| Submit your comments on this article | |||
| -Great Cultural Revolution | |||
| Descendants of the former owner of a Van Gogh painting are demanding that it be removed from Sotheby's auction | |||
| 2026-11-16 | |||
| Direct Translation via Google Translate. Edited [Regnum] The heirs of Samuel Fischer, the former owner of Vincent van Gogh's "Chestnut Trees in Bloom," have asked Sotheby's to remove the painting from auction. This was reported on November 15 by The New York Times (NYT). According to the publication, Fischer's descendants living in the United States claim that the work was sold at market price in 1936 in Amsterdam under duress related to the family's persecution by the Nazi regime. Samuel Fischer, founder of the publishing house S. Fischer Verlag, purchased the painting in 1909. After his death, his family gave "Chestnut Trees in Blossom" to the Amsterdam dealer Walter Feilchenfeldt. In 1936, he sold the painting to a Parisian collector. After several ownership changes, the painting was acquired by its current owners, from Argentina, in 1975. The painting is now valued at $180 million, the highest estimate for any lot at art auctions this season and higher than any Van Gogh ever achieved at auction. On November 12, the lawyer for Fischer's heirs sent a letter to Sotheby's head of restitution, Marco Thoracca, expressing his commitment to a "fair and just resolution in the spirit of the 1998 Washington Principles." The auction house stated that research has not yet confirmed that the painting's sale was forced. In March 2024, Van Gogh's "Portrait of a Peasant Woman with a White Bonnet" (1884) sold at the TEFAF art fair in Maastricht for €4.57 million. The painting was auctioned by the American gallery MS Rau in New Orleans. Its authenticity was confirmed by the Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam.
Fischer family descendants say 1936 transaction was driven by persecution; Sotheby’s says research has not established the painting was sold under duress The descendants of the Jewish former owners of a Vincent van Gogh painting were asking Sotheby’s to pull the work from an auction scheduled for Wednesday night, arguing that their family sold it under duress from Nazi persecution in 1936, The New York Times ![]() ...which still proudly claims Walter Duranty's Pulitzer prize... reported Friday. Sotheby’s had also guaranteed the work, assuring the seller of a minimum price. Fischer founded S. Fischer Verlag, whose authors included Thomas Mann, Hermann Hesse and Alfred Döblin. After his death in 1934, his son-in-law, Gottfried Bermann Fischer, took over the publishing house. As the Nazis tightened their grip on Germany, many writers published by the company were banned. Bermann Fischer subsequently left Berlin for Vienna and attempted to continue publishing their work there. The heirs argue that the family’s circumstances under Nazi persecution were directly connected to the eventual 1936 sale of the Van Gogh. The Nazis restricted what Jews were permitted to take with them when leaving Germany, and the Fischer family was forced to pay the "Reich flight tax," according to research by the heirs’ attorney, Gunnar Schnabel. Before its sale, the Van Gogh had also appeared in exhibitions outside Germany. It was shown in Rotterdam in 1933 and in Bern the following year. Schnabel urged Sotheby’s to prove that the 1936 sale of the painting was sold at market value and that it would have sold even without the pressure created under Nazi rule. "Otherwise," he wrote in a November 12 email seen by the Times, "no auction may take place." Schnabel said his client "is prepared to work toward a fair and just solution in the spirit of the 1998 Washington Principles," a non-binding set of 11 guidelines on how to approach artwork that was stolen from Jews by the Nazis. Sotheby’s acknowledged the claim and said it had researched the painting’s ownership history, but had not concluded that the 1936 transaction was a forced sale.
The question of whether a sale outside Nazi-controlled territory can nevertheless constitute a persecution-related loss has arisen in other restitution cases. In 2021, Dusseldorf agreed to return a Franz Marc painting to the heirs of a Jewish owner who sold it in New York after fleeing Nazi Germany, with a German restitution commission finding that the location of the sale did not negate the role Nazi persecution played in forcing him to part with the work. After World War II, Fischer’s ownership of the publishing house was restored, but he did not seek restitution for his sold paintings in the Netherlands due to lack of a legal basis for compensation for art sales in countries not under Nazi rule at the time of such deals. The Times noted that restitution practice has evolved in recent years, with greater attention paid to whether Nazi persecution compelled Jewish owners to sell works even outside Nazi-controlled territory The Fischer family had previously raised similar concerns over another painting entrusted to Feilchenfeldt and sold in 1936. When Christie’s prepared to auction a Cézanne portrait in 2007, Gottfried Bermann Fischer’s daughter Gisela said she would not oppose that particular sale, but explicitly reserved the family’s right to pursue claims over other works her father had sold under duress from Nazi persecution.
Per the court order, the current owner of the painting, who bought it during the 2024 auction, will be required to return the painting to the family of its original owner. A Gay Paree court has ordered that a painting by Camille Pissarro be returned to the descendants of Jewish banker and art collector Salomon Flavian, French media outlet Le Figaro reported on Thursday.The painting was reportedly stolen by the Nazis during the Second World War. The court found that the Flavian family had provided sufficient evidence that the painting, The Port of Dieppe, had been confiscated from their ancestor by Nazi officers in 1941. They also proved that Salomon had made substantial efforts to recover his painting after the war ended. The ruling said that "all successive sales of the disputed painting since its spoliation are null and void, including the sale that took place in London on June 25, 2024, and ordered the restitution of the work, wherever it may be found and in whoever's hands it may be," Le Figaro reported. RECENT APPEARANCE OF THE PAINTING IN LONDON The painting, which hadn't been in circulation for years, appeared at a Sotheby's auction in London in 2024, where it sold for £1.2 million (5 million NIS). The court ordered Sotheby's to reveal the full identity of the 2024 buyer to Flavian's descendants within two months. Sotheby's will face a fine of 3,550 NIS per day after the two months are up. Per the order, the current owner of the painting, who bought it during the 2024 auction, will be required to return the painting to the family of its original owner. Sotheby's "silence prevents Salomon Flavian’s heirs from asserting their right to restitution from the subsequent purchaser of the disputed artwork, and contravenes the primary objective of the April 21, 1945, ordinance concerning the restitution in kind of looted property to the victims or their heirs," the court statement explained. Related: Sotheby''s 06/06/2025 An elephant in the dock. How Poroshenko hid billions from Zelensky with his wife Sotheby''s 11/14/2024 The oldest known stone tablet of the Ten Commandments to be auctioned by Sotheby's Sotheby''s 03/22/2022 Ukrainian perspective: Russian invasion of Ukraine, March 22nd, 2022 | |||
| Posted by:badanov |
| #1 |
| Posted by: mossomo 2026-11-16 13:07 |