Hello !
| Europe |
| THE REFUGEE CRISIS EUROPE HELPED BRING ON ITSELF |
| 2015-09-06 |
| h/t Instapundit Europe is paying the second installment on the debt for its indifference to the slow-motion disaster in Syria. The first installment was (and will continue to be) an increase in the threat of domestic terrorism. The second installment is the mass migration of Syrians and other Middle Easterners into Europe. According to Johannes Hahn, the EU Commissioner for European Neighbourhood Policy and Enlargement Negotiation (we'll know the U.S. has hit bottom when we have such a commissioner and we're not far from having one, in effect) 20 million refugees are waiting on the doorstep of Europe. David Pryce-Jones points out that not all of them are genuine refugees in flight from civil war and tyranny. Some are riding the coattails of true victims. But the number of genuine refugees is staggering and tragic. The overwhelming majority of the 20 million are Muslim. Their presence would, according to Pryce-Jones, at least double the number of Muslims already in Europe. |
| Link |
| Africa North |
| US foreign policy implodes |
| 2013-08-19 |
| An awful lot of good commentary is emerging over the turmoil in Egypt. First Wretchard: What could be a more blatant attempt than that? If true then Putins openly trying to grab Egypt. Breitbart reports Egypt is sending a diplomatic mission to Russia. Sadat threw Russia out of Egypt, the source told Breitbart News. Peace came from that. If Russia reenters Egypt, they reenter the world. Are the reports true? But things may have reached a crisis. The Egyptian military is planning to outlaw the Muslim Brotherhood. That would put Obamas hand squarely in a vise. He may be forced to do what he loathes most: to take a definite, public stand that must alienate part of his international coalition. He has thrived so far by selling the same real estate to all comers; by being the blank slate who is each and every supplicants friend. But now he must anger somebody. Now somebodys asking for a refund. The web is rife with rumor that one side or the other is holding a scandal over the administrations head. There is no proof that any such scandal exists. But given the parade of scandals already too numerous to mention it cannot wholly be discounted that some such exists. So Obama remains hunkered down in Marthas Vineyard, emerging periodically from his vacation home, like a cuckoo from a clock, to make a statement no one appears to hear, playing for time. No one in the Beltway seems to know what line to take. Shall they restore democracy in Egypt by supporting the Muslims Bros, knowing they too will take their revenge on the generals and the Copts? Suspend aid to the Egyptian military and open the door to Russia, who might do a hat trick and scoop up Saudi Arabia into the bargain? And Mark Steyn: As a result, the factions in Egypt are united only in their contempt for Washington. Obama is despised by Sisi and the generals for being fundamentally unserious; by the Brotherhood for stringing along with the coup; by the Copts for standing by as the Brothers take it out on them; and by the small number of genuine democrats in Egypt for his witless promotion of Morsis thugs as the dawning of democracy. Any national-unity government of the kind the usual deluded twits are urging on Egypt would be united only in its unanimous loathing of Obama, his secretaries of state, and his inept ambassador. Meanwhile, out on the streets, Washington is reviled both for standing by Mubarak too long and for pushing him out too soon (eighty per cent of Egyptians say things are worse than under the old man). And, with the 2011 Facebook Revolution all out of Likes, the King of Jordan and the Gulf emirs understand the meaning of the ailing, abandoned strongman in his military prison cell in purely geopolitical terms that (as Bernard Lewis once warned) America is harmless as an enemy but treacherous as a friend. Whatever regime emerges in Cairo, it will be post-American. A year before the fall of Mubarak, David Pryce-Jones, in a conversational aside, quoted to me Lord Lloyd, British High Commissioner to the old Kingdom of Egypt in the Twenties: Ah, the jacarandas are in bloom. We shall soon be sending for the gunboats. Theres more wisdom about Arab springs in that line than in all the blather of Obama, Clinton, Kerry and Anne Patterson combined. |
| Link |
| Africa North | |
| Thoughts on Qaddafi | |
| 2011-10-25 | |
| David Pryce-Jones, National Review ...The capture, trial, and hanging of Saddam Hussein first showed Arabs that they could be masters of their fate. The so-called Arab Spring is the principal consequence. In one Arab country after another, people have risen in large numbers to prove that they are ready to oust rulers who have been inflicting needless injustices and cruelties on them. Like so many other Arabs, Libyans revolted earlier this year to demand to be heard. To a man of Qaddafi's character, reform is indistinguishable from surrender. He chose repression and rage, he cursed and threatened and set about killing. Western intervention alone has warded off what otherwise would have been the tyrant's vengeance. Qaddafi was found sheltering in a sewage drain, and then and there met the summary execution reserved for the Benito Mussolinis, Ceausescus, and their like. He deserved it, but the chance has been lost to bring him to court and confront him with his crimes. That might have been exemplary.
| |
| Link |
| -Obits- |
| Michael Foot, British socialist who lost to Iron Maggie, age 96 |
| 2010-03-04 |
David Pryce-Jones, National ReviewMichael Foot, the veteran Socialist trounced in a general election by Mrs. Thatcher, has died at the venerable age of 96. Perhaps it is only right and proper that the obituaries contain nothing but compliments to his oratory, his energy, his wide reading, his idealism, and all the rest of it. About his truculent assumption of moral and intellectual superiority there is no hint. To me, he represented the very worst features of the 1930s in which period his character was formed and became stuck.... ...For him, it was much better to be Red than Dead. I always used to imagine what role he would have played in the event of a Soviet invasion and take-over. Probably he would have refined the argument that we should all cooperate with the Soviets in order to mitigate what they would do if we opposed them. And perhaps they would have shot him because he'd given evidence of being ready for treason. And then along came Oleg Gordievsky, the most senior KGB officer ever to defect. Among other startling evidence, he informed us that Foot had taken money from the Soviets to subsidize Tribune, the hard Left socialist publication. Confronted with this, Foot said he couldn't remember. ... The obituaries that I have seen are silent about this, but that was when dread of what the man stood for turned into contempt for him. Couldn't remember a commitment like that? |
| Link |
| Terror Networks |
| Muslims: integration or separatism? |
| 2006-02-06 |
| Great article by David Pryce-Jones on the Islamist threat. Nothing here will surprise the regulars, but it is a great overview. Pryce-Jones has been rather sphinx-like on the eventuality of civilizational conflict. In my opinion he is one of the the best conservative commentators on the Arab world. While not staking out a personal position in this article, he nonetheless leans heavily towards the possibility of war. |
| Link |
| Home Front: WoT |
| Mark Steyn - All men are not equal |
| 2005-08-13 |
| Thereâs an abandoned town in Labrador called Davis Inlet. An Innu community â i.e., natives, of the Mushuau people, if youâre big on whoâs who in the Great White North. About a decade ago Canadians switched on their televisions and were confronted by âshockingâ images of the townâs populace passing the day snorting drugs, glue, petrol and pretty much anything else to hand. So, as any impeccably progressive soft-lefties would, Her Majestyâs Government in Ottawa decided to build the Mushuau a new town a few miles inland â state of the art, money no object, new homes, new heating systems, new schoolhouse, new computers, plus new more culturally respectful town name (Natuashish). Total cost to Canadian taxpayers: $152 million, which works out to about $217,142.85 for each of the townâs men, women and children. Got a wife and two kids and youâre looking at a government handout of about nine hundred thousand bucks. And the upshot of Canadian taxpayersâ generosity? Two years after the new town opened, the former Mushuau chief and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police both agreed that there were more drugs, alcoholism, gas-sniffing etc., than ever before. Also higher suicide rates. Gas-sniffing is not a traditional native activity. Before the first European settlers came, the Mushuau did not roam the tundra hunting for Toyota Corollas to siphon the tanks of. Thatâs a particularly perverse form of cultural co-mingling, but one in which âcompassionateâ white liberals seem determined to keep the natives mired. The government showers native communities with money; thereâs no economic downside to sniffing petrol all day; and as everyone in Natuashish is driving around in brand-new pick-ups on roads that go nowhere you might as well use that full tank of gas for something. The net result of 40 years of a âcaringâ policy intended to maintain communities in their traditional âcultureâ is that Canadian natives now have tuberculosis, diabetes, heart disease and brain damage at levels accelerating further and further away from those in society at large, not to mention lower life-expectancy, higher infant mortality, and endemic suicide. On the last point, the Canadian government doesnât give natives the rope with which they hang themselves, but they do give them free supplies of ammunition. (Natives have higher murder rates, too.) Identity-group grievance-mongers routinely go on about the first Europeans introducing disease to hitherto vigorous North American Indians four centuries ago, but the current health crises afflicting literally dying communities are of less concern. Nonetheless, the math seems unarguable: too many agonised white liberal multicultural chiefs leads to not enough Indians. Canadian natives, as the most comprehensively wrecked minority on the continent, are a microcosm of everything thatâs wrong with multiculturalism. The premise of multiculturalism is that all cultures are equally âvalidâ, but of course thatâs bunk: some cultures are better, some are worse, some are successes, some are failures. Iâm not being âEurocentricâ here. Perish the thought: an awful lot of European cultures have proved hopeless at sustaining over any length of time representative government, property rights, the rule of law and individual liberty. Those are largely features of the Britannic world â not just of the United Kingdom, America, Australia and New Zealand but also of India, Singapore, St Lucia, as well as Quebec and Mauritius, to name but two francophone jurisdictions all the more agreeable for having spent their formative years under the British Crown. Thatâs one reason why Iâm a Eurosceptic â because I donât think the British have anything to learn from the Belgians or Germans; on the other hand, the Belgians and Germans have quite a lot to learn from Belize and Barbados. The debate led by the editor of this magazine and others over this last month about promoting âBritishnessâ is perplexing to an offshore observer, if only because the superiority of the Britannic inheritance should be self-evident. Even in the dodgier parts of the globe, a good rule of thumb is head for the joint that was under British rule the longest: try doing business in Malaysia and then in Indonesia and youâll see what I mean. The fact is that the further you remove people from the Britannic inheritance, the greater disservice you do them â the unfortunate Innu of Davis Inlet, excluded from the normal currents of advanced society (home ownership, economic activity, etc.) are merely a particularly grim example of this general truth. In the Telegraph the other week, Boris Johnson mentioned Mary Seacole, a 19th-century black nurse from Jamaica who was in her day as famous as Florence Nightingale. And, reading of her, I was reminded for the umpteenth time of why the British, of all people, should never have fallen for the neo-apartheid of multiculturalism. âBritishâ was the prototype multiethnic nationality: if you were a doctor from Kingston-on-Thames or a nurse from Kingston, Jamaica, or an assistant choreographer from Kingston, Ontario, you were British â and, unlike the Germans, race didnât come into it. âThe British,â wrote Colin Powell of his Jamaican background, âtold my ancestors that they were now British citizens with all the rights of any subject of the Crown.â Thatâs correct: in law, there was no distinction between a British subject in Wales and a British subject in Tobago. Britishness was far more of a genuinely multicultural identity than the yawning we-are-the-world nullity of modern multiculturalism. Iâm still a wee young thing but my earliest passports bore in bold print on page three the words âA Canadian citizen is a British subject.â It requires a perverse ahistorical fanaticism to decide that Britishness is some shrivelled Little-Englander thing that should never be passed on to our children. Itâs always been the great outward, global, embracing identity. Conversely, I donât see why we should pretend that self-evidently deficient cultures are our moral equal. In so far as I understand the Arabist mindset of the FCO, it would seem to be something to do with the old Lawrence-of-Arabia routine, dressing up in robes and singing âThe Desert Song calling/ Its voice enthralling/ Will make you mine...â. Iâm sympathetic to the romance of the noble Bedouin riding his Arab on the moonlit sands, just as, apropos the Innu, I can see the attraction of seal and bear hunting. But both cultures seem to have a difficulty accommodating contemporary life. Even in corners of the Arab world that have the veneer of modernity, people say nutty stuff to you all the time. Not misfit weirdsmobiles in loser jobs, but fellows at the very heart of the community. To pluck at random, take Abd Al-Sabour Shahin, respected Egyptian professor, lecturer at Cairo University and head of the Sharia faculty at Al-Azhar university, the Harvard of Sunni Islam. On Monday on Saudi Channel One, Dr Shahin told viewers: âOur enemies weave many lies about us, which we are not necessarily aware of. For example: one day, we awoke to the crime of 9/11, which hit the tallest buildings in New York, the Empire State Building. There is no doubt that not a single Arab or Muslim had anything to do with these events. The incident was fabricated as a pretext to attack Islam and Muslims.â Er, OK. So if no Muslim hit the, um, Empire State Building, who did? On that, Dr Shahin was in no doubt: âI believe a dirty Zionist hand carried out this act.â Dr Shahin is the product of a deformed culture. In the days after 9/11, we heard innumerable reprises of the lazy leftist trope âpoverty breeds terrorismâ. But the Arab world is wealthy. It suffers, as David Pryce-Jones has said, from intellectual poverty. And, whether or not Boris and co. need to talk up Britishness, weâd be doing ourselves and them a great favour if we were to make a concerted effort to talk down Muslim nuttiness. With hindsight, the problem with the Salman Rushdie affair â the prototype example of the Islamists claiming global jurisdiction for their psychoses â was that the resistance was left to a bunch of largely humourless self-important literati who made it all into a dreary business about the âneedâ for âtransgressiveâ âartistsâ to âchallengeâ ...zzzzzzz ...losing will to type.... Instead we should have resisted with a gleeful mocking campaign against Islamoparanoia. Every day of the week you can find some bonkers story from the Muslim world. Hereâs the Sunday Age in Melbourne reporting on 31 July on Werribee Islamic College: âThe imam told the students that the Jews were putting poison in the bananas and they should not eat them.â You donât have to be bananas to teach in an Islamic school but it helps. Thatâs a college, by the way, that receives funds from Australian taxpayers of about $3 million a year. For three million bucks they canât hire a catering guy who can find them Jew-free bananas? Even their terrorism is mostly laughable. The shoebomber gets his bomb on the plane but has only a damp book of matches. The 21 July bombers are all hot for their 72 virgins but their bombs refuse to perform, like a bunch of dud fireworks. One Palestinian suicide bomber is intercepted en route by another Palestinian who tries to steal his suicide bomb and they both get blown up before theyâve got near any Jews. The only thing these guys have going for them is our undervaluation of ourselves and perverse boosting up of them. By pretending that all cultures are equal, multiculturalism doesnât âpreserveâ traditional cultures so much as sustain them in an artificial state that ensures theyâll develop bizarre pathologies and mutate into some freakish hybrid of the worst of both worlds. With the Innu, the destructive âcompassionâ of guilt-ridden white liberals is no big deal â at least for us. The Innu live a long way away from anybody else and so for the most part they mostly harm each other. But the Islamists are much closer to home. Like the Innu, theyâre a dysfunctional amalgam of traditional and Western culture, fundamentalist Islam filtered through an old-school European fascist movement. Like the Innu, theyâre hooked on welfare and the glorification of self-destruction. Like the Innu, theyâre the creations of Western largesse â from the firebrand imams bilking the British welfare state, to the bananaphobic imams of taxpayer-funded Aussie schools, to Osama bin Laden himself, who took his paâs dough from the US-fuelled Saudi construction boom and sunk it into a hole in the ground in Tora Bora. Remember Mohammed Atta? He piloted the jet that hit the first World Trade Center tower â or, for any Saudi TV viewers reading this, the first Empire State Building tower â and his main concern seemed to be that his corpse would make it to paradise without being contaminated by infidels and whores. As he wrote in the will he left behind, âHe who washes my body around my genitals should wear gloves so that I am not touched there.â Young Mohammed graduated from Cairo university with a degree in architectural engineering and later studied at Hamburg university. One had assumed his wealthy parents didnât put junior through architectural engineering in order to pull off one spectacular demolition job. But his dad, also called Mohammed, recently popped up on CNN to praise the 9/11 attacks and the 7 July bombings and tell the network that if it wanted another interview it would cost $5,000 which heâd donate towards financing the next attack in London. Heâs a lawyer, his son was an engineer and qualified pilot (well, except for the landing and take-off part, which he told his flight school he didnât need to learn). But theyâre kookier than the most in-bred backwoods up-country yakherd. Yet somehow weâve wound up in a situation where it requires a hugely agonised public debate â even in the Telegraph â about whether we should state the obvious and historically indisputable truth about British culture, while simultaneously we all agree to dissemble like crazy about Muslim culture, handling it with the kid gloves Mohammed Atta wanted reserved for his genitals. This is a disastrous strategy. One lesson of Dr Shahinâs drivel is that a culture in which it is difficult if not impossible to tell the truth eventually goes nuts. It would be a most unBritish ending. |
| Link |
| Fifth Column | |
| Insane review blasted | |
| 2004-02-02 | |
| EFL. The New York Times assigning a left-wing history professor to review a left-wing history book is de rigeur. That the reviewerâs last published book, a monograph on the fall of the Soviet Union, was "clever," according to David Pryce-Jones, but written by a Soviet "apologist" is, again, status quo. When the book in review claims that Kim Jong-Ilâs North Korea is an overstated evil (and that all Kim needs is a little tenderness and understanding) and that, on balance, President George Bush is "more evil" than the "Dear Leader" of North Korean, we shrug our shoulders; a typical of the tenured radical, pandering to 68âer constituents. And, after years of conditioning, we at the Politburo are not surprised when the Times positively reviews such a book. It is logical that the NYT will be illogical. Stephen Kotkinâs review of Bruce Cumingsâ North Korea: Another Country, an examination of the current crisis on the Korean peninsula, finds a book brimming with historical revisionism and moral equivalence, a book, we think, unworthy of praise, however faint, from Americaâs top-selling "serious" broadsheet. (The Economist, the only other major publication to review Another Country, panned the book, chiding Cumings for "pick[ing] his facts to fit his prejudices") All the brains of a keanulint. Kotkin quotes the author as urging the United States to butt out of Kimâs affairs, for, after all, "it is their country." Penetrating analysis, for sure. But most readers will surely understand that "their" refers to Kim Jong-Il and his leisure-suited yes-men, not the enslaved people of North Korea. Regardless, the problems plaguing the "Democractic" Peopleâs Republic are the fault of, from the very beginning, evil Uncle Sam. Cumings, Kotkin says, is clear on this point: "The United States contributed mightily to the [current] North Korean predicament." And he isnât talking about Americaâs financial contributions to the North, the bags of cash meant to bribe Kim into nuclear compliance, and the donations meant to alleviate the effects of a man-made famine. Kotkin had to go to a music store to replace a busted harp string. As did Cumings. "[Cumings] suggests that it was not Kim Il Sung or Stalin who incited hostilities but Dean Acheson and Harry S. Truman." This bit of selective history is important to Cumings case (he has written a previous book on the subject). But Kotkin is engaged in a recitation of Cumingsâ theses, not a critical review of their cogency. The historians skeptical eye is not on display. Instead, these themes--that the Korean War was a legitimate "anti-imperialist" struggle that, thus, legitimizes Kimâs current enthusiasm for Stalinist dictatorship--are not disputed or discussed at length by the reviewer. Cumingsâ lips fell off. Cumings can barely conceal his enthusiasm for Korean communism. He is quoted by Kotkin as recommending Pyongyang as a holiday destination with therapeutic powers: "On my infrequent visits to the country I have been happy...empathy for the underdog is something I canât help, being a life-long fan of the Cleveland Indians." A real cut-up, this Cumings. Besides reading like the delusional dispatch from a modern-day Walter Duranty, we think there is something crass in comparing a mediocre baseball team to a totalitarian government guilty of genocide against its citizens. (A question for Cumings: if you are a sucker for the underdog, then why not root for the hundreds of thousands of innocents languishing in Kimâs concentration camps?) Hey Cumings? You think starvation under communism is better than prosperity under capitalism? Asshole. All that personalty-cult business, absurd "Juche" philosophy and lack of freedom forces Cumings to concede that "politically [North Korea] is not a nice place, but it is an understandable place... [itâs] an anticolonial and anti-imperial state growing out of a half century of Japanese colonial rule and another half century of continuous confrontation with a hegemonic United States and a more powerful South Korea." That Korea is "not a nice place" is surely the understatement of the year. That the lack freedom and rights afforded to North Korean citizens is "understandable" leads us to believe that Cumings might be in the pay of Kimâs propaganda machine and is so preposterous that it doesnât merit a serious response. If thatâs anticolonialism then give me colonial states.
Cumingsâ political philosophy: Freedom bad, tyranny good. Read, freedom is slavery. This is a truly appalling sentiment; and one that is presented without controversy by Kotkin. What "new" information is Cumings privy to that would challenge existing estimates of detainees? (He might want to consult "The Hidden Gulag," a 125 page report compiled by the United States Committee for Human Rights in North Korea, complete with satellite photographs of the camp complexes and spine-tingling testimony from camp survivors). Regardless of numbers, Cumings claims that the gulag at least itâs survivable and they generously arrest the whole family, presumably to alleviate the boredom of the accused. (Would Cumings also--given the experiences of Elie Wiesel and Primo Levi--label the Nazi KZ komplex "survivable"?) Probably. In comparison to the "shrewd" Kim Jong-Il, Bush is "the greater evil," says Cumings. Again, the reviewer registers no disagreement, treating the comparison as judicious and entirely reasonable. Cumingsâbrand of "scholarship" is of the Robert Thuston, David Irving variety--we love the ideology, so we support the ideologues. But because the dominant view is contra Bush--the reviewer occasionally writes for the American Prospect, for example--this apologia for mass murder and fifty years of state Stalinism is treated with seriousness. Well, evil IS serious. | |
| Link |
| Arabia | |
| Can Riyadh reform before the royal family falls? | |
| 2003-11-12 | |
| by David Pryce-Jones in the Wall Street Journal. EFL; read it all. [In Saudi Arabia,] 5,000 or more princes control all power and resources, sharing out ministries and governorships and oil revenues as they see fit. Their idea of democracy is to appoint an advisory council and religious leaders carefully vetted to provide a facade of legitimacy. Immemorial tribal custom and the local Wahhabi brand of Islam are defended and perpetuated to create the impression that this is the natural order of things. The Shiite minority forms about 20% of the population, but on the grounds that they are not Wahhabis they are arrested without trial, tortured and often disappear. Rights and the rule of law are only what the ruling family says they are. The Saudi family of course has a large and privileged security and police apparatus at its service. In other words, less like a government than a mob family. No blueprint exists in any of the textbooks for successfully modernizing a society like this one. . . . Sept. 11 forced the U.S. and everyone else to recognize that Saudi Arabia has become a danger to itself and the rest of the world. Lest we forget, almost all the hijackers hailed from the kingdom. Individual Saudis, including some princes and their so-called charities, have sponsoredand continue to sponsorterror groups, including their homegrown al Qaeda, in some 60 countries. Faced with the evidence, the ruling Saudis have preferred to prevaricate, often refusing to share intelligence, hampering investigations and the pursuit of justice. That only works for a while. Those who gave money to al Qaeda were hoping to buy off Osama bin Laden, insuring themselves against him. But that's not easy. Bin Laden wants to return to a tribal Wahhabi society in its purest form. In his eyes, the presence of U.S. troops in Saudi Arabia was sacrilege, and he has been threatening to dethrone the Saudi royal family that permitted it. The relocation of U.S. troops elsewhere in the region removes that particular grievance but also leaves the country to its own devices. The ruling family, bin Laden, the Shiites, groups of dissidents and exiles, and everyone else are quite free to struggle for power as best they can without outside interference. "Last one standing gets to claim soverignty." At this late moment, any suggestion of reform looks like weakness, which only invites more of the violence it aims to disarm. In aviation, that's known as a "graveyard spiral." Evidently granting concessions under pressure, the ruling family recently announced that in principle elections could be held for 14 municipal councils. Another unprecedented step was a human rights conference held in mid-October in Riyadh. Hundreds of people took this opportunity to demonstrate, until antiriot police firing tear gas dispersed them. The conference called, among other things, for a greater role for women in a country where they are not allowed to drive a car or even to go out unaccompanied by a male member of the family. "They demand it," in the words of an editorial in an official English-language newspaper, "Saudi Arabia needs it."
. . . until the next time it happens. Unlike the unfortunate Louis XVI, those 5,000 and more princes have a real stranglehold on power, as well as the will for self-preservation. Their security apparatus may well succeed in maintaining for a while longer the peculiar stagnation cherished by the ruling family. Not indefinitely, though. A revolt that becomes a revolution is an irresistible force that sweeps away what once seemed unmovable objects in its path. Faster, please. | |
| Link |
| Home Front |
| Brink Lindsey on Islamism... |
| 2001-09-28 |
| At first glance, shadowy Islamist terrorists look very different from any enemy we have ever faced. And indeed, the tactics they employ are novel, as are the tactics that must be used to defeat them. But the fundamental nature of our present adversaries, once seen plainly, is all too familiar. The evil we confront today is the evil of totalitarianism: Osama bin Laden, al Qaeda, and their coconspirators are the modern-day successors of Lenin and Stalin, Mussolini and Hitler, Mao and Pol Pot. The misbegotten secular religions of totalitarianism won their devoted and ruthless followings by offering an escape from the stresses of modernity specifically, from the agoraphobic panic that liberal open-endedness roused. They aspired to "re-enchant" the world with grand dreams of class or racial destiny dreams that integrated their adherents into communities of true believers, and elevated them from lost souls to agents of great and inexorable forces. With their insidiously appealing lies, the false faiths of communism and fascism launched their mad rebellion against the liberal rigors of questioning and self-doubt and so against tolerance and pluralism and peaceable persuasion. They inflicted upon a century their awful, evil perversion of modernity: the instrumentalities of mass production and mass prosperity twisted into engines of mass destruction and mass murder. Despite the trappings of religious fervor, Islamist totalitarianism is strikingly similar to its defunct, secular cousins. It is an expression, not of spirituality, but of anomie: in particular, a seething resentment of Western prosperity and strength. Consider the origins of the Muslim Brotherhood. Founded in 1928 to resist the British presence in Egypt, the Brotherhood was the original radical Islamist terror network. As detailed in David Pryce-Jones' powerful The Closed Circle, the official account of its formation records this statement at the group's initial meeting: "We know not the practical way to reach the glory of Islam and serve the welfare of Muslims. We are weary of this life of humiliation and restriction. Lo, we see that the Arabs and the Muslims have no status and dignity." And just like its Communist and fascist predecessors Islamist totalitarianism seeks redemption through politics. It is animated by the pursuit of temporal power: the destruction of the "decadent" (i.e., liberal) West and creation of a pan-Islamic utopian state featuring unrestrained centralization of authority. Whether the utopian blueprint calls for mullahs, commissars, or Gauleiters to wield absolute power is of secondary importance: It is the utopian idea itself the millennial fantasy of a totalitarian state that unites all the radical movements of the Industrial Counterrevolution. Today, the sectaries of radical Islamism continue to uphold various collectivist strains of "Islamic economics" trumpeted as righteous alternatives to the secular and individualist corruption of "Eurocentric" globalization. But this much is clear: The United States is now at war with the totalitarians of radical Islamism. And in prior conflicts with the totalitarian impulse of the Industrial Counterrevolution, the United States has been undefeated. Americans triumphed first over fascism, then over Communism movements with ideologies of potentially global appeal, and with political bases in militarily formidable great powers. Americans will rise again to this latest challenge. Unlike its predecessors, radical Islamism speaks only to the disaffected minority of a particular region, and none of the governments of that region holds any hope of prevailing against the resolute exercise of U.S. power. However long the present war must last, and however costly it must be, the final outcome cannot be doubted: interment of Islamist totalitarianism in what President Bush so stirringly referred to as "history's unmarked grave of discarded lies." |
| Link |
| Home Front |
| Pryce-Jones: It's their own damned fault |
| 2001-10-09 |
For the past half century and more, the Muslim world has been free and independent, with every opportunity to organize as it wishes. And this is the heart of the issue: The Muslim world is a political and social disaster for all to see. With the arguable exception of Turkey, it consists of a series of despotisms, each with an absolute ruler whose ultimate justification is his strength and will. A family or a clique gathers around the ruler under the protection of the state apparatus of secret police and military repression. To the powerful, the spoils; to the weak, submission. No rights, no freedom of expression, no loyal opposition, no rule of law, no redress except through violence, conspiracy, a coup, and ultimate civil war. Whose fault is this? The huge majority of Muslims understand that they are responsible for themselves. |
| Link |