Warning: Undefined array key "rbname" in /data/rantburg.com/www/pgrecentorg.php on line 14
Hello !
Recent Appearances... Rantburg

India-Pakistan
IHC orders 
bullet-proof car for Pak ex-chief justice
2014-01-16
The Islamabad High Court on Wednesday directed the government to immediately provide a bullet-proof car to former chief justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry.
Why would a Chaudhry need a bullet-proof car in Pakiwakiland?
The government has been accused of dragging its feet on providing appropriate security to the former chief justice.

Last week the government accepted a court order and provided an old bullet-proof car to Justice Iftikhar but imposed condition that it will be used only for “official” purposes for three months and the former chief justice will be responsible for its maintenance. As a retired person, Justice Iftikhar has no official work to perform.

In his verdict on a petition filed by Sheikh Ahsanuddin, IHC’s Justice Shaukat Siddiqui said the former chief justice should be provided security on a par with former prime ministers.
Link


India-Pakistan
Musharraf ready to end diferences with Sharif
2011-04-18
ISLAMABAD — Former military ruler Gen. (retd) Pervez Musharraf has expressed his desire to sort out his differences with the Pakistan Muslim League chief Nawaz Sharif but says he has no regrets for toppling him in 1999.

“I would not mind if it happens for the good future of the country under my own terms of course,” he said in reply to a question in an interview with DawnNews from Dubai. He said he had not phoned Sharif to enquire after his health because his heart and mind did not allow him to do so in view of some statements by PML-N leaders.

When asked about warrants issued against him by an anti-terrorism court of Rawalpindi, Musharraf declined to comment on “these technical, legal questions”.

He said he would definitely return to Pakistan and did not fear going to jail, but “I am waiting for the proper time”.
When he or his bestest friends are back in power...
In reply to a question about a petition filed by former president Rafiq Tarar for withdrawal of Gen. Musharraf’s titles of president and other posts, he said Tarar was an “irrelevant person.”

He disclosed that when he was in power he had good relations with Tarar and had asked him to continue serving as president.

“Mr Tarar, who was actually a man of Mian Nawaz Sharif and his father, had played a key role in purchasing the loyalties of judges when Justice Sajjad Ali Shah was the chief justice of Pakistan.”

In reply to a question about Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry, he said that if he (Justice Iftikhar) could not hear cases against him, he should refer them to other judges. Musharraf said he had no regrets over the military coup of October 12, 1999, and the unconstitutional steps taken on November 3, 2007.
Link


India-Pakistan
Chaudhry: Armed forces must be subservient to civilian govt
2011-04-18
Sure. After he finished the generals applauded politely, sent him home and got back to doing whatever they were doing before he arrived.
ISLAMABAD — In an unusually candid speech to military officers, Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry has said that the armed forces of Pakistan must be subservient to the civilian administration.

Addressing the officers of Command and Staff College Quetta on their visit to the apex court, the chief justice blamed military interventions in politics for the stunted growth of democratic institutions and reminded the officers of their sworn oaths to preserve, protect and defend the constitution in addition to the frontiers of the nation.

“If we are to be recognised as a civilised nation in the world, then we must have supremacy of the constitution and the rule of law,” said the chief justice, in a speech that laid out the history of civil-military relations with unusual candour.

Chief Justice Iftikhar said the constitution itself manifestly states that all the executive and judicial authorities shall act in aid of the Supreme Court. The 1973 constitution introduced provisions pertaining to the command, oath and functions of the armed forces for the first time.

The armed forces’ role has been clearly defined in Article 245 of the constitution which envisages that the armed forces shall, under the federal government’s directions defend Pakistan against external aggression or threat of war, and, subject to law, act in aid of civil power when called upon to do so.
Which happens more than you might expect...
The chief justice went on to say that parliamentary subordination to a powerful executive had its roots in the weak political framework in the initial years.

“We did not have popularly or directly-elected legislatures from 1947 to 1970. This also retarded the political development of the state,” he added. But the chief justice also acknowledged the positive contributions of the military and its stature in the eyes of ordinary Pakistanis.

He said the Pakistan Army has been regarded over the years as a highly disciplined and trained force.
They haven't beaten anyone in a war, but they're highly disciplined and trained...
He blamed the military’s dominance of the polity of Pakistan as the primary cause of the public eventually questioning its role.
"If you guys can't win a war what good are you?"
The welfare of the people must be the supreme consideration of all institutions and all functionaries of the state, he added. He also cautioned against military ‘adventurism’ even as he praised the sacrifices of Pakistani soldiers to the cause of national security.
Link


India-Pakistan
Musharraf's Acts Declared Illegal
2009-08-01
Chaudhry's revenge, or more of the Pakistani version of 'waging law' ...
ISLAMABAD, Pakistan, July 31 -- Pakistan's Supreme Court ruled Friday that former president Pervez Musharraf violated the constitution by declaring emergency rule in 2007, a verdict widely viewed as a rebuke to the retired general's military regime.

The ruling, which prompted jubilant chants by the crowd in the packed courtroom, raises the possibility that the federal government could bring treason charges against Musharraf and further volatility to this unstable nation. The decision also invalidated judicial appointments made by Musharraf under a provisional constitution during the six weeks of emergency rule.

"I think this is a decision that has established independence for the judiciary in Pakistan," said Hamid Khan, former president of the Supreme Court Bar Association, who represented the group that filed a petition against the emergency order. "It will certainly be a boost for our democracy and will block the way for any future military adventurer."

Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari, an opponent of Musharraf, described the verdict in a statement as "most welcome" and "a triumph of the democratic principles, a stinging negation of dictatorship."

The verdict was delivered by Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry, who was sacked for the second time in November 2007, along with dozens of other judges, when Musharraf declared emergency rule, suspended the constitution, shut down television stations and imprisoned opponents. At the time, Musharraf justified his actions by citing growing extremism in the country, but many saw the actions as an attempt to ensure his political survival, given that court was deliberating whether to disqualify him from proceeding with a second five-year term.

Musharraf's moves fueled a protest movement of lawyers and civil society advocates that swept the country and brought about the reinstatement of the chief justice and other judges in March.

"After these two years of the movement, there's a change in the mindset of Pakistan. They do not want any military intervention. They want matters to be moving according to the constitution," said Athar Minallah, a leader of the lawyers' movement. "This will have far-reaching consequences," he added, referring to the decision.

Chaudhry delivered the verdict Friday evening in a 45-minute speech that the assembled crowd strained to hear over the rain that hammered down on the Supreme Court building's vaulted roof. But the words "illegal" and "unconstitutional" were heard frequently enough that the result was clear, and the crowd celebrated with chants of "long live the Supreme Court!" Television news footage showed people reveling in the streets in Pakistani cities.

The court did not invalidate the decisions made by the judges Musharraf appointed, but said their jobs no longer exist. It also said that Parliament should decide which laws passed under emergency rule would stand.

Musharraf, who now lives in London, stepped down in August 2008 after nearly nine years in power, facing the threat of impeachment. The Supreme Court summoned him to discuss the case this week, but neither he nor an attorney attended.

The federal government could now prosecute Musharraf, according to lawyers at the courthouse. Nazir Ahmed, a member of Britain's House of Lords who was present for Friday's verdict, said that evidence was being gathered in London on possible breaches of international law "relating to abductions, torture and war crimes committed by the former dictator."

Minallah, the activist lawyer, said, "If the people of this country want the prosecution of Musharraf, the entire pressure will shift to the Parliament and the federal government. So that will be the first impact of this decision."
Link


India-Pakistan
Zardari pays to end Pakistan crisis
2009-03-17
The promised reinstatement of Pakistan's chief justice defused a protest movement threatening the U.S.-allied government, but it could still spell trouble for the country's struggling president.

The army is said to have directed President Asif Ali Zardari to defuse the developing showdown with opposition leader Nawaz Sharif and lawyers leading a column of protesters toward the capital Sunday night. But by yielding to demands to restore judges fired by former military ruler and U.S. ally Pervez Musharraf, Zardari may have strengthened democracy in the nuclear-armed nation as it faces daunting security and economic challenges.

"Never before in Pakistan's political history have you had people standing up for the rule of law, for the constitution," said Nasim Zehra, a political and defense analyst. "Civil society has won out."

Musharraf ousted Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry in 2007 after he blocked a privatization deal, investigated the fate of hundreds of people allegedly held incognito by security agencies, and even questioned the legality of the ex-general's rule.

But the move backfired as lawyers, rights activists, liberal media pundits -- as well as the general's political opponents -- mounted a dogged campaign for an independent judiciary that turned the dour, mustachioed judge into an unlikely democratic icon.

The very same constellation has now humbled Zardari.
Link


India-Pakistan
Police Beat Up Lawyers at Rally
2008-09-05
So the Pakistani police aren't all bad ...
ISLAMABAD - Police resorted to a whiff of grape light baton charge to disperse a rally of leaders of bar associations and civil society activists converging here from across the country to demand restoration of deposed judges including chief justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry.

President of Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) Chaudhry Aitzaz Ahsan, who led the rally outside the Parliament House, rejected government’s move to invite judges to take fresh oath after reappointment though with previous seniority. He said the government action is illegal and can be challenged by new judges who claim to be senior to the reappointed judges under the constitution.

He said the lawyers would also not accept reinstatement of judges without Justice Iftikhar.

But the government said it recognised only current chief justice Hameed Dogar as legitimate head of the Supreme Court. Emphasising that there could not be two chief justices of the Supreme Court. Information Minister Sherry Rehman said Justice Dogar is the chief justice of entire Pakistan and not that of Asif Zardari as the lawyers are depicting him.

Attorney-General Latif Khosa said Zardari does not want to restore the chief justice. However, if he is invited to take fresh oath, he can work under Dogar and his seniority cannot be restored. He said it will be up to the government to invite any number of the deposed judges to take oath. Those who are not called or decline to take oath would be regarded as retired, he added.

Naek, talking to reporters outside the Parliament House, urged lawyers to terminate their agitation and let judges to take fresh oath. He said the government has extended old perks and seniority to all those who have agreed to take fresh oath.
Link


India-Pakistan
Pakistan's ruling coalition on verge of collapse
2008-08-24
Pakistan's ruling coalition teetered on the brink of collapse Saturday as the two main partners squabbled over a successor to ousted President Pervez Musharraf.

Former Prime Minster Nawaz Sharif, who heads the junior partner in the coalition, demanded the dominant Pakistan People's Party slash the president's powers before he would support its candidate.

Asif Ali Zardari, head of the PPP and widower of the party's assassinated leader Benazir Bhutto, agreed Saturday to run for the presidency.

Sharif also pushed forward the deadline for restoration of dozens of judges sacked by Musharraf -- another key issue dividing the two main parties since they forced the president from power less than a week ago.

Still pressure was building for the two sides to end differences that appeared increasingly irreconcilable.

Presidential elections by parliament were set for Sept. 6 and the political infighting is a distraction from militant violence flaring in the volatile northwest, where 37 insurgents were killed Saturday in retaliation for a string of deadly suicide bombings.

Though Zardari is a longtime Musharraf critic, he would likely continue the former general's support for the U.S.-led war against terrorism.

But Zardari's climb to power would dismay many in this nation of 160 million who view him as a symbol of corruption that tainted its last experiment with civilian rule in the 1990s.

He won the nickname "Mr. 10 Percent" for alleged graft during his wife's turns as prime minister.

Despite the backing of the PPP, his election is far from certain.

Sharif, who heads the second-largest party in parliament, was one of Bhutto's bitter rivals and has been threatening to bolt in a struggle over power.

He demanded after meeting with Zardiri's lieutenants Saturday that the PPP agree to sharply reduce the powers of the new president before he'd support their candidate.

Sharif wants the head of state to be deprived of the constitutional right to dissolve parliament or to appoint chiefs of the armed forces -- but Zardari's name was thrown into the race without any such guarantee.

Sharif, ousted by Musharraf during his 1999 coup, also pushed up a middle-of-the week deadline for the restoration of judges fired by Musharraf late last year to avoid challenges to the former strongman's rule.

He wants an agreement by Monday that all -- including former chief justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry -- will be back on the bench, saying a surprise Sept. 6 presidential election date forced him to push up his deadline.

Zardari, though he wants the judges reinstated, is not quite as enthusiastic. Like Musharraf, he has accused Chaudhry of being too political, and says it should be up to parliament to decide.

Analysts say he also might fear that the former chief justice would revive corruption cases killed off by Musharraf as part of a failed effort to form a pro-Western power-sharing deal with Bhutto before her assassination.

The PPP, fearing the loss of its coalition partner, has already started seeking support from other smaller parties.

The crisis comes as Pakistan is increasingly threatened by extremist violence.

The ruling coalition -- united primarily in their hatred of Musharraf -- dabbled in peace talks with the militants soon after taking power five months ago, something the former president briefly tried as well.

But after limited success, they have increasingly relied on military force to try to beat back al-Qaida and Taliban-linked insurgents in the remote and rugged tribal regions along the border with Afghanistan.

The militants have responded with force in recent days.

The Taliban claimed responsibility for one of the country's deadliest-ever terrorist attacks, a twin suicide bombing at a massive government weapons complex that killed 67 people and injured more than 100 on Thursday.

On Saturday, a car packed with explosives rammed into a police station in Swat, a former tourist destination, killing six officers and injuring several, said local police official Mohib Ullahn.

A roadside bomb in the nearby village of Bari Kot killed one civilian and injured four, said Muslim Khan, a spokesman for the Taliban militants, threatening more violence unless the army stops operations against them.
Link


India-Pakistan
Chaudhry still pining for his old job
2008-04-01
QUETTA, Pakistan - Pakistan’s deposed chief justice revved up his campaign to win back his old job while Cabinet ministers, some wearing black armbands, took their oath of office under protest from President Pervez Musharraf. Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry’s return to the political spotlight Monday and the pledge of the new government to restore judges fired by Musharraf crank up the pressure on the U.S.-backed leader to quit after eight years of sweeping power.

In a move that could ease Western concern that Pakistan will ease up on Islamic militancy, the winners of last month’s elections installed a British-educated loyalist of assassinated ex-leader Benazir Bhutto as foreign minister.

Musharraf dismissed Chaudhry and about 60 other senior judges during a burst of emergency rule in November to halt legal challenges to his re-election as president the previous month. But new Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani last week ordered the release of a man who has become a symbol of resistance to the former army strongman’s increasingly strong-armed rule.

On Monday, supporters carried baskets of rose petals to shower Chaudhry as he stepped into the arrivals hall at Quetta airport. In the baking sun outside, jubilant lawyers in stiff black suits chanted Go Musharraf go!” and Musharraf must go to jail!”

Bhutto’s party tapped Shah Mehmood Qureshi, the suave, Cambridge University-educated scion of a landowning family as the new foreign minister to face Western countries concerned that militants are regrouping along the Afghan border.

Qureshi said "good governance” should take priority over political rhetoric as the government settles into office. "I expect the international community to support democracy in Pakistan,” Qureshi told reporters after the swearing-in. "I am sure that the world community has accepted this change wholeheartedly.”
Link


India-Pakistan
Sharif has reservations about MQM joining coalition
2008-03-24
LAHORE — Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) chief Nawaz Sharif has reservations about the Muttahida Qaumi Movement’s plan to join hands with the four-party coalition to be set up at the centre. Sharif told reporters that he had reservations about the MQM which should be allayed by the relevant quarters.

The PML-N had hosted the all parties conference in London last July where all participants had said no party should form a coalition with the MQM in future because of the latter’s alleged role in the killings in Karachi on May 12 last year.

Some 50 people had been killed when deposed Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry went to Karachi to address lawyers, who were condemning a reference against him. The London APC had held the MQM responsible for the carnage and vowed not to cooperate with it in forming a government.
Link


India-Pakistan
Pakistan's PPP and PML-N to form coalition govt
2008-02-22
(Xinhua) — Pakistan's political parties Pakistan People's Party (PPP) and Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) will form coalition governments in central and provincial levels, leaders of the two parties said here Thursday night.

PPP co-chairman Asif Ali Zardari and PML-N leader Nawaz Sharif made the statement at a joint press conference after almost an hour of closed-door meeting here Thursday night. "I have requested Nawaz Sharif to be a part of that government," Zardari told the media. "We are looking for a broader national consensus government," Zardari said. "We intend to be together in our struggle for democracy," Zardari said, adding that "We intend to remain together in the parliament."

Regarding the stance towards President Perez Musharraf, Sharif said that "the sooner the president respects the will of the people the better."

Analysts say the coalition of PPP and PML-N will bring great challenge to Musharraf, who in 1999 seized power in a coup. "We have agreed to restore the 1973 Constitution in its original form," Sharif said.

Zardari also said the PPP's first resolution in the National Assembly will be a request for the United Nations probe into the assassination of former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto.

Bhutto was killed in gunshots and suicide bombing attacks at the gate of the Liaqat Bagh park in Rawalpindi where she addressed an election rally on Dec. 27 last year.

Sharif and Zardari also agreed to reinstate the judges Musharraf sacked last year. "In principle, there is no disagreement on restoration of deposed judges," Sharif said.

Sharif said earlier Thursday that the deposed former chief justice of Pakistan Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry would be reinstated within days.

The lawyers took out to the street in Islamabad and tried to march to the residence of Chaudhry. They chanted slogans against President Perez Musharraf and demanded restoration of Chaudhry. Chaudhry was sacked on Nov. 3 last year when Musharraf declared a state of emergency in the country. He remained under house arrest ever since.
Link


India-Pakistan
Saudi Arabia ready to 'broker exile deal' with sacked chief justice
2007-12-09
(AKI) - (by Syed Saleem Shahzad) - Saudi Arabia is ready to offer Pakistan's sacked chief justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry, shelter in the kingdom, Pakistani government sources told Adnkronos International (AKI). High-level sources told AKI, on condition of anonymity, that this was discussed when the Saudi Ambassador to Pakistan, Ali Awaz Al Asiri, called on the deposed chief justice at his residence in the capital Islamabad on Friday. They said that the meeting was set up by the Pakistani government.

Al Asiri is believed to have invited Chaudhry and his family to make the Haj or Muslim pilgrimage to the holy city of Mecca in Saudi Arabia, this year. The Haj is scheduled to take place this month. Al Asiri is also believed to have offered Chaudhry and his family a prolonged stay in Saudi Arabia. Sources within the Saudi consulate in Karachi, on the condition of anonymity, also confirmed to AKI the offer of shelter to Chaudhry and said that the government of Saudi Arabia had tried to bring stability to Pakistan.

Chaudhry was sacked as chief justice after President Pervez Musharraf declared a state of emergency in Pakistan on 3 November, citing rising extremism and an unruly judiciary. The former head of the Supreme Court was placed under house arrest. While opposition leader and former prime minister Nawaz Sharif was prevented from meeting Chaudhry on Thursday, just a day later Al Asiri was allowed to meet him.

It is believed that the potential deal would help break the deadlock within opposition parties who are divided on whether to contest the January general elections if the sacked judges are not reinstated. A Saudi-brokered deal would be a face-saving gesture for Chaudhry and the entire opposition who need to deal with Musharraf's government and also support an independent judiciary to gain public support.
Link


India-Pakistan
Musharraf aides say he'll announce end to emergency rule
2007-11-29
Aides to President Pervez Musharraf said today that a date for lifting his nearly 4-week-old emergency decree could be announced as early as Thursday, the same day he takes office as civilian president. Musharraf's inauguration to a new five-year presidential term is a purposeful display of what he and his allies say has been a long-intended transition to civilian rule. Opponents, though, consider Musharraf's new term to be tainted by the fact that he was military ruler when the vote was held, and by the fact that the balloting was endorsed by a new Supreme Court seeded with loyalists.

Two senior Pakistani officials, speaking on condition of anonymity, said language on lifting the state of emergency had been incorporated into the text of a speech Musharraf is to deliver to the nation Thursday, hours after the inaugural ceremony. Dawn News, the country's main English-language news channel, said the state of emergency could end in the next 48 hours. The Pakistani leader, however, often instructs his senior lieutenants to circulate word of planned actions well before he intends to carry them out. Before Musharraf stepped down today as army chief of staff, fulfilling a long-standing pledge, target dates were repeatedly announced and then ignored.

Even if an end to the emergency decree is announced, opponents doubt that Musharraf will reverse what has emerged as the centerpiece of the decree: his firing of Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry and other high court justices and senior judges. The Pakistani leader has repeatedly ruled out their reinstatement. Some other provisions of the decree have already been eased. The government says all but a few dozen opposition activists rounded up in the wake of the declaration have been freed, though human rights groups say they cannot verify that claim.
Link



Warning: Undefined property: stdClass::$T in /data/rantburg.com/www/pgrecentorg.php on line 132
-12 More