comment immediately about Shepel's remarks, an FSB spokesman said. The headquarters for federal forces in Chechnya could not be reached for comment Friday. Alexei Malashenko, an analyst at the Carnegie Moscow Center, noted that Shepel's account was politically convenient in light of Western regret that Moscow did not capture Maskhadov alive. The European Union has demanded an explanation about why Maskhadov was killed, and the Council of Europe, a human rights watchdog, has expressed regret that authorities lost the opportunity to bring Maskhadov to court. Gennady Gudkov, a member of the State Duma's Security Committee, complained that the latest statement on Maskhadov's death was only creating more confusion. "The more time goes by, the information that is made public gets more confusing and incomprehensible," he said, Interfax reported. Shepel also said Friday that forensic tests had confirmed that Maskhadov died March 8, RIA-Novosti reported. |
Link |