You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Great White North
Syria won't co-operate with Arar inquiry
2004-07-05
Syria has turned down a request from the Maher Arar inquiry for assistance in unravelling the circumstances of the Ottawa man's arrest and deportation. The decision could make it tougher to get to the bottom of how and why Ottawa resident Arar wound up in a Syrian prison as a terrorism suspect. In its refusal to provide information, Syria cited the lack of an overall agreement with Canada with respect to legal co-operation, said Paul Cavalluzzo, commission counsel for the inquiry. "We were certainly hoping that the Syrian government would co-operate," he told reporters Monday. "My own view is that they could co-operate, with or without an agreement."
If their view is that they won't, you're up the creek, aren't you?
The Foreign Affairs Department also said the absence of a treaty should not preclude sharing of information with the inquiry. Syria's decision came as parties to the investigation tussled at hearings Monday over ground rules for deciding how much information about Arar's case will be disclosed publicly. Arar, a Syrian-born Canadian citizen, was detained in New York on suspicions of terrorism in September 2002. The telecommunications engineer, travelling on a Canadian passport, was subsequently deported to Syria by U.S. authorities after a stop in Jordan. Arar says he was tortured for months by Syrian officials before being released. He denies any involvement in terrorism.

Earlier this year, the federal government appointed Justice Dennis O'Connor to lead an inquiry into the case. The inquiry had asked Syria, Jordan and the United States to help the commission piece together details of the affair. Formal letters were sent to the three countries by diplomatic pouch last month via Foreign Affairs. Cavalluzzo said the inquiry will work on its own to corroborate statements made about Arar by Syrian officials. "We'll have to do that through other means, and we will." Officials at the Syrian Embassy in Ottawa were not immediately available.
Posted by:Fred

#3  wow - this'll be pretty hard to hang on the Joooos; Although I'm sure they'll give it the ol' Arab try....
Posted by: Frank G   2004-07-06 12:07:26 AM  

#2  From what I've read on this case, the Canadian intelligence department [CSIS] provided the US with the "goods" on this guy-the RCMP had been monitoring him for quite some time. The RCMP and CSIS in Canada did not want the US to return Arar to Canada, because they knew he'd get his walking papers if he was returned to Canada. So because Arar was a dual citizen-Arar had never renounced his Syrian citizenship[interesting], the US sent him back to Syria to be put in the deep freeze for a while. Actually I don't think Syria was a "bad guy" in this scenario-they just threw him in the slammer because neither Canada not the US wanted him back and they didn't want a suspected loose cannon on their streets. Then Arar's family got the Muslim community beating the PM's door down, and Paul Martin, as Chretien had done before him, pretended that this was done without the PMO's knowledge, initially blaming it on the USA, but then a journalist with the National Post came across some secret dossierres that demonstrated that both PM's had been kept in the loop all along and had approved the CSIS and RCMP decision. The Liberal Party of Canada counts heavily on the Muslim vote, so Paul Martin was very nervous about his office being linked to approving Arar being deported to Syria. I'll bet Paul Martin is very happy that Syria is refusing to co-operate with Canada's investigation hearing.
Posted by: rex   2004-07-05 11:43:17 PM  

#1  My supposition is that we were pretty sure that this guy was a terrorist. Deporting a terrorist to Canada is Akin to playing with a jet black boomerang on a football field at 2 am on an overcast night.
Posted by: Super Hose   2004-07-05 11:13:26 PM  

00:00