Hello !
Recent Appearances... Rantburg

Home Front: Politix
MA - Political science rule: "undecided voters will break heavily for the challenger"
2010-01-12
There's been a lot of analysis lately of the various polls in the Massachusetts Senate race that are floating around the Internet. The polls are all over the place, but I think Scott Rasmussen hit the nail on the head with his analysis.

The bottom line is that almost all of these polls agree on one thing: Democrat Martha Coakley is hovering right around 50%.

Consider: PPP (D) has her at 47%. The Globe/UNH poll has her at 53%. Rasmussen has her at 50%. Even internal Democratic polling -- which usually represents the Democrat's best-case scenario -- has her leading state Senator Scott Brown 50%-36%. In other words, most of the variance comes from Brown's numbers -- which vary between 36% and 48% support -- not Coakley's. As I've noted before, when you see one candidate very stable and one candidate with a high degree of variance in their numbers, it means that the undecideds are trending toward the candidate with the higher variance. In other words, that candidate will tend to be toward the high end of their polling range.

This is where the "undecided rule" starts to come into play. It's a political science rule that predicts that undecided voters will break heavily for the challenger. It's come into a bit of disrepute of late, especially given Bush's strong showing among undecideds in the 2004 election. There were also some good examples in 2006 and 2008 of the rule failing to perform as expected, and a quick google of "undecided rule" links to various criticisms of it.

My take on it this that this is simply an example of people taking a political science "rule" and losing track of the reasons the rule existed in the first place, what might have changed to make it weaker, and what might still survive of it. The reasoning behind the undecided rule is that if voters haven't fallen in love with the incumbent by election day, they aren't going to vote for him (or her). The undecideds, therefore, can be expected to take a flier on the challenger.

But the undecided rule was formulated in the 1980s, in pre-internet America, when information moved much slower, and where expenses on television advertising were not nearly as high as they are today. And the dataset trickles down to state Attorneys General races, mayor races, and countywide contests. It even covered primaries. (If you want to read the original article giving the intellectual backdrop for the rule, click here). In other words, its dataset included an awful lot of races where people probably never heard a peep from the challenger. In those situations, it makes sense that voters who didn't like an incumbent would cast a default vote for the challenger.

Contrast that to POTUS, Senate, and even Congressional races today. Everyone knew everything about Bush and Kerry, and began focusing intently on the race early on. It was one of the longest, most intense races of my lifetime (at least until 2008). Similarly, Senate races, Governor's races, and even Congressional races receive a lot more scrutiny than they used to. In other words, the challenger today is probably much less likely to be a "default" option by the time election day rolls around, especially in high profile races that people tend to follow closely.

Indeed, take a look at the examples given in the original "undecided rule" article of cases where the undecideds broke against the challenger:

Last year in Minnesota, where Hubert Humphrey III challenged Sen. David Durenberger; and in Nebraska, where Bob Kerrey, the former governor, challenged David Karnes, who had been appointed to his Senate seat. In 1986 in Florida, when incumbent Sen. Paula Hawkins faced ex-Gov. Bob Graham. And in Chicago in 1979, where two-year incumbent Mayor Michael Bilandic split undecided voters with challenger Jane Byrne.


All of these examples included situations where a well-known challenger was involved, or where an incumbent without a full term under his belt was involved. You probably can't get a more well-known name in Minnesota than Hubert Humphrey, and Kerrey and Graham were popular Governors. It makes intuitive sense that these races would tend to break more evenly -- in the case of the well-known challenger, the people could potentially have equally negative feelings about the challenger, while in the case of the short-term incumbent, voters might be more willing to give the incumbent a chance. For a more recent example, look no further than Lisa Murkowski, who beat two-term Governor Tony Knowles despite trailing in almost every poll that cycle (this is the rare combination of short-term incumbent and well-known challenger).

So if we look for a principle that survives this new age of saturation advertising and internet-driven intensity, we might say that when you have two well-known candidates, the undecided rule is probably inapplicable as a predictive device. But if there's a disparity between the candidates, the undecideds will still tend to break toward the lesser-known candidate. There's probably caveats and exceptions here, but I think that's probably about right.

So what does that tell us about the Massachusetts Senate race? We have a sitting Attorney General who came out of a contested primary, going up against a more-or-less completely unknown state Senator. She's struggling to get above 50%. All of this points toward a very close final race -- potentially much closer than a week ago when I guessed at a 54-46 spread. Again, this is also consistent with what we're seeing in the variance in the Coakley/Brown numbers. Coakley should be worried.
Link


Home Front: WoT
A reminder: profile of Sgt. Jason Thomas, USMC
2006-09-10
Never forget the heroism of ordinary Americans on 9/11. Thank you Sgt. Thomas.
(CBS/AP) NEW YORK Aug. 14, 2006. For years, authorities wondered about the identity of a U.S. Marine who appeared at the World Trade Center on Sept. 11, 2001, helped find a pair of police officers buried in the rubble, then vanished.

Even the producers of the new film chronicling the rescue, "World Trade Center," couldn't locate the mystery serviceman. The only name he'd given at the scene was "Sgt. Thomas."

The puzzle was finally solved when one Jason Thomas, of Columbus, Ohio, happened to catch a TV commercial for the new movie a few weeks ago as he relaxed on his couch. His eyes widened as he saw two Marines with flashlights, hunting for survivors atop the smoldering ruins. "That's us. That's me!" thought the New York native, now working as a court officer in Ohio's Supreme Court.

Thomas, 32, hesitantly re-emerged last week to recount the role he played in the rescue of Port Authority police officers Will Jimeno and Sgt. John McLoughlin, who were entombed beneath 20 feet of debris when the twin towers collapsed.

Now a father of five, Thomas had been out of the Marine Corps for about a year when the terrorists struck. He was dropping a daughter off at his mother's Long Island home when she delivered the news. "My mother insisted it must be an accident," he said. Thomas believed differently.

Rushing to his car, he dug in his trunk, retrieved his Marine uniform and put it on.

Minutes later, he was speeding toward Manhattan, eventually finding himself on the West Side Highway following a convoy of police cars. He had just parked when one of the towers collapsed. "All I saw was ash. Ash coming in my direction," Thomas said.

As it billowed around him, he knelt by the side of his car and pulled his shirt up over his mouth. Then, he got up and ran at the center of the cloud. "Someone needed help. It didn't matter who," he said. "I didn't even have a plan. But I have all this training as a Marine, and all I could think was, 'My city is in need."'

Thomas spent hours putting people on stretchers and setting up triage stations before bumping into another ex-Marine, Staff Sgt. David Karnes. Like him, Karnes had also grabbed his fatigues and headed into Manhattan when he learned of the attacks.

Acting on their own, the pair decided to search for survivors. Carrying little more than flashlights and an infantryman's shovel, they climbed the mountain of debris and began an hours-long hunt, skirting dangerous crevasses and shards of red-hot metal, calling out "Is anyone down there? United States Marines!"

It was dark before they finally heard a response. The two crawled into a deep pit to find McLoughlin and Jimeno, injured but alive. Even then, getting help wasn't easy. Thomas clambered back to the surface and feverishly tried to flag down other rescuers in the dark. Karnes phoned his sister in Pennsylvania and had her relay their location to 911 dispatchers.

Jimeno would spend 13 hours in the pit before he was pulled free. Thomas stayed long enough to see him come up, but couldn't find the strength to wait for McLoughlin, who remained pinned for another nine hours. "I was completely exhausted. I just had to get out of that hole," Thomas said.

He stumbled away and drove home, stopping to hose himself off in his backyard. "I knew my wife would kill me if I went in to the house with all that ash," he said.

Thomas said he returned to ground zero every day for another 2 1/2 weeks to pitch in, then walked away and tried to forget. "I didn't want to relive what took place that day," he said.

As for his story, Thomas said he is gradually becoming more comfortable telling it. "It's been like therapy," he said.
Link


Home Front: Culture Wars
'WTC' casting error draws flak from African-Americans
2006-08-16
A hero of another color in Oliver Stone's "World Trade Center" has some people again balking at the whitewashing of a black character in a Hollywood film. This time it's the character of Marine Sgt. Thomas, one of two former Marines who help rescue New York Port Authority Officers Will Jimeno and John McLoughlin from beneath 20 feet of twisted metal, broken concrete and sparking debris in the aftermath of the Sept. 11 attacks. In the film, white actor William Mapother -- who's Tom Cruise's cousin and who played Ethan Rom in the first season of "Lost" and Quecreek miner John "Flathead" Phillippi in ABC's "The Pennsylvania Miners' Story" -- plays Sgt. Thomas.
His part in the movie was much smaller than that of Staff Sgt. David Karnes, mostly because no one knew who he was.
Last week, the real Sgt. Thomas -- a black, former Marine named Jason Thomas of Columbus, Ohio -- came forward and told his story. "Someone needed help. It didn't matter who," Thomas told the Associated Press. "I didn't even have a plan. But I have all this training as a Marine, and all I could think was, 'My city is in need.' "
Thank you, Marine
So, instead of heading to class at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice at City University of New York that fateful morning, he headed toward the devastation. At ground zero, he ran into another ex-Marine and Connecticut accountant, Staff Sgt. David Karnes, and the two decided to search for survivors. Eventually they found Jimeno and McLoughlin. Karnes, who couldn't reach Manhattan's 911 from his cell phone at ground zero, called his sister in Munhall, Joy Karnes. She helped relay information to New York emergency services that helped them pinpoint the trapped men's location.

Film producer Michael Shamberg apologized to Thomas for the racial inaccuracy in the film, saying they realized the mistake only after production had already begun, the Associated Press reported. That apology comes a bit late for Paradise Gray, 42, of Wilkinsburg who sent out e-mails to hundreds of thousands via African-American list serves and Internet groups, such as the Luv4Self Network yesterday calling for a boycott of the film. "You want to apologize to me?" Mr. Gray says. "Stop it." Black men so rarely are portrayed or presented as heroes in popular culture and the media that when the opportunity to do so arises, they should be, he says.
Well, what do you expect from a bunch of right-wing Repub........oh, wait
"It's so natural for Hollywood to assume that every hero is a white man," Mr. Gray wrote in his e-mail. "Hollywood has always changed facts and edited history. From Charlton Heston as Moses and Elizabeth Taylor as Cleopatra. They are only continuing their tradition of whitewashing our history."
Uh, Mr. Grey? Cleopatra was a member of the Ptolemy dynasty, put in charge of Egypt by Alexander the Great. They were Greek.
He also criticized the black community for not speaking out more. The Jewish community's mantra is "never forget" while the black community's mantra is "forgive and forget," he said. The black community should speak up every time this happens.
Backlash against Oliver Stone in ......Hello?
Six years ago, there was a similar controversy surrounding color-blind casting in the film "Pay It Forward." Kevin Spacey's white burn victim in the movie actually was a black Vietnam veteran in the book.

Though disappointed his character in the "World Trade Center" movie wasn't black, Thomas, who lived on Long Island during the attacks and now works as an officer in Ohio's Supreme Court, told the Associated Press he's not upset. "I don't want to shed any negativity on what they were trying to show," he said.

The movie is much bigger than him, Thomas told the New Pittsburgh Courier, and it's the people who lost their lives who need to remembered.
Link


Terror Networks
Oliver Stones "World Trade Center"
2006-08-06

Chuck Sereika
Vero Beach, Florida

Members Of The Press:

Re: Oliver Stone's "World Trade Center"


Dear Ladies and Gentleman:

Oliver Stone, Michael Shamberg, and Stacy Sher have created a Movie and that's all it is. Some of the rescuers had signed on as consultants in order to assure that the movie would be accurate to content and emotion. We did our best to provide every detail of the events of September 11, 2001 to the producers and were assured by all involved that the film would be factual. We were deceived by the director and producers of the film throughout production.. Mr. Michael Shamberg even attempted to convince me after I had already seen the film that the story was "as factual as they could make it" "with time constraints". This Movie is a far cry from a "true" story and it has nothing to do with "time constraints." Officer Jimeno had temper tantrem after temper tantrem on set in Hollywood and threatened to leave several times in order to get his way. Ssgt David Karnes, FF Tommy Asher, and myself all find the film to be very disheartening. I second Ssgt. Karne's opinion (NY Post). Fame and Fortune with no regard for the "truth". Oliver Stone, Michael Shamberg, Stacy Sher and William Jimeno have no honor. They have forced a fictional movie about the worst day in American history on us in order to glorify themselves and stuff their pocket's with the procedes from ticket sales. They are attempting pull the wool over the eye's of America. If you are interested in seeing Officer Jimeno you can tune into Country Music Television next week during his interview on what country music he enjoy's listening to "I urge American's to refrain from supporting the film until members of the media can bring the "truth" to light."

Respectfully,

Chuck Sereika
NYSAEMT-4 Paramedic
#093394

" I urge American's to refrain from supporting the film (Oliver Stone's "World Trade Center") until members of the media can bring the "truth" to light" NYSAEMT-4 Paramedic Chuck Sereika #093394
Link


-4 More