You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
McFaul pretends to be an idiot by asking stupid questions
2023-01-01
Direct Translation via Google Translate. Edited.

Commentary by Russian military blogger Andrey Chervonets

How did an American diplomat manage to graduate from university with absolutely no knowledge of history?

Are the British indigenous to Nigeria? And the French in Algeria? Portuguese in Angola? The countries mentioned by McFaul are far from each other, do not have common borders, and people have fundamentally different cultures. And Nigeria has not bombed the indigenous population of Britain for 8 years.
A sensible start...
And the Russians in Ukraine are the indigenous people who have lived there for centuries. This is RUSSIAN LAND, for centuries. And without any colonialism. And the Ukrainians themselves are Russians. Eastern Ukraine is 80% ethnic Russians even now, when Ukrainians are singled out.
....and then he goes off the rails and falls into the ravine canyon.
Rather, I compare the situation as if Bavaria had separated from modern Germany and they would begin to call themselves Bavarians, opposing themselves to the Germans, developing German sentiments in the country. Plus, they would begin to develop Nazi ideology in Bavaria, sing songs "our father is Hitler, and Bavaria is our mother." What would Michael call it???
European Conservative might have some thoughts, were Berlin to start bombing Munich.
And why is McFaul silent about Israel in his examples?
What has Israel to do with anything?
How about the war in North Korea, the war in Vietnam, the invasion of Cuba, Panuma,
...is that supposed to be Panama?
Yugoslavia, Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria? How about the fact that the Americans drove warships far and wide many thousands of kilometers from their coast, but close to the coast of China? Or is it "do you not understand this other thing?"

Yes, and about something else significant, Michael modestly "kept silent" and "did not notice." These are extensions of the influence of the extremely hostile Alliance near the borders of Russia.
Posted by:badanov

#6  Of course nothing what this Russian author claims about Ukraine matters: Ukraine is a sovereign country and has been recognized as such by Russia.
Posted by: European Conservative   2023-01-01 16:34  

#5  Duchy of Bavaria under the Merovingians — sixth century, carved out of a couple of Roman provinces. Thank you, European Conservative — I thought you might enjoy that.
Posted by: trailing wife   2023-01-01 16:24  

#4  ..blink
Posted by: Procopius2k   2023-01-01 16:19  

#3  "Rather, I compare the situation as if Bavaria had separated from modern Germany and they would begin to call themselves Bavarians, opposing themselves to the Germans, developing German sentiments in the country. Plus, they would begin to develop Nazi ideology in Bavaria, sing songs "our father is Hitler, and Bavaria is our mother." What would Michael call it???"

Oh dear. The Bavarians have called themselves Bavarians for more than a thousand years. Bavaria was already a state before Russia even existed.

It's always embarrassing if you try to give history lessons to others if you don't know shit about history yourself.

"Eastern Ukraine is 80% ethnic Russians even now, when Ukrainians are singled out."

Indeed. Bavaria would be quite flat without mountains.
Posted by: European Conservative   2023-01-01 15:50  

#2  How did an American diplomat manage to graduate from university with absolutely no knowledge of history?

Trick question, right?
Posted by: Procopius2k   2023-01-01 07:24  

#1  This "who speaks what where" business was supposed to be resolved by Esperanto...
Posted by: M. Murcek   2023-01-01 00:25  

00:00