Good news/bad news/same good news/more bad news, in the name of balance. Some editing for continuity.
 The killing of the top Taliban commander Mullah Dadullah, a one-legged fighter who orchestrated suicide attacks, beheadings and an ethnic massacre, marks a major victory for the U.S. campaign but in fairness, we must report it comes at a time of flagging Afghan support over civilian killings.
As victims of Dadullah's brutality celebrated his death Sunday, analysts called the killing the most significant Taliban loss since the 2001 U.S.-led invasion. But even NATO acknowledged that Dadullah, who directed some of the Taliban's most notorious violence, would soon be replaced.
Every silver lining has a cloud©
Kandahar Gov. Asadullah Khalid, who called Dadullah a "brutal and cruel commander" showed the body to reporters in Kandahar who saw a one-legged corpse with bullet wounds to the head, chest and stomach. Qari Yousef Ahmadi, a purported Taliban spokesman, denied that the Taliban commander had been killed, but there appeared little doubt Dadullah was dead.
Dadullah is the second top-tier Taliban field commander to be killed in the last six months, after a U.S. airstrike killed Mullah Akhtar Mohammad Osmani in December. Dadullah, Osmani and policy-maker Mullah Obaidullah had been considered to be Omar's top three leaders.
Rahimullah Yusufzai, a Peshawar-based editor for the Pakistani newspaper The News and an expert on the Taliban, said Dadullah's death was "the biggest loss for the Taliban in the last six years." But he noted that even though the Taliban were demoralized after Osmani's death in December, they quickly resumed attacks. "I don't think they can find someone as daring and as important as Dadullah," Yusufzai said. "I think maybe temporarily some of their big operations will be disrupted, but i don't think it will have a long-term effect."
Yusufzai said many Taliban fighters had been unhappy with Dadullah, saying he maligned the militant group with his beheadings, a rash of kidnappings and boastful videos that starred himself firing guns and walking in Afghanistan's mountains. "They thought he had become too big for his shoes," Yusufzai said.
Mustafa Alani, director of security and terrorism studies at the Dubai-based Gulf Research Center, noted that insurgent attacks in Iraq did not abate after the killing of al-Qaida's leader in Iraq, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, last June. "In this sort of organization, people are replaceable, and always there is a second layer, third layer. They will graduate to the leadership," Alani said. "He is important, no doubt about it. Yes, it is a moral victory, but he's replaceable."
As opposed to our soldiers, who are leaving soon.
Still, Dadullah's particular brand of cruelty was unmatched inside the Taliban. Dadullah's men videotaped beheadings of Afghans suspected of cooperating with international forces or the Afghan government, and the suicide bombers he is believed to have commanded have killed or injured hundreds of Afghan civilians, soldiers and police, as well as dozens of international forces.
The Taliban's former ambassador to Pakistan, Abdul Salam Zaeef, said Dadullah's death would stir more violence and could motivate supporters to take revenge. He said negotiations were the only way to end the insurgency, echoing a call by Afghanistan's upper house of parliament this week for talks with Afghan Taliban fighters. "When they are killing one Mullah Dadullah, they are creating 10 more," Zaeef said.
Maybe not as experienced and elusive, though.
NATO said Dadullah moved into Afghanistan from his "sanctuary" - a reference to Pakistan - where he trained suicide bombers. Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf admitted in February that Dadullah had been in Pakistan several times and eluded capture. Dadullah "will most certainly be replaced in time, but the insurgency has received a serious blow," NATO said.
The Defense Ministry spokesman, Gen. Mohammad Zahir Azimi, said Dadullah was killed in the Sangin area of Helmand province, but just in case you think this is all good news, we must point out that this is a region that has seen heavy fighting in recent weeks and where airstrikes on Tuesday killed between 20 and 40 civilians, according to Afghan officials and villagers and Taliban Tools, the latest in a series of civilian deaths that has weakened support for the international mission.
Azimi said Dadullah was killed Friday, though the intelligence service and Kandahar governor said he died Saturday. He said Dadullah died in a shootout alongside 10 other fighters, and that military officials had reports Dadullah may have been at the battle site but weren't positive the information was true.
Maybe he was wacked by his own folks, who "...thought he had become too big for his shoes"
An ethnic Pashtun, the group that makes up the core of the Taliban and is prominent in eastern and southern Afghanistan, Dadullah lost a leg fighting against the Soviet army that occupied Afghanistan in the 1980s.
He stepped on a land mine. Maybe he never was in a battle - a boss, not a participant?
He emerged as a Taliban commander during its fight against the Northern Alliance in northern Afghanistan during the 1990s, helping the hard-line militia to capture the city of Mazar-e-Sharif. In 1999 he led a Taliban massacre of ethnic Hazaras in the province of Bamiyan, where the Taliban in 2000 destroyed two ancient Buddha statues carved into a hillside cliff.
Brave Lions of Islam started with statues, then worked up to women and children.
Since the Taliban's ouster in late 2001, Dadullah emerged as the group's most prominent and feared commander. He often appeared in videos and media interviews, and earlier this year predicted a militant spring offensive that has failed to materialize.
Of course it materialized. How do you think he got dead?
In March, London television Channel 4 aired an interview in which Dadullah said al-Qaida leader Osama bin Laden was alive and well and in contact with Taliban officers.
I saw the interview yesterday. IIRC, he said Binny directed several recent attacks, then a few minutes later said he'd heard reports he was alive. Couldn't keep his stories straight.
 The Taliban in Afghanistan says the younger brother of a top military commander killed over the weekend will take over as chief military strategist for the movement.
The Taliban named Mullah Bakht to succeed Mullah Dadullah, a one-legged fighter who was killed on Saturday in Helmand province in a joint operation involving British and Afghan troops and U.S. Special Forces. The NATO-led International Security Assistance Force said in a statement that Dadullah's death means "the insurgency has received a serious blow," but the Taliban moved quickly to name a replacement. His brother, however, is said to have less combat experience. |
QUETTA, Pakistan Pakistani security forces critically wounded a top figure in the Taliban militia fighting U.S. and NATO forces in Afghanistan, one of six militants captured after a clash near the border Monday, the army said. 
Earlier, a senior military official, speaking on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak to journalists, said Dadullah died of his wounds while being flown to a hospital with the other injured men.
Afghan forces have trapped up to 200 Taliban fighters in a southern village, possibly including the militia's military commander, 
Pakistans reported capture of the former Taliban defence minister boosts its anti-terror credentials and delivers a setback to the insurgent movement, but is unlikely to curb another wave of militant violence this year, said analysts on Friday. 
The Taliban on Saturday rejected claims made by a captured spokesman that Taliban chief Mullah Omar was in Quetta under Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) protection, stressing that the man did not know the movements military secrets. 
A prominent Taliban commander has been captured by NATO-led troops in southern Afghanistan. The militant leader, who has not yet been identified, was detained during a raid by NATO and Afghan troops on a compound in Helmand province, the alliance said on Wednesday. According to a NATO spokesman, the commander led insurgents in the volatile Panjwaii district of Kandahar province, said NATO spokesman Squadron Leader Dave Marsh. "This seizure of a Taliban commander once again shows that there is nowhere to hide for insurgent leaders," Marsh said. 
Forensic analysis and other information enabled the U.S. military to verify that a key associate of Taliban chief Mullah Omar was killed in an airstrike in southern Afghanistan last week, a spokesman said Sunday. The military is "very sure" it killed Mullah