Warning: Undefined array key "rbname" in /data/rantburg.com/www/pgrecentorg.php on line 14
Hello !
Recent Appearances... Rantburg
Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly Learned Elders of Islam Down Under 20050619  

Down Under
Australian Islamic Council cuts ties with mufti
2007-04-07
CONTROVERSIAL Muslim leader Sheik Taj al Din al-Hilaly has been sacked as mufti by the Australian Federation of Islamic Councils (AFIC). The AFIC has also abolished the role of mufti, severed all ties with the sheik and stopped paying his salary, Fairfax Newspapers report.

AFIC President Ikebal Patel said the organisation owned the title of mufti and had stopped paying Sheik Hilaly's salary. The role of mufti has now become redundant following a decision by the Australian National Imams Council (ANIC). The council has decided to create a community of imams to deal with community issues and a chairman or president will be selected as spokesperson.

But the Egyptian-born sheik has fought back and registered the title of mufti for himself.

The move to oust Sheik Hilaly comes as Australian Federal Police investigate allegations that he gave charity funds to supporters of the al-Qaeda and Hezbollah terrorist organisations.

His sacking follows a string of controversies which have embarrassed the Islamic community. Last year the sheik likened scantily-clad women to uncovered meat and then, during a visit to Egypt, said Muslims had more right to be in Australia than Europeans.

ANIC spokesman Mohamad Abdalla said 39 of the 50 clerics who attended the ANIC conference last month voted against reappointing him. “Muslims don't want al-Hilaly as mufti,” Dr Abdalla said. Sheik Hilaly will cease to be mufti once his three-month grace period ended, Dr Abdalla said.

Fairfax reports that the sheik, who is in Turkey at a conference, has established his own organisation in a bid to corner the title of mufti for himself.
Link


Down Under
Muslim fears for life over calls for sheik step-down
2006-11-08
A prominent Muslim doctor who demanded Australia's mufti quit after his controversial sermon fears for his life after a series of threats. Dr Jamal Rifi says he received calls, emails and letters from Islamic extremists after taking a stand against his former friend Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly. The threats were spurred by an open letter written by the Bankstown GP which condemned the mufti's apparent justification of rape.

Dr Rifi said he has been forced to install a security system at his surgery and take other precautions to protect his family and staff. "I've told my wife to be careful and we now take our kids to school and bring them back every day," he said.

"We're not seeing any new patients either, only people we trust, and I've told my office to take extra care. I have to be cautious because I've had a few nasty emails and a few nasty phones calls and faxes that were not nice at all."

But the threats have not stopped Dr Rifi from further demanding Sheik Hilaly step aside following the inflammatory comments which compared immodestly dressed women with uncovered meat and seemingly blamed them for sexual assault.

He said the cleric's recovery speech last Friday did manage to relieve some tension which had built up "like a pressure cooker about to explode". But his offer to resign if an ethical tribunal found him guilty of condoning rape "just causes more problems", the doctor said.

"He has already been trialled, judged and convicted in the court of public opinion so he must go," said Dr Rifi, who formed the Australian Muslim Doctors Against Violence during the Lebanon-Israel conflict.

"What he said has done a lot of damage. I believe he is the wrong image of Islam and it's really not a good reflection on our community, him staying in this position."
Link


Down Under
Rape victim defends Sheik al-Hilaly
2006-11-04
Rape victim defends embattled sheik November 04, 2006 12:00

Brilliant PR strategy from the Lebanese Muslim Association. It just goes to show what we are up against. F*ing bastards these Islamofascist gits are. But they are masters of spin doctoring and it is in the media that the war is won and lost. They are flogging us.

I wonder where they dug this alleged rape victim from, if indeed she was ever raped. Disgusting. Especially in light of the fact a victim of the gang rapes carried out by muslim pakistanis and lebs from southwest sydney in the Lakemba Mosque catchment area came out and told off the Sheik and said he had effectively incited the crime committed on her body.

A WOMAN who described herself as a rape victim today defended the mufti of Australia, Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly, saying his controversial comments did not mean he justified rape.
In fact he said he would lock up rape victims in prison as they were partly responsible for thier own rape. He said it was their fault as if they were 'in their home, in their room, in their hijab' it would not have occurred.
Useful idiotCindy Taylor walked with the sheik down the steps of Sydney's Lakemba Mosque after prayers today, before speaking to reporters.
Sheik's PR machine leaps into action
The sheik has been at the centre of controversy since likening immodestly dressed women to uncovered meat and suggesting they invited sexual assault.

Ms Taylor said she understood what the sheik had tried to say, and called on Australians to be more open-minded.
Open your mind to the idea that if you don't wear the hijab, 'you're asking for it'. Open your minds to the idea that women are not equals with the right to refuse sex.
"He was not being politically correct. But, he's not a politician, he's a philosophical leader," she said.
Who leads 5000 muslims many of whom participated in gang rapes specifically targetting non-Muslim 'aussie sluts', the attitude they learned in the mosque.
"He's a wonderful man and his analogy certainly did not justify the act of rape.
No, it did not justify it, it excused it and blamed the victim. Two different things.
"He believes that the act of rape is one of the worst capital crimes in Islam."
for which he believes the victim must be punished
Ms Taylor said she had been raped twice, when she was 14 and 30, but no one was ever charged.
got any evidence?
Four witnesses? No? Gather the stones.
She said was raised a Christian who had developed an interest in Islam.
Islamic female to the rescue
Sheik al-Hilaly yesterday said he would resign if an impartial panel found him guilty of inciting rape.
More islamic females on the jury? Direct incitement, no. Providing the cultural background and attitude behind it? Yes. Creating a culture of disrespect for non-Muslim women? yes. Blaming the victim for rape? yes.
Link


Down Under
Riot police at sheik's mosque
2006-11-02
RIOT police will be on hand during prayers at Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly's Sydney mosque today.

The sheik has called on his faithful to join him for Friday prayers at Lakemba Mosque for his first public appearances since being rushed to hospital with chest pains on Monday.

Police have already closed the road outside the mosque in western Sydney in anticipation of the thousands of supporters expected to gather before prayers begin at 1pm (AEDT).

Large numbers of police, including riot police, will also be on hand.

Officers with bomb-sniffer dogs had been through the mosque, which has been covered in flowers from the sheik's supporters.

The mufti will speak at the prayers and his appearance is expected to promote a strong display of loyalty from supporters galvanised by calls for his resignation.

The sheik, one of the country's most senior Muslim clerics, has been under fire from sections of his own community as well as others over a sermon he gave last month in which he suggested immodestly dressed women invited sexual assault.

Thousands of Muslims had been marshalled to attend a rally in Lakemba tomorrow but the sheik, speaking on Voice of Islam Radio in Sydney yesterday urged them not to attend.

Clerics had tried to stop the unofficial demonstration, which they feared could degenerate into chaos. Some are worried it could prompt a repeat of the violence of last year's Cronulla riot.

The groundswell of support for the sheik gained more momentum when senior clerics and imams joined dozens of Muslim community groups in backing him yesterday.

A statement signed by 34 Muslim community groups accused the media and politicians of exaggerating the scandal and using it to vilify Australian Muslims.

Link


Down Under
Hilaly 'refuses to be silenced'
2006-11-02
BESIEGED Muslim cleric Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly is expected to make his first public appearance since his dramatic collapse by attending Friday prayers tomorrow. As the controversial cleric yesterday checked out of Canterbury Hospital in Sydney and into a private hospital to continue recuperating, the Islamic community was abuzz with speculation he will attend Lakemba Mosque tomorrow.

"The plan was to keep him there for two weeks and after that get airline tickets for him to go to Saudi Arabia (for Haj)."
It comes as The Daily Telegraph can reveal supporters of the lunatic firebrand cleric had concocted a plan to have the Mufti moved to a farm at Goulburn while they "ride the wave" of public outcry following publication of his controversial sermon likening women to uncovered meat. "The plan was to keep him there for two weeks and after that get airline tickets for him to go to Saudi Arabia (for Haj)," former confidant Dr Jamal Rifi revealed yesterday.

The two men have had a major falling out since the reporting of the mufti's controversial comments even though Sheik Hilaly had sought Mr Rifi's opinion the night before the damaging remarks were made public. Dr Rifi said the Sheik had met at his home from 11pm (AEDT) seeking his opinion on how to handle any fall-out.
"Eminence, they are out there to get you and you have to be extremely careful!"
"I told him 'Your Corpulence Eminence, they are out there to get you and you have to be extremely careful'," Dr Rifi said. "It's not like before - this time is very serious and has created a big rift and you have to be careful."

But Dr Rifi said their plan to "ride the wave" was blown after Islamic Friendship Association president Keysar Trad organised for a television crew to interview the mufti in his sick bed. He said the mufti then reneged on a promise not to make any more public statements by attending Lakemba Mosque last Friday and delivering a "fiery" speech.

Sheik Hilaly's daughter Asma said yesterday the family was hopeful the 65-year-old would address worshippers and make a public statement tomorrow. "When he comes out, he'll probably be speaking to the media to put an end to all of this talk about him," Ms Hilaly told The Daily Telegraph.

Despite taking infinite indefinite leave from preaching, the mufti can deliver a sermon tomorrow if he wants to. "If he wants to do a speech on the day, he will," Lebanese Muslim Association president Tom Zreika said.
When you're a mufti, your seniority supersedes everyone else.
"When you're a mufti, you're superior to mere mortals your seniority supersedes everyone else. If the mufti says he wants to talk and you're the guy who's about to hold the sermon, you can't tell him to piss off say no. You would move aside and let him talk," he said. "Or else he'd turn you into a pillar of salt."

Supporters of the mufti yesterday accused worshippers from a rival mosque of trying to discredit him.That was yesterday denied by Bankstown mosque Imam Sheik Ibrahim El-Safie who said: "It's a stunt to deviate the attention away from the inflammatory remarks he's made." Sheik Safie said his group Darulfatwa - the Islamic Council of Australia - does not consider Sheik Hilaly to be the most-senior Muslim in the country. He said the title went to their mufti, Sheik Salim Alwan, chairman of Darulfatwa.
"Our guy's a lot holier," he added.
Link


Down Under
Muslims plan rally in support of Hilaly
2006-10-31
MEMBERS of Sydney's Islamic community sent thousands of text messages urging a non-violent rally yesterday as former prime minister Malcolm Fraser accused the Government of using Muslims as an election issue.

The text messages called for a show of support this Saturday for embattled cleric Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly. One described the planned rally as "a critical day to show our solidarity and to silence the hypocrites!"

The barrage of text and email messages came as the sheik's family confirmed he would not be stepping down as Mufti of Australia despite the outrage caused by his remarks about the victims of rape.

Sheik Hilaly's daughter Asma Hilaly said her father had simply taken temporary sick leave from his duties at Lakemba mosque after collapsing on Monday.

"He will not step down. He's always been strong. Strong, tall and defiant and none of this will shake him and bring him down," the 25-year-old said outside Canterbury Hospital.

She said her father – who is expected to remain in hospital for at least another two days – still planned to travel to Mecca in the next few weeks.

Former prime minister Malcolm Fraser accused the Howard Government of fuelling an "increase in fear and concern over the followers of Islam", The Age newspaper reported.

"There are already suggestions that this next election will be a 'Muslim election', as a while ago it was the Tampa election," he said.

"It would create a terrible and unnecessary divide between Islam and the rest of the community."

Many Muslims, wary of public perception, said they wanted to ensure any rally in support of Sheik Hilaly was peaceful and did not turn into a "flag burning" by an angry mob.

One message sender feared a repeat of the scenes at the Lakemba mosque on the night of the Cronulla riots, when fights broke out during a rally.

"Last thing we need is another display like what was seen outside Lakemba mosque on the night of the riots," the message implored.

Lebanese Muslim Association president Tom Zreika said last night the rally had not been officially organised by the association and "mixed messages" were being sent about what day the protest would take place.

"We will get some protesters on Friday coming up to Lakemba mosque and chanting for him (Sheik Hilaly) to come back," Mr Zreika said.

"Friday is our Sabbath so it's more likely to be then."

Other messages called on Muslims to support their besieged cleric at a protest at Parry Park near Lakemba Mosque on Saturday at 1pm.

Mr Zreika is urging that any show of support for Shiek Hilaly be in a peaceful manner.

Messages

Emails and text messages, referred to in a Muslim Village Australia website forum, calling on Muslims to support besieged Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly at Saturday's protest:

"THIS SMS has been spreading everywhere: Get Prepared! Peaceful protest in support of Mufti Al-Hilaly at Parry Park this Saturday at 1pm. This is a critical day to show our solidarity and to silence the hypocrites!"

"I WOULD like it to be an organised rally not just a gathering of angry, hot-headed Muslims shouting slogans, burning flags or other symbols etc"

"DEFINITELY keep it organised. Last thing we need is another display like what was seen outside Lakemba mosque on the night of the riots. A lot of the troublemakers weren't even Muslim, and were there just for the fights and trouble and then it becomes all about 'look at the trouble the Muslims are causing' instead of 'Muslims speak out in support of Shk Taj'"

"(THE rally must be) a message of unwavering support to our Shaykh and a show of strength that our community will not be forced to please the wishes of our fascist government."

Another member of the forum asked:

"IS this being organised by someone? Or is this (SMS) just being circulated by individuals? I think it would be much better if any rally is done professionally and in an organised manner."

The same forum member said it was important volunteer stewards were at the rally to:

"ENSURE no one steps out of line (no flag-burning etc)... The event itself will send a message that the Muslim community is strong, organised and united and will not be intimidated by the media or the politicians."
Link


Down Under
Sheik blasts judges over rapists
2006-10-30
THE leader of Australia's most radical Islamic group has fueled the Taj al-Din al-Hilaly controversy by accusing Australian judges of discriminating against Muslim rapists.

As Sheik Hilaly yesterday took "indefinite leave" from preaching after a "heart attack", The Australian can reveal Melbourne cleric Sheik Mohammed Omran told his flock on Friday that rapes committed by Australian non-Muslims - such as "bikies" or "football stars" - were treated more leniently than those committed by Muslims.

"I feel there is no justice here. Not 60 years and someone else three years and they did the same crime. Why?" Sheik Omran told worshipers at his Brunswick mosque.

"They make a big fuss about these kids because one of them, his name is Mohamed. Even if you kill someone you don't go for 60 years," he said, referring to Sydney's 2000 gang rapes in which Lebanese Muslim Bilal Skaf was initially sentenced to 55 years jail, but later had the sentence reduced on appeal.

"This is where I think everything has gone unbalanced," Sheik Omran said. "We don't support criminals or crimes, but at same time we want justice for everyone."

Sheik Omran strongly defended the besieged mufti, who until yesterday had defiantly resisted demands from Muslims and the wider community to step aside for likening women to uncovered meat and suggesting rape victims should be held responsible for enticing attackers.

Soon after arriving at Lakemba Mosque yesterday morning for another crisis meeting over the Ramadan sermon that prompted the furore when it was revealed by The Australian last week, Sheik Hilaly collapsed and was rushed to hospital.

In a statement issued in his name later, Sheik Hilaly - who came under more pressure yesterday when The Australian also uncovered recent comments supporting military jihad against US and Australian forces in Iraq and Afghanistan - said he would step aside.

"The pressure of the last couple of days has had an obvious effect on my health and wellbeing," the statement said.

"I ask the public to give my family and I some privacy, time and space to recover. I have also asked for indefinite leave from duties at Lakemba Mosque."

The decision came as the federal Opposition demanded that the Government investigate whether Sheik Hilaly's support of jihad in Iraq and Afghanistan constituted treason and John Howard repeated his advice to Muslims to overthrow their spiritual leader.

"One of the things that does bother me is that when he goes overseas he carries the title of Mufti of Australia and that represents to the world a view of Australian Islam which I feel very uncomfortable with," the Prime Minister said.

Sheik Hilaly - in an interview on Arabic radio a fortnight ago - had also praised Egyptian philosopher Sayyid Qutb, the intellectual mentor of Osama bin Laden.

And yesterday Immigration Department chief Andrew Metcalfe sought advice from the Prime Minister's office and intelligence agencies about whether he could discuss his knowledge of a 1984 intelligence report warning that Sheik Hilaly had links to extremist groups.

Mr Metcalfe said he had a "personal knowledge" of the matter because he was working with the department in a legal capacity at the time.

The intelligence report was provided to the department six years before Sheik Hilaly was granted permanent residency.

A former Australian secret agent has alleged the report was shelved because of the importance of the ethnic vote to the Labor Party, which was then in government.

The Weekend Australian revealed that Hawke government immigration minister Chris Hurford tried to have Sheik Hilaly deported in 1986.

But senior party figures including treasurer Paul Keating and MP Leo McLeay, whose electorate included the Lakemba Mosque, opposed the move, allegedly for political gain.

When asked about his knowledge of the intelligence report yesterday, Mr Metcalfe said he had "knowledge as to the answer of that question" but was concerned about revealing it because it could breach matters of privacy, national intelligence and protocol surrounding the decisions of a previous government.

Sheik Omran, one of the country's most outspoken and controversial fundamentalist clerics, said on Friday that attacks on Sheik Hilaly were attacks on Islam.

"His name is a mufti and we should respect that name - we should respect the turban on his head," Sheik Omran said in the sermon, an audio copy of which was posted on his Ahlus Sunnah Wal-Jamaah Association website yesterday. "This is the sign of a scholar - you are not attacking Sheik Taj here, you are attacking the scholars, you are attacking Islam."

Sheik Omran has said bin Laden was a good man and the US, rather than the al-Qaeda leader, was behind the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001.
Link


Down Under
Sheik Hilaly rushed to hospital after collapsing in Mosque
2006-10-30
CONTROVERSIAL cleric Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly has been taken to hospital after fainting at Lakemba Mosque. NSW Police Inspector David Donohue said the sheik was taken to hospital shortly after 1pm (AEST). He did not know his condition but said officers accompanied him to hospital.
Sepsis?
More likely the vapors.
Outside the mosque, Lebanese Muslim Association president Tom Zreika would not confirm the sheik had fainted. He said that "due to unforeseen circumstances, we were unable to continue our private meeting" with the sheik. "He's okay," Mr Zreika said.

An AAP reporter at the mosque said officers drew an orange plastic tarpaulin across the driveway at the mosque to block the ambulance from the view of waiting media. It left through a through a rear entrance to the mosque.

Sheik Hilaly took ill late last week after sparking controversy over his comments in a sermon which compared immodestly dressed women to uncovered pieces of meat. He has a history of past medical trouble and suffers from asthma.
Link


Down Under
'To hell with the sheik' - Liberal MP
2006-10-29
SHEIK Taj al-Din al-Hilaly should be stripped of his permanent residency and kicked out of the country, a prominent Liberal backbencher said today.

Queensland Liberal MP Warren Entsch said he understood the cleric was only a permanent resident, not a citizen, and his invitation to remain in Australia should be rescinded.

The mufti of Australia is under pressure to step down after suggesting in a sermon that immodestly dressed women invited sexual assault.

"My first reaction is to hell with him," Mr Entsch said in Canberra.

"Having citizenship is an absolute privilege, so is residency, and if he wants to abuse that privilege than he should suffer the consequences.

"I'm not too sure what the legal ramifications are, whether the Government has the capacity to do that once it's granted, but I think it's something that should be considered.

"He shouldn't be here."

But Mr Entsch said he had taken heart that the mainstream Muslim community had quickly stood up against the sheik.

He said high-profile leaders were speaking against the cleric and making strong moves to have him step down.

"From what I've heard within the Muslim community they are certainly lining him up to do a lot more than an apology," he said.

"And it's good to see the moderates and more mainstream Muslims in the community actually taking this character on and telling him it's totally unacceptable in this country to be making the statements he is."

Liberal MP Cameron Thompson said the cleric should listen to the groundswell of people in the Islamic community asking him to step down.

"From where I sit he's long outlived his usefulness as an effective leader of that religion," Mr Thompson said.

Labor's deputy leader Jenny Macklin said the Muslim community should show leadership and make it clear the sheik's views were not acceptable.

"I think this man needs to be condemned for his lack of moral leadership," she said.
"He certainly should go, from my point of view."

Ms Macklin said Attorney-General Philip Ruddock should actively investigate whether Sheik Hilaly had broken any laws with his comments.
Link


Down Under
Clerics to discuss mufti's future
2006-10-29
SENIOR clerics will meet at Sydney's Lakemba Mosque tonight to discuss the future of controversial Muslim leader Sheik Taj al-Dina al-Hilaly - following public outcry over his comments comparing women to meat.

Lebanese Muslim Association spokesman Keysar Trad said the meeting would take place at the mosque in Sydney’s west from 9pm (AEST). "It is open to clerics who want to go, and they will be mostly from NSW," Mr Trad said.

Sheik Hilaly has said he will stand down if he is proved to have been deliberately offensive in his sermon that suggested women provoked sexual attacks. The sheik was widely criticised last week for comparing scantily clad women to uncovered meat.

Prime Minister John Howard today said he did not have the power to sack the Muslim leader, and could only call on those with power to resolve the issue. "The responsibility to resolve this matter sensibly rests with the Islamic community," he said. "I don't appoint him, I can't dismiss him.

"And there is no point in people in my position calling for this and that, other than to call upon those who have the power to resolve this matter, to resolve this matter in a way that promotes the interests of harmony in our community and promotes the view Islamic Australians are fully integrated into Australian society."

He said the Islamic community must hear what the rest of the Australian community was saying on the issue and asked them to "discharge their obligations as members of the Australian community". "If this matter is not properly handled by the Islamic community I am concerned that their failure to do so will do lasting damage to the perceptions of that community within the Australian community," Mr Howard said. "His remarks were totally unacceptable - full stop."

Meanwhile, Mr Howard said the Labor government at the time made a "blatantly political decision" to keep Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly in Australia in the late 1980s.

News Limited newspapers - parent company of News Interactive, publisher of NEWS.com.au - have said that Mr Keating and leading Labor figure Leo McLeay demanded in 1989 that then-immigration minister Robert Ray grant the sheik residency and were furious when he refused. It was the second time the party leaders had attempted to intervene on behalf of the sheik, according to Labor sources.

The sheik arrived in Australia in 1982 but did not gain residency until 1990. "But it's happened now and he has rights as an Australian citizen and those rights have to be respected," Mr Howard said.

Sheik Hilaly said he would not be attending the Multicultural Eid Festival and Fair to celebrate the end of the Islamic fasting month of Ramadan at Fairfield today. A spokesman for the sheik said he did not want his presence to take the focus off the festival itself.
Link


Down Under
Meeting to decide cleric's future
2006-10-29
MUSLIM leaders will decide on the future of controversial Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly tonight. Sheik Hilaly has said he will stand down if he is proved to have been deliberately offensive in his sermon that suggested women provoked sexual attacks.

A meeting of senior clerics and the Lebanese Muslim Association was planned for 9pm (AEDT) tonight at Lakemba Mosque, in Sydney's west, Lebanese Muslim Association spokesman Keysar Trad said today. "It is open to clerics who want to go, and they will be mostly from NSW," Mr Trad said.

Sheik Hilaly said he would not be attending the Multicultural Eid Festival and Fair to celebrate the end of the Islamic fasting month of Ramadan at Fairfield today. A spokesman for the sheik said he did not want his presence to take the focus off the festival itself. The sheik was widely criticised last week for comparing scantily clad women to uncovered meat.
Link


Down Under
Sheik al-Hilaly is here to stay
2006-10-27
AUSTRALIA'S senior Muslim cleric cannot be sacked or deported despite the outrage caused by him saying immodestly dressed women invite sexual attacks. Sheik Taj al-Din al-Hilaly yesterday “unreservedly” apologised for any offence caused to women by his comments, made in a Ramadan sermon last month. But he said he had been misunderstood and added: “I had only intended to protect women's honour from feral cats

The mufti of Australia and New Zealand was last night under intense pressure from within the Muslim community over the sermon in which he likened scantily-dressed women to uncovered meat eaten by animals.

Many Muslim leaders and groups yesterday distanced themselves from his remarks and some called for their religious figurehead to stand down. Five Muslim leaders at Gallipoli Mosque in Sydney's west said many Muslims were “sick and tired” of religious leaders like Sheik al-Hilaly claiming to speak on their behalf. “Whether he steps down or not, I think it's time for Australia's Muslim faith to have a religious leader who has a better understanding of Australian laws, Australian values, and the Australian way of life,” said Alia Karaman, one of three women in the group.

A former member of the Federal Government's Muslim Advisory board, Iktimal Hage-Ali, said she had listened to a recording of Sheik al-Hilaly’s speech and believed he should be stripped of his position. “I was just flabbergasted,” she told ABC radio.

Prime Minister John Howard labelled Sheik al-Hilaly’s comments “appalling and reprehensible”. “They are quite out of touch with contemporary values in Australia.

“The idea that women are to blame for rapes is preposterous.”

Federal Sex Discrimination Commissioner Pru Goward suggested the sheik be dumped or deported, saying: “I think it is time he left.”

But, as an Australian citizen, the mufti cannot be deported and in his position as Islam's most senior religious figure in Australia, he is not answerable to any organisation. The Egypt-born imam came to Australia in 1982 and cannot have his citizenship revoked.

He was appointed mufti by Australia's peak Islamic body, the Federation of Islamic Councils of Australia (FICA), 15 years ago, but no-one has the authority to sack him. “Nobody can sack him because it's not an elected position,” said Amir Ali, the chairman of the Prime Minister's Muslim Community Reference Group and immediate past president of FICA.
"Only another man holier than him can do it, and we don't have one of those."
The Lebanese Muslim Association (LMA) can withdraw his right to speak at Sydney's Lakemba Mosque, where he preaches, but has given him “the benefit of the doubt” until it reviews the tape of his contentious sermon.
Sheik al-Hilaly yesterday appeared badly affected by the backlash to his remarks, with a spokesman saying he was depressed and confined to bed all day, breathing with the assistance of an oxygen tank.
Link



Warning: Undefined property: stdClass::$T in /data/rantburg.com/www/pgrecentorg.php on line 132
-12 More